I made this soup yesterday afternoon and my husband and I LOVED it! I had read comments prior to making it and noted that some had found the rice undercooked at the end of the recommended cooking time. I chose to use the low setting – removed the chicken thighs after 5 1/2 hours as they were done but did need to cook the soup longer as the rice was underdone. Next time I make it, I will increase the heat to high after removing the chicken to speed up the remaining cooking time for the rice. I’m sure that everyone’s slow cooker is different though. We haven’t even finished the leftovers and my husband is suggesting that I make it again in the near future. Wonderful flavor and very little “hands-on” time needed. We loved it – thank you for another great recipe!
This is the worst chicken soup recipe I’ve ever tried – did every thing exactly as the recipe says. Please don’t waste your money on ingredients like I did. Not trying to be a Karen but I have no idea why this has good reviews.
Making this tonight to use up leftover rice. Soo I realize now that soup needs to be salty to taste good. Don’t use the no salt added chicken broth like I did. It will take you to flavorless town. The recipe does warn you of this. I added some salt and it has improved.
FYI the rice will take longer to cook than is noted in the instructions. It will be the last ingredient to cook. I have had my
soup on high for 4.5 hrs and it’s just
starting to get soft . Should be ready in another 1-2 hrs. :)
Hi Taylor! Unfortunately, I do not recommend substituting white rice in this recipe, as it will become soggy. You could, however, cook the rice separately as directed on the package, then stir it into the soup at the very end of the cooking time. If you decide to try this, I’d love to hear how it goes!
Probably won’t make this recipe again. Everything else will cook besides the rice.
Don’t cook the rice with the recipe I wish I would have cooked it separately.
This was delicious! Pre-seasoning the veggies and add the fresh lemon were the difference-makers for me! I also adapted with what I had in my pantry and the results were great. Thanks for a great site full of ideas!
Taste is okay but I’ve had better chicken soup. After 6 hours the rice was still uncooked. I mean it wasn’t even beginning to soften. So I gave up and cooked it on the stove. Will not use this recipe again.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Jo. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
We absolutely loved it! I was out of brown rice, so I followed your suggestion, made white rice separately and added to the soup after it was done cooking. It was perfect!
I cooked on low setting and followed recipe exactly as written. The rice fell apart and turned to a thick mush. Would it help if I added the rice towards the end of cooking, or to reduce cooking time by a few hours?
I’m so sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Eedl. You used brown rice? It typically holds up well in the crockpot so trying to figure out why it would turn to mush.
I have no idea why people had such trouble with this recipe. It was delicious and nourishing and if anything the rice was a bit overcooked. Not sure what everybody is doing wrong. I’ll make this one of my regular dishes in the winter
If anyone has trouble getting the rice to cook, trying getting one of those crockpots where the lid seals and locks on. These work wonderfully for everything. I have never had trouble getting the rice finished with this kind of crockpot though I have had problems with the ones with loose fitting covers. I thought the soup was great.
I used brown rice and at 5 hours it was complete mush. It doesn’t even have texture of rice anymore. I would never make this again. And I’m not making rice separate that defeats the purpose of having a simple crock pot recipe.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Jill! Other readers say that their rice isn’t done at 5 hours, other readers say that it came out perfectly, so we are unsure what the issue some readers are having. Could you tell us what kind of crockpot you have? And what brand of brown rice? We haven’t be able to replicate the issue on our end so it’s quite puzzling. I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
We loved this soup the first time we made it. I plan to make it again but I was wondering if anyone has tried to make this without frying up the celery, etc. first to soften. I’m generally in a hurry and would like to omit that step if not truly necessary. Thanks!
I am trying to make a double batch in a 5qt, older rival crock pot. I’m using uncle Bens brown rice. Should I run the pot on high or low to get the rice done correctly?
I made this soup yesterday afternoon and my husband and I LOVED it! I had read comments prior to making it and noted that some had found the rice undercooked at the end of the recommended cooking time. I chose to use the low setting – removed the chicken thighs after 5 1/2 hours as they were done but did need to cook the soup longer as the rice was underdone. Next time I make it, I will increase the heat to high after removing the chicken to speed up the remaining cooking time for the rice. I’m sure that everyone’s slow cooker is different though. We haven’t even finished the leftovers and my husband is suggesting that I make it again in the near future. Wonderful flavor and very little “hands-on” time needed. We loved it – thank you for another great recipe!
Thank you so much for the feedback, Pam! So glad you enjoyed it!
This is the worst chicken soup recipe I’ve ever tried – did every thing exactly as the recipe says. Please don’t waste your money on ingredients like I did. Not trying to be a Karen but I have no idea why this has good reviews.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Katie. Anything that we could help troubleshoot?
Making this tonight to use up leftover rice. Soo I realize now that soup needs to be salty to taste good. Don’t use the no salt added chicken broth like I did. It will take you to flavorless town. The recipe does warn you of this. I added some salt and it has improved.
FYI the rice will take longer to cook than is noted in the instructions. It will be the last ingredient to cook. I have had my
soup on high for 4.5 hrs and it’s just
starting to get soft . Should be ready in another 1-2 hrs. :)
Thanks for the feedback, Sandy! Hope you love it!
Can I use White basmati rice instead?
Hi Taylor! Unfortunately, I do not recommend substituting white rice in this recipe, as it will become soggy. You could, however, cook the rice separately as directed on the package, then stir it into the soup at the very end of the cooking time. If you decide to try this, I’d love to hear how it goes!
What is the point of spraying the slow cooker with cooking spray?
Hi Lindsey, cooking spray prevent food from sticking to the surface. Enjoy!
Yes, but the broth would prevent it from sticking? Wouldn’t the broth just mix oil into the soup?
Hi Lindsey, you are definitively more than welcome to leave it off. Enjoy!
Probably won’t make this recipe again. Everything else will cook besides the rice.
Don’t cook the rice with the recipe I wish I would have cooked it separately.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Jack. Could you tell me which size crockpot you used?
This was delicious! Pre-seasoning the veggies and add the fresh lemon were the difference-makers for me! I also adapted with what I had in my pantry and the results were great. Thanks for a great site full of ideas!
Great to hear, thank you Kim!
Taste is okay but I’ve had better chicken soup. After 6 hours the rice was still uncooked. I mean it wasn’t even beginning to soften. So I gave up and cooked it on the stove. Will not use this recipe again.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Jo. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
We absolutely loved it! I was out of brown rice, so I followed your suggestion, made white rice separately and added to the soup after it was done cooking. It was perfect!
Great to hear, thank you Leandra!
This recipe worked exactly as written and it was amazing! I have made it several times now and it’s a go-to because it’s easy and healthy.
Great to hear, thank you Kim!
I cooked on low setting and followed recipe exactly as written. The rice fell apart and turned to a thick mush. Would it help if I added the rice towards the end of cooking, or to reduce cooking time by a few hours?
I’m so sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Eedl. You used brown rice? It typically holds up well in the crockpot so trying to figure out why it would turn to mush.
I really love this recipe! I usually change it up a tad with adding fresh sage and rosemary, plus mushrooms. It’s a family favorite!
YAY, thanks for sharing, Tricia!!
I have no idea why people had such trouble with this recipe. It was delicious and nourishing and if anything the rice was a bit overcooked. Not sure what everybody is doing wrong. I’ll make this one of my regular dishes in the winter
Hi Ross! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thanks for the feedback!
If anyone has trouble getting the rice to cook, trying getting one of those crockpots where the lid seals and locks on. These work wonderfully for everything. I have never had trouble getting the rice finished with this kind of crockpot though I have had problems with the ones with loose fitting covers. I thought the soup was great.
Thanks so much for the feedback and tip, Kim! Glad you enjoyed it!
Perfect! The chicken was so tender and a perfect balance of rice and broth. We loved it.
So glad to hear, JenInVa!
I used brown rice and at 5 hours it was complete mush. It doesn’t even have texture of rice anymore. I would never make this again. And I’m not making rice separate that defeats the purpose of having a simple crock pot recipe.
I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Jill! Other readers say that their rice isn’t done at 5 hours, other readers say that it came out perfectly, so we are unsure what the issue some readers are having. Could you tell us what kind of crockpot you have? And what brand of brown rice? We haven’t be able to replicate the issue on our end so it’s quite puzzling. I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
We loved this soup the first time we made it. I plan to make it again but I was wondering if anyone has tried to make this without frying up the celery, etc. first to soften. I’m generally in a hurry and would like to omit that step if not truly necessary. Thanks!
Hi Alison, in a pinch you could probably skip the step. So glad you enjoyed the soup!
I have been having a problem finding brown rice. Any reason I can’t cook white rice separately and add at the end?
Hi Phyllis, that should work. Enjoy!
Great recipe! My daughter loves it and eats a lot of soup! Due to health conditions this soup has become her comfort food!!
Makes me so happy to hear, Carol! Thank you for sharing!
I am trying to make a double batch in a 5qt, older rival crock pot. I’m using uncle Bens brown rice. Should I run the pot on high or low to get the rice done correctly?
Hi Justin, I’d probably do high.