I don’t have diced canned tomatoes with basil, garlic, and oregano But I have tomato sauce & tomato paste and the seasoning separately.. would this still turn out okay?
If so how much garlic , basil and oregano should I use?
Hi Hamlet! While I haven’t tried it myself, another reader has done this with success. She added about 2 teaspoons total of garlic and the herbs. I think you could certainly adjust the amount to suit your tastes. I hope this helps and that you enjoy the recipe!
Made this recipe exactly as written. Didn’t turn out too well. The pasta was stuck together in a gelatinous mass and ruined the whole thing. Kinda tasted like wallpaper paste—or what I imagine wallpaper paste would taste like. Maybe less pasta, or more liquid or cook the pasta separately and add to the chicken and sauce? Not sure, but I think I’ll pass on this one.
I’m sorry that this didn’t turn out as you hoped, Sue. It’s so hard to say what might’ve happened without being in the kitchen with you. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed the recipe, so I truly wish you would’ve too!
I made this the other day for a family lunch, I marinated the chicken with olive oil, garlic, salt, pepper and Italian seasoning for about two hours before cooking.
I didn’t have the diced tomatoes so I used cherry tomatoes but I did have some lovely tomato paste which seemed to work well. But this recipe is so easy and delicious to make, I absolutely loved it!
I’m sorry you had trouble with this recipe, Spence. Unfortunately, it’s so hard to say what might’ve gone wrong without being in the kitchen with you. Could you be a little more specific on how the recipe itself ruined your pot? Myself (and others) have had success in making this pasta, so I wish it would of been a hit for you.
We liked this a lot.
It was time for dinner and the chicken breasts were frozen, so I substituted some chicken fajita meat that I had. I browned it in the skillet. I just had Penne pasta, so I boiled it in a separate pan and added it. That meant I did not add the water to the recipe. I had a can of ripe olives and added them.
I truly believe the cans of tomatoes with the spices are the great secret to this recipe. We’ll make it again! Very good!
This was delish! I have to admit I changed a couple things. I added chopped yellow bell pepper and onion after chicken was cooked. Then added the can tomatoes and half my feta. Left covered on low while I cooked the pasta. Added pasta and about 1 cup of pasta water to chicken mixture. Added rest of feta (used a total of a 6 oz package of sun-dried tomato basil flavor) SO yummy! Thanks for the recipe!! A new favorite!
I wish I had seen your review. I made this recipe last night. The flavors were delicious, but the pasta turned out horrible. Pasta was not meant to be cooked this way, but I did try it. As I expected, it did not have the flavor of properly cooked pasta. It was edible, but barely. I already noted on my printed copy to boil the pasta separately next time. Also, it definitely needed a flavor boost, so I added some fresh garlic and more herbs. With some changes, the recipe will be delicious. Note to others: Boil pasta separately!
I’m sorry that this didn’t turn out as you hoped, Rhonda. It’s so hard to say what might’ve happened without being in the kitchen with you. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed the recipe, so I truly wish you would’ve too!
Loved this recipe! I used lentil pasta spirals and at the end threw in some cooked mushrooms halved and a big handful of baby spinach as i didnt have fresh basil … so tasty!! Will definitely be making again… I did use more liquid than stated (although i used home made chicken stock instead of water)
Going to make this tonight but add my own twist of black olives , spinach and I will blacken the chicken for that extra flavor . Plus I will add alit of fresh garlic . Excited to try ! I use to work for a Greek restaurant so feta is something I live but wonderful paired w/ garlic and black olives
I made this tonight and while I enjoyed it, I would’ve made same changes. The cooking time for the pasta was way too long and I think more liquid or tomato sauce would’ve made it less dry? Because the pasta was all stuck together and not saucy enough for my taste. But it was easy and will def try it again
I was asked to cook dinner at the last minute, so made this with what I had on hand. I used two cans of whole tomatoes since I didn’t have the diced, and I added fresh spices to make up for not being in the cans.
Some notes: I would cook the pasta separately next time. and mix it in. The cook five minutes + ten minutes overcooked the pasta.
Adding the cheese made a sort of a reasonable sauce, but it was lacking overall. I grated in some parmesan cheese to boost the “cheesiness” of the sauce and tossed in a couple of handfuls of frozen spinach. Lastly I added a couple of tablespoons of yogurt for creaminess.
Hi Kathleen, I’m sorry I don’t have an experience with using grams. This is my favorite kitchen scale that might help you with conversions: http://amzn.to/1HZiioX
This was awful. I knew I should have cooked my pasta separately! Thankfully I added onions, garlic, and olives for flavor, but I won’t be following this recipe again.
I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Nicole. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it, so I truly wish it would have been a hit for you.
Very tasty! Seeing all the folks who had trouble with it… I’m wondering if they didn’t use enough water… I ended up using about 3 cups when it was all said and done. I also added some chicken broth which was great!
This was my first time trying a one pot meal and I am (tentatively) sold! To those of you commenting that the pasta didn’t turn out, it takes a little trial and error to know how to get the liquid ratio right and to turn off the heat before it starts to burn and stick. I learned this the hard way but I was (almost) prepared because I’m gluten free so I was expecting a mishap anyway! I salvaged most of it, though, and it turned out definitely edible! I know what not to do next time, at any rate. It did help to do a little research on one pot pasta meals, though. That might be helpful in a recipe note. Watching it closely instead of relying on the timer and erring on the side of al dente helps, too. I will probably marinate the chicken next time but overall I think one pot pasta meals are my new favorite!
Just made this recipe tonight, as my wife has a Costco amount of feta! I used 2 cans diced tomatoes and added my own garlic, basil, and oregano. I also used gluten-free rotini which soaked up the sauce nicely. I added baby spinach at the end. Overall, my wife said I should make it again (high praise!). When I make this again, I will remove the chicken after its cooked before adding the pasta, then add it back at the end after adding spinach. Also, don’t forget to sauté the pasta for a couple minutes before adding liquid. Thanks so much!!
Made this last night. While it tasted pretty good, some parts of the recipe were vexing.
There wasn’t much room in the pot for the fettuccine to get down into the liquid with the chicken still in the pot. Removing the chicken to a plate helped and still got the fond at the bottom of the pan into the dish.
It would help to have a sense of what heat to use once the pasta is added. Boil? Boil, then reduce to a simmer? Medium the whole time? I also had problems with the pasta sticking to the bottom of the pot and kept reducing the temp to prevent this, but then the noodles were not as well cooked as I would have liked.
I’ll try this again, because the flavors were interesting, but with some adjustments to the pasta cooking.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, LR. The recipe has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
On the positive side, this tasted delicious. However, it was a gluey mess! I used capellini which I broke in half, and eventually added 2 extra cups of water, but the pasta still clumped unappealingly. If I make this again, I’ll try a short, tubular pasta (such as penne). I don’t think the flat pasta is an appropriate choice.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Neva. The recipe has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
Hi Barbara! You could probably adapt it for the slow cooker, I just have never tried it. It only takes about 35 minutes or less and you could prep most of the ingredients ahead of time. Hope this helps!
Unfortunately very stodgy, difficult to stir pasta when chicken pieces so big. Became a congealed pink mess, had to keep adding water and the kids refused to eat it. Note the picture doesn’t look like the chicken has been cooked in the sauce, so clearly not from the same recipe. Won’t be making it again, will stick to the usual approach of cooking a sauce and pasta separately. Added olives in attempt to make it more interesting, only flavoursome part of the dish. Sorry Erin!
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe Sarah. I’m not sure what would of caused it to congeal but normally adding water will help give a pasta dish a creamy texture while you stir it over the heat. Also I can assure you that the photos are true to the recipe.
I don’t have diced canned tomatoes with basil, garlic, and oregano But I have tomato sauce & tomato paste and the seasoning separately.. would this still turn out okay?
If so how much garlic , basil and oregano should I use?
Hi Hamlet! While I haven’t tried it myself, another reader has done this with success. She added about 2 teaspoons total of garlic and the herbs. I think you could certainly adjust the amount to suit your tastes. I hope this helps and that you enjoy the recipe!
Made this recipe exactly as written. Didn’t turn out too well. The pasta was stuck together in a gelatinous mass and ruined the whole thing. Kinda tasted like wallpaper paste—or what I imagine wallpaper paste would taste like. Maybe less pasta, or more liquid or cook the pasta separately and add to the chicken and sauce? Not sure, but I think I’ll pass on this one.
I’m sorry that this didn’t turn out as you hoped, Sue. It’s so hard to say what might’ve happened without being in the kitchen with you. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed the recipe, so I truly wish you would’ve too!
I made this the other day for a family lunch, I marinated the chicken with olive oil, garlic, salt, pepper and Italian seasoning for about two hours before cooking.
I didn’t have the diced tomatoes so I used cherry tomatoes but I did have some lovely tomato paste which seemed to work well. But this recipe is so easy and delicious to make, I absolutely loved it!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Shilpa! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This recipe completely ruined my nice Dutch Oven. What a horrible way to cook this dish. One of the worst recipes, truly.
I’m sorry you had trouble with this recipe, Spence. Unfortunately, it’s so hard to say what might’ve gone wrong without being in the kitchen with you. Could you be a little more specific on how the recipe itself ruined your pot? Myself (and others) have had success in making this pasta, so I wish it would of been a hit for you.
We liked this a lot.
It was time for dinner and the chicken breasts were frozen, so I substituted some chicken fajita meat that I had. I browned it in the skillet. I just had Penne pasta, so I boiled it in a separate pan and added it. That meant I did not add the water to the recipe. I had a can of ripe olives and added them.
I truly believe the cans of tomatoes with the spices are the great secret to this recipe. We’ll make it again! Very good!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Peggy! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I don’t have a Dutch Oven but do have a large deep skillet that looks like a wok with lid. Will this work?
Hi John! Any large pot with a lid should work! Hope that helps! Let me know if you try it!
This was delish! I have to admit I changed a couple things. I added chopped yellow bell pepper and onion after chicken was cooked. Then added the can tomatoes and half my feta. Left covered on low while I cooked the pasta. Added pasta and about 1 cup of pasta water to chicken mixture. Added rest of feta (used a total of a 6 oz package of sun-dried tomato basil flavor) SO yummy! Thanks for the recipe!! A new favorite!
HI Michelle! So glad the changes worked out for you! Thank you for this kind review!
I wish I had seen your review. I made this recipe last night. The flavors were delicious, but the pasta turned out horrible. Pasta was not meant to be cooked this way, but I did try it. As I expected, it did not have the flavor of properly cooked pasta. It was edible, but barely. I already noted on my printed copy to boil the pasta separately next time. Also, it definitely needed a flavor boost, so I added some fresh garlic and more herbs. With some changes, the recipe will be delicious. Note to others: Boil pasta separately!
I’m sorry that this didn’t turn out as you hoped, Rhonda. It’s so hard to say what might’ve happened without being in the kitchen with you. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed the recipe, so I truly wish you would’ve too!
Loved this recipe! I used lentil pasta spirals and at the end threw in some cooked mushrooms halved and a big handful of baby spinach as i didnt have fresh basil … so tasty!! Will definitely be making again… I did use more liquid than stated (although i used home made chicken stock instead of water)
Hi Diane! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Going to make this tonight but add my own twist of black olives , spinach and I will blacken the chicken for that extra flavor . Plus I will add alit of fresh garlic . Excited to try ! I use to work for a Greek restaurant so feta is something I live but wonderful paired w/ garlic and black olives
Hi Catherine! Hope you enjoy it!
I made this tonight and while I enjoyed it, I would’ve made same changes. The cooking time for the pasta was way too long and I think more liquid or tomato sauce would’ve made it less dry? Because the pasta was all stuck together and not saucy enough for my taste. But it was easy and will def try it again
Hi Lily! So glad you enjoyed the pasta! Thank you for this kind review and feedback!
I was asked to cook dinner at the last minute, so made this with what I had on hand. I used two cans of whole tomatoes since I didn’t have the diced, and I added fresh spices to make up for not being in the cans.
Some notes: I would cook the pasta separately next time. and mix it in. The cook five minutes + ten minutes overcooked the pasta.
Adding the cheese made a sort of a reasonable sauce, but it was lacking overall. I grated in some parmesan cheese to boost the “cheesiness” of the sauce and tossed in a couple of handfuls of frozen spinach. Lastly I added a couple of tablespoons of yogurt for creaminess.
Hi Alan! If you happen to get a chance to make the recipe as directed I do hope you will enjoy it. It’s so tasty as is!
could you please also put weights in grams.
Hi Kathleen, I’m sorry I don’t have an experience with using grams. This is my favorite kitchen scale that might help you with conversions: http://amzn.to/1HZiioX
This was awful. I knew I should have cooked my pasta separately! Thankfully I added onions, garlic, and olives for flavor, but I won’t be following this recipe again.
I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Nicole. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it, so I truly wish it would have been a hit for you.
Very tasty! Seeing all the folks who had trouble with it… I’m wondering if they didn’t use enough water… I ended up using about 3 cups when it was all said and done. I also added some chicken broth which was great!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Brittany! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This was my first time trying a one pot meal and I am (tentatively) sold! To those of you commenting that the pasta didn’t turn out, it takes a little trial and error to know how to get the liquid ratio right and to turn off the heat before it starts to burn and stick. I learned this the hard way but I was (almost) prepared because I’m gluten free so I was expecting a mishap anyway! I salvaged most of it, though, and it turned out definitely edible! I know what not to do next time, at any rate. It did help to do a little research on one pot pasta meals, though. That might be helpful in a recipe note. Watching it closely instead of relying on the timer and erring on the side of al dente helps, too. I will probably marinate the chicken next time but overall I think one pot pasta meals are my new favorite!
Hi Sarah! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review and feedback!
Just made this recipe tonight, as my wife has a Costco amount of feta! I used 2 cans diced tomatoes and added my own garlic, basil, and oregano. I also used gluten-free rotini which soaked up the sauce nicely. I added baby spinach at the end. Overall, my wife said I should make it again (high praise!). When I make this again, I will remove the chicken after its cooked before adding the pasta, then add it back at the end after adding spinach. Also, don’t forget to sauté the pasta for a couple minutes before adding liquid. Thanks so much!!
Hi Mic! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Made this last night. While it tasted pretty good, some parts of the recipe were vexing.
There wasn’t much room in the pot for the fettuccine to get down into the liquid with the chicken still in the pot. Removing the chicken to a plate helped and still got the fond at the bottom of the pan into the dish.
It would help to have a sense of what heat to use once the pasta is added. Boil? Boil, then reduce to a simmer? Medium the whole time? I also had problems with the pasta sticking to the bottom of the pot and kept reducing the temp to prevent this, but then the noodles were not as well cooked as I would have liked.
I’ll try this again, because the flavors were interesting, but with some adjustments to the pasta cooking.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, LR. The recipe has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
On the positive side, this tasted delicious. However, it was a gluey mess! I used capellini which I broke in half, and eventually added 2 extra cups of water, but the pasta still clumped unappealingly. If I make this again, I’ll try a short, tubular pasta (such as penne). I don’t think the flat pasta is an appropriate choice.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Neva. The recipe has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
Love this! Come back to it any time I need something quick, easy and delicious!
Hi Rhys! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Has anyone made this recipe in the crock pot? I bought the ingredients thinking it was a crockpot recipe😢
Hi Barbara! You could probably adapt it for the slow cooker, I just have never tried it. It only takes about 35 minutes or less and you could prep most of the ingredients ahead of time. Hope this helps!
Unfortunately very stodgy, difficult to stir pasta when chicken pieces so big. Became a congealed pink mess, had to keep adding water and the kids refused to eat it. Note the picture doesn’t look like the chicken has been cooked in the sauce, so clearly not from the same recipe. Won’t be making it again, will stick to the usual approach of cooking a sauce and pasta separately. Added olives in attempt to make it more interesting, only flavoursome part of the dish. Sorry Erin!
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe Sarah. I’m not sure what would of caused it to congeal but normally adding water will help give a pasta dish a creamy texture while you stir it over the heat. Also I can assure you that the photos are true to the recipe.