Love it. I also freeze plastic cocktail cups with cranberry juice or any juice. Floating orange slices and cranberries. To use instead of just ice. It keeps large batches cold without watering down!
Thank you Erin. This recipe was a big hit for a holiday event for 60+ people. I quadrupled the recipe, substituted raspberry vodka for the dark rum, and used Vernor’s zero sugar ginger ale, which IMO, is the best ginger ale in the world. This drink is pleasantly fruity but not sweet. I mixed the vodka, cranberry juice and apple cider well before the event and refrigerated the mix, and added the ginger ale and brut Prosecco moments before serving. I froze 100% Cranberry Juice in a Bundt cake pan and used a large drink dispenser with a spigot and a cone in the middle filled with rosemary sprigs, ice, and water (isolated from the drink mix). The cranberry “Bundt ring” floated in the dispenser with the orange slices and cranberries. I did not add ice to the drink and it stayed cold all evening. It undoubtedly had a more tart flavor by not adding ice. As the recipe states, keeping the ingredients chilled before mixing is essential. This is the best large batch cocktail mix I have ever made or tasted. Sure to be a hit at any event.
Hi R Hood, while I haven’t tried it using an alcoholic apple cider, you could definitely use it and experiment. It will make it more potent though. If you give it a try, let me know how it turns out!
My sister throws a big Christmas Eve party every year. Last time I made this punch for the first time and everyone loved it! It was really a hit. Sis called me yesterday to ask if I’d make it again this year and of course I told her yes! I want to know, would 2 cups of brandy be too much for this recipe instead of 1 and a half cups?
Hi Marissa! I have not but I know that is classic (my Grandma used to for n/a punch). It will definitely make it sweet, so depends on your preferences!
Hi Erin,
Hoping you read this now. Followed all ingredients, uses dry Prosecco, and aged Rum, with all other ingredients. The punch tastes a little tart. I did use organic cranberry pure juice. I have not added oranges or cranberries because party is in hour. We’re thinking of adding organic stevia to sweeten if oranges don’t help.
Dark rum is not the spirit for this drink IMO. It’s overpowering and clashes with the other flavors. I would try this again with brandy, perhaps apple brandy. I didn’t mind the booziness, and the effervescence is really good. I’m guessing a vodka would work too. Why have dark rum do battle with the cranberry, ginger, and cider? Dark rum is already a medley of flavors onto itself. If you decide to use rum, cut some limes and serve each cup with a wedge. That helped.
Hi Katlyn, the apple cider is pretty essential to the punch. You could try plain apple juice, but it won’t have the same warm flavors. I’d recommend sticking with cider for this one! Although if you do decide to leave it out, I would love to know how it goes!
So sorry to leave a bad review here, but don’t want anyone else to waste £40 on ingredients. I made this in in the UK and I assume ingredients might taste different. Followed the measurements exactly but the punch tasted of nothing but apple cider vinegar. Made this for a group gathering back in December and not one of the 8 attendees wanted more than a sip. Big party fail I’m sorry to say.
Hi Jane, I’m sorry to hear you had trouble. There is no vinegar in this recipe. In the US we have a product that called apple cider which is a raw, unfiltered, unsweetened beverage made from the juice of pressed apples that contains no alcohol. For our recipes, when we use apple cider vinegar, we will always specifically say that in the ingredient list. Hope this helps for next time!
It was a big hit! Everyone loved it. I have a bottle that I can use to keep the leftover, it has a good seal. How long can this last in the fridge if properly stored? Thank you.
Hi! What size dispenser would you recommend using?
Thanks!
Hi Melissa, I use a 3 gallon punch bowl. You can also use a 2.5 gallon dispenser. Enjoy!
Has anyone ever used pomegranate juice in place of cranberry? Thanks!
Sounds tasty! Let us know if you decide to experiment, Carolann!
Love it. I also freeze plastic cocktail cups with cranberry juice or any juice. Floating orange slices and cranberries. To use instead of just ice. It keeps large batches cold without watering down!
Love it! Thanks for the tip, Amy!
Thank you Erin. This recipe was a big hit for a holiday event for 60+ people. I quadrupled the recipe, substituted raspberry vodka for the dark rum, and used Vernor’s zero sugar ginger ale, which IMO, is the best ginger ale in the world. This drink is pleasantly fruity but not sweet. I mixed the vodka, cranberry juice and apple cider well before the event and refrigerated the mix, and added the ginger ale and brut Prosecco moments before serving. I froze 100% Cranberry Juice in a Bundt cake pan and used a large drink dispenser with a spigot and a cone in the middle filled with rosemary sprigs, ice, and water (isolated from the drink mix). The cranberry “Bundt ring” floated in the dispenser with the orange slices and cranberries. I did not add ice to the drink and it stayed cold all evening. It undoubtedly had a more tart flavor by not adding ice. As the recipe states, keeping the ingredients chilled before mixing is essential. This is the best large batch cocktail mix I have ever made or tasted. Sure to be a hit at any event.
So glad to hear! Thank you Steve!
Has anyone used alcoholic cider?
Hi R Hood, while I haven’t tried it using an alcoholic apple cider, you could definitely use it and experiment. It will make it more potent though. If you give it a try, let me know how it turns out!
Thanks very much I love to bake and learn new things
Hope you enjoy it!
Mande this for a Friend’s Christmas dinner and it was a hit!
Yay! Great to hear, Ruth!
This looks delicious! I have some leftover dark spiced rum, do you think that would work?
Hi Jana! Others have tried it with spiced rum, which great success. Hope you enjoy it!
We absolutely loved it!
My sister throws a big Christmas Eve party every year. Last time I made this punch for the first time and everyone loved it! It was really a hit. Sis called me yesterday to ask if I’d make it again this year and of course I told her yes! I want to know, would 2 cups of brandy be too much for this recipe instead of 1 and a half cups?
So glad to hear, Angie! It’s definitely going to add some sweetness to the punch, and be more potent, so precede with caution! Enjoy!
Hello. I have a dry Rose would that work? Also, I cannot find diet ginger ale locally. Is regular okay> Thank you.
Hi! Yes to regular ginger ale. As far as the dry rose, as long as its sparkling, that’s great! Happy Holidays!
Hi Erin, is sweet apple cider fine to use? That’s the only kind sold around me
Certainly Sheena! Enjoy!
Have you tried adding sherbet ice cream?
Hi Marissa! I have not but I know that is classic (my Grandma used to for n/a punch). It will definitely make it sweet, so depends on your preferences!
Hi Erin,
Hoping you read this now. Followed all ingredients, uses dry Prosecco, and aged Rum, with all other ingredients. The punch tastes a little tart. I did use organic cranberry pure juice. I have not added oranges or cranberries because party is in hour. We’re thinking of adding organic stevia to sweeten if oranges don’t help.
Hi Richard, it sounds like it could probably be the time of juice used. Hope the stevia helped!
Dark rum is not the spirit for this drink IMO. It’s overpowering and clashes with the other flavors. I would try this again with brandy, perhaps apple brandy. I didn’t mind the booziness, and the effervescence is really good. I’m guessing a vodka would work too. Why have dark rum do battle with the cranberry, ginger, and cider? Dark rum is already a medley of flavors onto itself. If you decide to use rum, cut some limes and serve each cup with a wedge. That helped.
Thanks for the feedback, Ed. It’s the one we prefer and enjoy but you can definitely use something else.
Can I omit the apple cider if I can’t find any? or any substitutions I could do? Thank you
Hi Katlyn, the apple cider is pretty essential to the punch. You could try plain apple juice, but it won’t have the same warm flavors. I’d recommend sticking with cider for this one! Although if you do decide to leave it out, I would love to know how it goes!
Would this fit in a 2 gallon dispenser if I don’t add ice to it? My plan is to just have guests add their own ice so it doesn’t get diluted!
Hi Katlyn, yes this should fit into a 2 gallon dispenser! Enjoy!
So sorry to leave a bad review here, but don’t want anyone else to waste £40 on ingredients. I made this in in the UK and I assume ingredients might taste different. Followed the measurements exactly but the punch tasted of nothing but apple cider vinegar. Made this for a group gathering back in December and not one of the 8 attendees wanted more than a sip. Big party fail I’m sorry to say.
Hi Jane, I’m sorry to hear you had trouble. There is no vinegar in this recipe. In the US we have a product that called apple cider which is a raw, unfiltered, unsweetened beverage made from the juice of pressed apples that contains no alcohol. For our recipes, when we use apple cider vinegar, we will always specifically say that in the ingredient list. Hope this helps for next time!
It was a big hit! Everyone loved it. I have a bottle that I can use to keep the leftover, it has a good seal. How long can this last in the fridge if properly stored? Thank you.
Great to ear, Lyssa! Your bubbly liquids are going to go flat but it should still be drinkable for a day or two.
Hi! Looks like a great recipe! I wanted to confirm the Apple Cider is non alcoholic (like Martinelli’s, right?)
Thank you
Hi Katrina! No, it’s like Musselman’s 100% Apple Cider. Hope this helps!