• I made this recipe the other day and it is fabulous. My husband, however, does not like nutmeg. Feeling the need to add something in its place, I thought about cinnamon. That didn’t seem like a good replacement, so I decided, why not think outside the box a little. So, I added cumin. Not the full 1/8 teaspoon as indicated for nutmeg, but 3 or 4 good dashes of it. It was amazing!5 stars

  • Hello, I want to try this recipe but was wondering if using spiced rum instead would work?
    Thanks in advance

  • I’ve been making this recipe for a few weeks now. I don’t change a thing about the recipe. This is my most requested dessert at family gatherings and holidays. Superb!5 stars

  • I make this at least twice a year, but, I do enjoy it all thru the year. It’s my favorite pie, reminds me of wen I was a kid at my great grandparents at holidays. It came out great, perfect. Thank you5 stars

  • I’m so glad that I found your buttermilk pie recipe. I love that this recipe is incredibly easy to follow. This pie became my kids favorite dessert.5 stars

  • Fantastic recipe! I love the hint of nutmeg it adds an extra layer of flavor. The buttermilk filling is smooth and creamy. I slightly reduced the amount of sugar in recipe coz I think it’s gonna be too sweet for my taste.5 stars

  • I’m blown away by the silky-smooth texture and delectable flavor of this buttermilk pie. The flavors are perfectly balanced.5 stars

  • This is a great pie! I followed the recipe exactly and baked it for 45 minutes. The filling was nice and firm, not runny at all. I will definitely make this pie again.5 stars

  • I have tried several recipes for buttermilk pie and consider this to be the best one! I use cinnamon instead of the nutmeg.5 stars

  • I’ve never made buttermilk pie before, so I have nothing to compare it to, but my guests who ate it said this recipe hit it right on. The recipe is definitely easy to make.5 stars

  • OHHH MY!! Finally, the Buttermilk pie recipe I have been looking for! I really LOVE Buttermilk pie. It’s my all-time favorite. Simple deliciousness. The one thing I don’t care for in many recipes I have made ..is when the sugar overpowers the buttermilk flavor, just making it a sweet pie. This recipe was complimented straight away for being able to actually taste the Buttermilk.5 stars

  • I made it with orange zest and I love the brightness that it adds but I didn’t have lemons this time so I used orange zest and I liked this as well. I also made my own buttermilk from cream. Thank you for the recipe5 stars

  • I was so happy to see that I could use a store-bought pie crust for this buttermilk pie. I cannot make a decent pie crust to save my life! I LOVE this pie! So simple and so easy. My 80 year old grandma was in town visiting and I surprised her with this pie. She said it reminded her of the good old days.5 stars

  • This recipe is the BEST! I swear it’s as good as my grandmother used to make. I rarely keep fresh lemons on hand so I skip the lemon zest and it’s still perfect without it. Thank you so much for sharing it with us.5 stars