This recipe made me an overnight oats believer. I added coconut flakes and a few chocolate chips to make it an afternoon sweet treat. DELICIOUS. I send this recipe to all of my clients! (Well I send every well plated recipe to my clients.) Dietitian approved!!
I’ve made this for months. I prefer it with quick cooking oats (I find the texture closer to steel cut than rolled). Thanks for the recipe! I love to eat it with a sliced banana, chopped apple, or, berries and nuts when I have them. Thanks for a great recipe!
I really appreciate all of these healthy recipes because that is exactly what I want for my family, but please provide options to the Greek yogurt, as we are dairy-free. Thank you.
Hi Olga! I’m sorry but I’m not dairy free so I don’t normally tested my recipes this way. Feel free to try and use whatever you normally use in place of yogurt. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Can this recipe be made as an overnight oatmeal cooked in a crockpot like your banana bread overnight oatmeal crockpot recipe? I’m not a fan of cold oatmeal for breakfast.
This recipe is absolutely amazing, could not believe how good it was and that the apples were not mushy or brown. Topped with some applesauce I had in the fridge for a little extra sweetness.
This is a great recipe. I also use it as a base for other additions (substitution of dairy yogurt for nut based yogurt), pumpkin, and blueberries. Super yummy with blueberries (leave out the apples) and the addition of pumpkin purée with the apples is what I like to call “Fall in a jar”! Enjoy!
I haven’t made this recipe yet but I plan to and I know it will be great. My only change will be to increase the oats to my usual measure of 1/2 cup. My comment tonight is about overnight oats in general. I do make them frequently but I have never liked them cold. I put them in the microwave for long enough to warm them and enjoy my breakfast. I never bought the idea that overnight in the fridge means eat them cold.
I am new to overnight oats – what a delicious and nutritious breakfast! Easy to prep the night before, prep two to use the whole apple. I subbed whole seed for chia b/c that’s what I had, apple spice mix for the spices and used oat milk. Yum! This will be my go-to breakfast this summer with berries/vanilla variation, apple/spice and whatever fruit is in season. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
I tried this recipe for me and the hubby with the chia seed substitution, but it did not work well as the last ingredient in the layers. I checked the texture before going to bed, after 1 1/2-2 hours, and they had not started softening at all, so I pushed them into the yogurt some. Next morning they had softened some but not swelled up like the chia pudding recipe, even after stirring and sitting for another hour. I think next time chia seeds need to go in with the oats, and maybe with more milk to yogurt ratio. I did wonder about whole seeds vs flaxseed meal.
Hi Theresa, I found that keeping them at the top works best for the oats’ texture and also keeps the apples from becoming too mushy. But you can stir them in, that would be fine if you prefer to do it that way! Thanks!
Well, I learned a valuable lesson—to follow the instructions regarding the order in which the ingredients are listed. Once I did that, it was very easy to make and delicious. I added protein powder to mine.
These oats are great! Having crunchy pieces of apple through every bite is genius – if you’re not totally sold on the texture of overnight oats this might be the recipe for you. I love stirring through some almond butter when I’m ready to eat – makes it over the top good!!
If you try the chia seed substitution, don’t expect them to swell up like they would in a chia pudding. The yoghurt doesn’t have that much moisture for them to absorb, and in fact acts like a buffer to stop them soaking up all the milk that’s meant for the oats. I end up with a few dry chia seeds on top each time – just stir them through when you’re ready to eat and it’s the last thing you’ll notice.
Perhaps you can confirm this, but if I diced the apples and put them in the container with the rest of the ingredients one in the apples, just a crunchy and crisp? i’m thinking about trying this one, but I’d rather cook the apples first so that they’re soft and non crunchy and then put it in the jar with the other ingredients in the order you specified.
The flavor was good, but I would definitely make some changes if I make this again. Layering the oats without stirring left the oats too dry and some felt completely raw. It was hard to mix in the morning, and felt like there wasn’t quite enough liquid to actually shake it up. If I were to try it again, I’d definitely stir before putting it in the fridge, and maybe add a little more milk.
This recipe made me an overnight oats believer. I added coconut flakes and a few chocolate chips to make it an afternoon sweet treat. DELICIOUS. I send this recipe to all of my clients! (Well I send every well plated recipe to my clients.) Dietitian approved!!
Hi Taylor! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I’ve made this for months. I prefer it with quick cooking oats (I find the texture closer to steel cut than rolled). Thanks for the recipe! I love to eat it with a sliced banana, chopped apple, or, berries and nuts when I have them. Thanks for a great recipe!
Hi Joy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I really appreciate all of these healthy recipes because that is exactly what I want for my family, but please provide options to the Greek yogurt, as we are dairy-free. Thank you.
Hi Olga! I’m sorry but I’m not dairy free so I don’t normally tested my recipes this way. Feel free to try and use whatever you normally use in place of yogurt. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Most (Not all) grocery stores now carry almond milk yogurt as any dairy free option for yogurt…
Thanks for the tip Tonya!
You can also make overnight oats without the yogurt.
Great tip, thanks Mary!
Can this recipe be made as an overnight oatmeal cooked in a crockpot like your banana bread overnight oatmeal crockpot recipe? I’m not a fan of cold oatmeal for breakfast.
I’m sure you could. It would be easy to adapt the flavors of the oatmeal. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!
So you eat this cold?
Hi V! Yes, you would typically eat it cold, but I know some people like to heat theirs up.
This recipe is absolutely amazing, could not believe how good it was and that the apples were not mushy or brown. Topped with some applesauce I had in the fridge for a little extra sweetness.
Hi Morgan! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
My favorite ON apple oats!
Hi Elaine! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Can I substitute steel cut oats?
Hi Mary! You likely could! Here is my steel cut oats version: https://www.wellplated.com/overnight-steel-cut-oats-recipe/ ENJOY!
So weird. I clicked on your recipe after searching apples cinnamon overnight oats and see my name pop up….I was so confused for a minute! Lol
Hope you enjoy them Erin!
This is a great recipe. I also use it as a base for other additions (substitution of dairy yogurt for nut based yogurt), pumpkin, and blueberries. Super yummy with blueberries (leave out the apples) and the addition of pumpkin purée with the apples is what I like to call “Fall in a jar”! Enjoy!
Hi Molly! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I haven’t made this recipe yet but I plan to and I know it will be great. My only change will be to increase the oats to my usual measure of 1/2 cup. My comment tonight is about overnight oats in general. I do make them frequently but I have never liked them cold. I put them in the microwave for long enough to warm them and enjoy my breakfast. I never bought the idea that overnight in the fridge means eat them cold.
Enjoy Diane!
My almost 2 year old daughter LOVES these oats exactly as is and I do too! Thank you ☺️
Yay! Glad to hear, Vanessa!
Sooooo good! New staple!!
Yay! Thank you Alicia!
I am new to overnight oats – what a delicious and nutritious breakfast! Easy to prep the night before, prep two to use the whole apple. I subbed whole seed for chia b/c that’s what I had, apple spice mix for the spices and used oat milk. Yum! This will be my go-to breakfast this summer with berries/vanilla variation, apple/spice and whatever fruit is in season. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
Great to hear, thank you Anke!
I tried this recipe for me and the hubby with the chia seed substitution, but it did not work well as the last ingredient in the layers. I checked the texture before going to bed, after 1 1/2-2 hours, and they had not started softening at all, so I pushed them into the yogurt some. Next morning they had softened some but not swelled up like the chia pudding recipe, even after stirring and sitting for another hour. I think next time chia seeds need to go in with the oats, and maybe with more milk to yogurt ratio. I did wonder about whole seeds vs flaxseed meal.
Hi Theresa, I found that keeping them at the top works best for the oats’ texture and also keeps the apples from becoming too mushy. But you can stir them in, that would be fine if you prefer to do it that way! Thanks!
So good, easy to prep for busy mornings.
Thanks Kristina!
Well, I learned a valuable lesson—to follow the instructions regarding the order in which the ingredients are listed. Once I did that, it was very easy to make and delicious. I added protein powder to mine.
Great to hear, thank you Jen!
These oats are great! Having crunchy pieces of apple through every bite is genius – if you’re not totally sold on the texture of overnight oats this might be the recipe for you. I love stirring through some almond butter when I’m ready to eat – makes it over the top good!!
If you try the chia seed substitution, don’t expect them to swell up like they would in a chia pudding. The yoghurt doesn’t have that much moisture for them to absorb, and in fact acts like a buffer to stop them soaking up all the milk that’s meant for the oats. I end up with a few dry chia seeds on top each time – just stir them through when you’re ready to eat and it’s the last thing you’ll notice.
So glad you enjoyed it, Eleanor! Thank you!
Perhaps you can confirm this, but if I diced the apples and put them in the container with the rest of the ingredients one in the apples, just a crunchy and crisp? i’m thinking about trying this one, but I’d rather cook the apples first so that they’re soft and non crunchy and then put it in the jar with the other ingredients in the order you specified.
Hi Jean, the apples stay crisp, you could definitely cook them. Hope you enjoy!
The flavor was good, but I would definitely make some changes if I make this again. Layering the oats without stirring left the oats too dry and some felt completely raw. It was hard to mix in the morning, and felt like there wasn’t quite enough liquid to actually shake it up. If I were to try it again, I’d definitely stir before putting it in the fridge, and maybe add a little more milk.
Glad you were still able to enjoy the flavor, Taryn!
Do you have a favorite plain greek yogurt? I’m having trouble finding one I like.
Hi Rose, Chobani, Fage, Stonyfield are all good ones.