• Looks delicious! Can I Omit the walnuts in the topping? Also, I want to make it dairy free. I will be using soymilk instead of milk. Can I use oil instead of the softened butter?

    1. Hi! While I appreciate your needing to make the cake dairy free, I’m afraid the changes you suggested would alter the flavor and texture of the cake. You can easily omit the walnuts (or swap them for a different nut such as pecans), but canola oil can’t be swapped for butter with the same results, since it is a liquid and can’t be creamed with the sugar the way softened butter can, so it will change the texture of the cake. I’d suggest swapping a dairy-free or soy butter instead. I’ve never tried the cake this way, but I think that would give you better results than canola oil. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to hear how it turns out!

    2. Hi! This looks amazing! However, I’m having trouble finding whole wheat white flour! Can I substitute with more all purpose flour?

  • I’ve made this 3 times in the last month. I didn’t have walnuts so substituted pecans but it was still incredibly delicious. Thank you!

    1. Melanie! that is fantastic news!! I bet it was great with pecans too. THANK YOU for trying it and sharing this lovely review.

  • I’ve made this Apple cake three times (twice for the same person who personally requested it) and people love it!. I don’t have a 9″ pan so I use an 8″ and make a couple of muffins with the left over batter. Mine also comes out much darker than in your photos. Not sure why as it takes a shorter time to cook.

    This last time, the batter was sooooo thick and the only difference is that I used an electric hand mixer (instead of a good old wooden spoon) and I weighed all the ingredients. It’s turned out really tough! This makes me sad.

    Thanks for the recipe! Next time I’ll get it perfect.

    1. Hi Kate! Thank you so much for leaving a review. I’m happy to hear you’re making the recipe and people are loving it! Oven temperatures can vary, and the type of pan you use can affect things too, so there are a couple factors that could be causing the coffee cake to take a shorter time to bake and turn out a bit darker. As for this last batch turning out tough, I think using a hand mixer probably caused the batter to be overmixed, so I would suggest sticking with that good ol’ wooden spoon. I hope it’s perfect next time you make it!

  • I don’t mind using buttermilk with the exception of not being able to find a carton small enough and I end up tossing half a bottle. Is there something else I can use? I’ve heard of buttermilk substitutions (recipes) but I’ve never used one.

    1. Hi Melanie, there are two substitutions I’ve used. I haven’t tried it for this particular recipe, but I’ve used it successfully in others. The first is to thin yogurt with a bit of milk…for this recipe, I’d use a scant 1/2 cup yogurt and stir in enough milk to make it buttermilk consistency. The second is to add half a tablespoon of white vinegar to 1/2 cup of milk and let it sit 5 minutes before using it. I hope you enjoy the cake!

    1. Thank you so much, Angela! I really appreciate your taking the time to leave this awesome feedback. I wish I could see a picture too—I’m sure it’s beautiful!

  • This was so so good. Ilooked over so many recipes and most were filled with lots of sugar and sour cream. Thank you for posting something a little healthier.5 stars

  • I made this cake over and over again last fall. It’s delicious!  The scent of cinnamon in the air is unbeatable.  My family and co-workers could not believe that it was tasty and healthy.

    Thank you for sharing!5 stars

  • Super delicious cake, nice and moist and with the perfect level of sweetness for me and my husband. I skipped the icing. I bought a bag of Macoun apples for snacking, but I didn’t care for them out of hand, so I landed on your recipe when I searched for an apple buttermilk cake with oatmeal. I added the juice of half a lemon and a splash of Bragg’s apple cider vinegar to compensate for the sweeter apples. I used 1/2 cup King Arthur regular whole wheat flour, and 3/4 cup all-purpose. I added a touch of freshly crushed cardamom to the spices, and subbed almonds in the topping. It smells and tastes so good. I love a simple recipe like this that you can mix with a wooden spoon.5 stars

    1. I have not tried this recipe with Splenda, but you could experiment with it. I hope you enjoy the recipe if you give it a try!

  • This was by far one of the best coffee cakes I have ever eaten. I will not eat anything that is not healthy and most coffee cakes fall far short of even being close to healthy. But this one is not only healthy, it is absolutely delicious. I am very particular about trying new recipes and scrutinize them carefully especially in relation to the fat and sugar used; I loved that this cake uses whole wheat flour, very little butter, and relatively little sugar compared to most recipes. In spite of it being healthy, the cake is tender, flavorful and oh so moist; and the topping adds just the right amount of texture and sweetness. With the icing, it tastes downright sinful, but it is actually very light and doesn’t leave you feeling weighed down or stuffed. My husband labeled this one “A Definite Keeper” even with the whole wheat flour; the two of us ate the entire cake in two mornings (and it was just as good, or better, the second day! It just goes to prove that you really can “have your cake and eat it too”!
    P.S.: This is the first review I have ever posted in all my years of cooking… that is how good this cake is!5 stars

  • So delicious, so moist! I substituted whole wheat pastry flour and brown sugar in the cake and it turned out great!5 stars

    1. Hi Jacqueline! I’ve only tested this recipe out as written so I wouldn’t be able to advise on how much to use. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

  • This cake is absolutely delicious…a real crowd pleaser! I had lots of fresh picked apples and wanted to make something other than a traditional pie. This cake was the perfect option. It’s filled with fall flavors, a tasty streusel topping, and not loaded with tons of butter and sugar.
    I added some maple extract to the glaze. The maple combined with the apples, tender cake, and crisp streusel topping had people coming back for seconds!5 stars

  • I’ve made this recipe multiple times, it’s so wonderful and always requested by family members. I substitute thinly sliced almonds for walnuts because I don’t like them and it tastes great. I also don’t make the icing, I don’t think it needs it and I’m not a overly sweet person. I use a regular 9 inch round pan and it comes out nice and thick but takes almost twice as long to bake!5 stars

  • This coffee cake was absolutely delicious. The crunch of the oat streusel compliments the moist cake, and all of the flavors meld together so nicely. I was pleased that my time and labor were so well rewarded by the final product. Thank you for this fantastic recipe! P.S. You have a great website. Your instructions are very detailed and informative and I appreciate the various tips, hints, etc.5 stars

    1. I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with this recipe, Lori. Every oven is different so definitely adjust the baking time if it produced that kind of result. It has worked well for myself (and others), so I wished it would of been a hit for you too.

  • Really just okay, not sure how it has been described as best ever. The topping seems too buttery. Spices don’t come through even though I used fresh nutmeg. I will not be making this again. ( I am an experienced baker and know how to follow a recipe).3 stars

    1. I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Beth. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!