I made this recipe the other day and it is fabulous. My husband, however, does not like nutmeg. Feeling the need to add something in its place, I thought about cinnamon. That didn’t seem like a good replacement, so I decided, why not think outside the box a little. So, I added cumin. Not the full 1/8 teaspoon as indicated for nutmeg, but 3 or 4 good dashes of it. It was amazing!
I’ve been making this recipe for a few weeks now. I don’t change a thing about the recipe. This is my most requested dessert at family gatherings and holidays. Superb!
I make this at least twice a year, but, I do enjoy it all thru the year. It’s my favorite pie, reminds me of wen I was a kid at my great grandparents at holidays. It came out great, perfect. Thank you
Fantastic recipe! I love the hint of nutmeg it adds an extra layer of flavor. The buttermilk filling is smooth and creamy. I slightly reduced the amount of sugar in recipe coz I think it’s gonna be too sweet for my taste.
This is a great pie! I followed the recipe exactly and baked it for 45 minutes. The filling was nice and firm, not runny at all. I will definitely make this pie again.
I’ve never made buttermilk pie before, so I have nothing to compare it to, but my guests who ate it said this recipe hit it right on. The recipe is definitely easy to make.
OHHH MY!! Finally, the Buttermilk pie recipe I have been looking for! I really LOVE Buttermilk pie. It’s my all-time favorite. Simple deliciousness. The one thing I don’t care for in many recipes I have made ..is when the sugar overpowers the buttermilk flavor, just making it a sweet pie. This recipe was complimented straight away for being able to actually taste the Buttermilk.
I made it with orange zest and I love the brightness that it adds but I didn’t have lemons this time so I used orange zest and I liked this as well. I also made my own buttermilk from cream. Thank you for the recipe
I was so happy to see that I could use a store-bought pie crust for this buttermilk pie. I cannot make a decent pie crust to save my life! I LOVE this pie! So simple and so easy. My 80 year old grandma was in town visiting and I surprised her with this pie. She said it reminded her of the good old days.
This recipe is the BEST! I swear it’s as good as my grandmother used to make. I rarely keep fresh lemons on hand so I skip the lemon zest and it’s still perfect without it. Thank you so much for sharing it with us.
I made this recipe the other day and it is fabulous. My husband, however, does not like nutmeg. Feeling the need to add something in its place, I thought about cinnamon. That didn’t seem like a good replacement, so I decided, why not think outside the box a little. So, I added cumin. Not the full 1/8 teaspoon as indicated for nutmeg, but 3 or 4 good dashes of it. It was amazing!
Hi Melinda! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review and feedback on the cumin!
Hello, I want to try this recipe but was wondering if using spiced rum instead would work?
Thanks in advance
Hi Misty, yes that should work. Hope you enjoy the pie!
I was actually wondering about rum extract?
I’ve been making this recipe for a few weeks now. I don’t change a thing about the recipe. This is my most requested dessert at family gatherings and holidays. Superb!
All I have on hand is regular fat buttermilk. Any reason I shouldn’t use that?
Hi Mark! Full fat should work. Enjoy!
I make this at least twice a year, but, I do enjoy it all thru the year. It’s my favorite pie, reminds me of wen I was a kid at my great grandparents at holidays. It came out great, perfect. Thank you
Hi Mellany! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
It was so easy and the texture turned out great! Will lessen the sugar next time.
The buttermilk pie recipe and tips were spot on! We loved this and will make again!
I’m so glad that I found your buttermilk pie recipe. I love that this recipe is incredibly easy to follow. This pie became my kids favorite dessert.
Fantastic recipe! I love the hint of nutmeg it adds an extra layer of flavor. The buttermilk filling is smooth and creamy. I slightly reduced the amount of sugar in recipe coz I think it’s gonna be too sweet for my taste.
Your buttermilk pie recipe is simply amazing! The filling is so rich and creamy. I loved every single bite!
Hi Lourdes! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I’m blown away by the silky-smooth texture and delectable flavor of this buttermilk pie. The flavors are perfectly balanced.
Hi Sabrina! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This is a great pie! I followed the recipe exactly and baked it for 45 minutes. The filling was nice and firm, not runny at all. I will definitely make this pie again.
So happy to hear it Belle, thank you!
I have tried several recipes for buttermilk pie and consider this to be the best one! I use cinnamon instead of the nutmeg.
Hi Arianne! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
It turned out so good! Easy recipe to follow with simple ingredients. I will definitely be making this pie again!!
Hooray! So glad to hear it, thank you for letting me know Belinda!
Good pie. The only change I made was instead of the nutmeg I used pumpkin pie spice. It was still delicious!
YUM! I love that idea Ruby!
I’ve never made buttermilk pie before, so I have nothing to compare it to, but my guests who ate it said this recipe hit it right on. The recipe is definitely easy to make.
Yay! Thank you Jenna!
OHHH MY!! Finally, the Buttermilk pie recipe I have been looking for! I really LOVE Buttermilk pie. It’s my all-time favorite. Simple deliciousness. The one thing I don’t care for in many recipes I have made ..is when the sugar overpowers the buttermilk flavor, just making it a sweet pie. This recipe was complimented straight away for being able to actually taste the Buttermilk.
Woo hoo!
I made it with orange zest and I love the brightness that it adds but I didn’t have lemons this time so I used orange zest and I liked this as well. I also made my own buttermilk from cream. Thank you for the recipe
I was so happy to see that I could use a store-bought pie crust for this buttermilk pie. I cannot make a decent pie crust to save my life! I LOVE this pie! So simple and so easy. My 80 year old grandma was in town visiting and I surprised her with this pie. She said it reminded her of the good old days.
Thank you so much for sharing with me, Marian!
This recipe is the BEST! I swear it’s as good as my grandmother used to make. I rarely keep fresh lemons on hand so I skip the lemon zest and it’s still perfect without it. Thank you so much for sharing it with us.
Thank YOU Isabelle!