Made this this tonight. So good. I cut the recipe in half for my family of three except I kept the onion, bell pepper and jalapeño the same. We loved it!! Thanks
I am planning to make this for a large group of about 45 people;
I am going to x6 your recipe because the servings look generous.
Can you tell me if the corn tortillas are the very small ones, about
4.5″ diameter or the regular size , 6″ diameter?
Jenny, I’d recommend corn because they break down and become soft, so you can easily scoop the casserole. Flour will be denser and chewier and the layers will be more separate, sort of like a lasagna but with tortillas. That said, if you are trying to cook with what you have on hand, you could swap the flour tortillas—just know that the results will be different.
Made this tonight and my toddler enjoyed it just as you predicted! I was skeptical about it being too spicy but it surprisingly wasn’t. Great flavor and oh so easy ! The only thing I’d change next time is trimming the tortillas on the very top (last) layer to fit the pan because the edges that weren’t under the sauce were hard to chew. Thanks for a great recipe – excited to try more from your site!
I made this and rather than using chicken broth, tomato sauce and tabasco, I just used a jar of mild enchilada sauce. I also omitted the jalapeno since my husband cannot tolerate those well. I also used just a little sharp cheddar rather than MJ cheese. Turned out good! Thank you!
This was very good. I omitted the Jalapeno because my kids are sensitive to spice, and didn’t have the green Tabasco suggested, so I used 4T Trader Joe’s salsa verde instead. It was labor/time/ingredient intensive, but I’ll make it again with a different recipe that requires shredded chicken on back to back nights, with leftovers between the two on night 3 to balance out the effort. Next time I plan to add the jalapeño back in, but I’ll also add a can of black beans, and maybe some shredded carrots and chopped spinach to up the veg.
I made this the other night and the only change I made to the recipe was using fire roasted diced tomatoes (salsa style w/chilies) because I was out of tomato sauce and this has been asked to be made often! It sparked the conversation that we need a list of meals to NOT forget and a rotation list of what they love! THANK YOU!!
Plan to make this dish for book club because it looks so delish. Can I assemble the day before and then bake the following day or will the tortillas get too mushy?
Hi Suzette! I’d recommend fully baking the dish the day before, then reheating it just before serving to help crisp everything back up. I hope you enjoy it!
I kept it super simple and just used canned enchilada sauce, instead of making my own sauce and followed All of the other directions and it turned out amazingly. Thank you for another great recipe.
We love this recipe! I’ve made it a few times and my family loves it. I want to double the recipe and freeze one to cooker later but I cannot find the freezer instructions.
Hi Lacy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Here are the freezer instructions: Leftover casserole (either individual protions or a whole frozen casserole) can be frozen for up to 3 months. Wrap airtight and make sure your container/pan is freezer safe. Let thaw overnight in the refrigerator. To reheat a whole casserole, let your pan come to room temperature prior to putting it in the oven. Hope this helps!
Erin, I’m going to make this to stash in my freezer (along with a bunch of your other recipes!) before baby comes this spring. Do I need to bake this before freezing, or can I put it all together and wrap for the freezer? Thanks for creating one great recipe after another and sharing with us!
Hi Meagan! Here are the freezer instructions: FREEZER INSTRUCTIONS: Leftover casserole (either individual protions or a whole frozen casserole) can be frozen for up to 3 months. Wrap airtight and make sure your container/pan is freezer safe. Let thaw overnight in the refrigerator. To reheat a whole casserole, let your pan come to room temperature prior to putting it in the oven. Hope this helps!
This recipe was delicious😃 instead of the jalapeño I put in a small can of mild green chilies. The can of chilies was 4 oz so I used 4 oz less of the tomato sauce. I also had a little shredded cheddar cheese which I sprinkled on top along with the Monterey Jack cheese. My 88 year old Mom loved it. Thanks for the great recipe Erin!
I made this tonight. This dish was totally mushy! I could not determine any tortillas. I bought white corn tortillas. Could this have caused the mushiness? I really wanted to love this but it was very disappointing.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Jayne. The method and timing has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it! The white corn tortillas could work too.
Very good, kind of tedious to make, I thought. If I were to do again, I think I’d fry? Saute? the tortillas in olive oil, to make them crunchy…
But I liked it…
Made this this tonight. So good. I cut the recipe in half for my family of three except I kept the onion, bell pepper and jalapeño the same. We loved it!! Thanks
Thanks so much, Kendall! I’m glad your family enjoyed it. I really appreciate your taking the time to leave this nice review!
I can’t even tell you how many times my husband and I have made this. It is so easy and so good. Thanks for a great recipe.
Kara, I’m so glad to hear you enjoy this recipe! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave this awesome review!
I am planning to make this for a large group of about 45 people;
I am going to x6 your recipe because the servings look generous.
Can you tell me if the corn tortillas are the very small ones, about
4.5″ diameter or the regular size , 6″ diameter?
Hi Catherine! The tortillas I used are 6 inch. I hope you enjoy!
Can we use flour tortillas or does it have to be corn?
Jenny, I’d recommend corn because they break down and become soft, so you can easily scoop the casserole. Flour will be denser and chewier and the layers will be more separate, sort of like a lasagna but with tortillas. That said, if you are trying to cook with what you have on hand, you could swap the flour tortillas—just know that the results will be different.
Hi! I wonder if the flour tortillas would become softer if you were to dip the tortillas in the sauce first. I’m going to give it a try 🙂.
Hey Erin this looks delicious, wondering if I could assemble early in the day then bake it later?
Yes Mackenzie, I think that would be just fine!
A sign of a good meal is when you look forward to the leftovers. This is SOOOO good. Going to add to our regular dinner rotation. Thanks Erin!!!
Hooray! Thanks for sharing this review, Elizabeth!
Made this tonight and my toddler enjoyed it just as you predicted! I was skeptical about it being too spicy but it surprisingly wasn’t. Great flavor and oh so easy ! The only thing I’d change next time is trimming the tortillas on the very top (last) layer to fit the pan because the edges that weren’t under the sauce were hard to chew. Thanks for a great recipe – excited to try more from your site!
Thank you for sharing this kind review, Tiffany! I’m so happy that this recipe was a hit!
Simple to prep and delicious!!!
Thank you for sharing this kind review, Rebecca! I’m so happy to hear that the recipe was a hit!
I made this and rather than using chicken broth, tomato sauce and tabasco, I just used a jar of mild enchilada sauce. I also omitted the jalapeno since my husband cannot tolerate those well. I also used just a little sharp cheddar rather than MJ cheese. Turned out good! Thank you!
Thank you for sharing this kind review, Kimberly! I’m so happy you enjoyed the recipe!
This was very good. I omitted the Jalapeno because my kids are sensitive to spice, and didn’t have the green Tabasco suggested, so I used 4T Trader Joe’s salsa verde instead. It was labor/time/ingredient intensive, but I’ll make it again with a different recipe that requires shredded chicken on back to back nights, with leftovers between the two on night 3 to balance out the effort. Next time I plan to add the jalapeño back in, but I’ll also add a can of black beans, and maybe some shredded carrots and chopped spinach to up the veg.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Elise! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I made this the other night and the only change I made to the recipe was using fire roasted diced tomatoes (salsa style w/chilies) because I was out of tomato sauce and this has been asked to be made often! It sparked the conversation that we need a list of meals to NOT forget and a rotation list of what they love! THANK YOU!!
I’m so happy that it was a hit, Kerri! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Plan to make this dish for book club because it looks so delish. Can I assemble the day before and then bake the following day or will the tortillas get too mushy?
Hi Suzette! I’d recommend fully baking the dish the day before, then reheating it just before serving to help crisp everything back up. I hope you enjoy it!
I kept it super simple and just used canned enchilada sauce, instead of making my own sauce and followed All of the other directions and it turned out amazingly. Thank you for another great recipe.
So glad to hear you enjoyed it! Thank you for your kind review Becky!
We love this recipe! I’ve made it a few times and my family loves it. I want to double the recipe and freeze one to cooker later but I cannot find the freezer instructions.
Hi Lacy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Here are the freezer instructions: Leftover casserole (either individual protions or a whole frozen casserole) can be frozen for up to 3 months. Wrap airtight and make sure your container/pan is freezer safe. Let thaw overnight in the refrigerator. To reheat a whole casserole, let your pan come to room temperature prior to putting it in the oven. Hope this helps!
Can I fully assemble the casserole and put it in the freezer, unbaked? Then when read to use, defrost and bake as directed?
Hi Mary! I wish I could advise but I’ve never made it and placed it in the freezer unbaked. If you decide to try it out, let me know how it goes!
Erin, I’m going to make this to stash in my freezer (along with a bunch of your other recipes!) before baby comes this spring. Do I need to bake this before freezing, or can I put it all together and wrap for the freezer? Thanks for creating one great recipe after another and sharing with us!
Hi Meagan! Here are the freezer instructions: FREEZER INSTRUCTIONS: Leftover casserole (either individual protions or a whole frozen casserole) can be frozen for up to 3 months. Wrap airtight and make sure your container/pan is freezer safe. Let thaw overnight in the refrigerator. To reheat a whole casserole, let your pan come to room temperature prior to putting it in the oven. Hope this helps!
Easy Mexican Chicken Tortilla Casserole tried it tonight it was delicious!
Hi Nancy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This recipe was delicious😃 instead of the jalapeño I put in a small can of mild green chilies. The can of chilies was 4 oz so I used 4 oz less of the tomato sauce. I also had a little shredded cheddar cheese which I sprinkled on top along with the Monterey Jack cheese. My 88 year old Mom loved it. Thanks for the great recipe Erin!
Hi Ellen! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Hi! I have leftover shredded chicken from a roast chicken that I’d like to use. Can anyone tell me how much 1.5 lbs yields in cups? Thanks!
Hi Lisa, Google says it’s roughly 4 1/2 cups of shredded chicken. Hope this helps!
I made this tonight. This dish was totally mushy! I could not determine any tortillas. I bought white corn tortillas. Could this have caused the mushiness? I really wanted to love this but it was very disappointing.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Jayne. The method and timing has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it! The white corn tortillas could work too.
Very good, kind of tedious to make, I thought. If I were to do again, I think I’d fry? Saute? the tortillas in olive oil, to make them crunchy…
But I liked it…
Hi Yvonne! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!