• During the current q, Dry Marsala seems impossible to find in any of the stores that offer curbside pickup… (Cribari Marsala is the only Marsala wine that Krogers stocks… I’m fairly certain it’s the sweet type.) Any suggestions for a substitute or do I wait until I can get back into the wine shop?

    1. Mark, while dry is definitely ideal, I’ve made this with a semi-dry that I could actually get at Kroger and we liked it OK (it was *as* good as a true dry marsala, but it was still good). One thing to consider is if you’ll mind having the extra semi-dry leftover. Sorry I can’t give you a 100% clear answer, but I hoipe that helps.

      1. I found dry Marsala! There’s a wine shop in Ann Arbor that is doing curbside pickup. I’m thinking I may dust the chicken breasts in flour before searing them… Thanks for the inspiration!

  • Made this tonight and it was SO good. I couldn’t find Marsala wine at my grocery store (and didn’t want to go looking at other stores), so I Googled swaps and used Sauvignon Blanc. It was delicious! 5 stars

    1. I’m SO happy that you enjoyed it, Lauren! Thank you for taking the time share this kind review and your swap!

  • I’m not a mushroom lover so I made it without the mushrooms and the flavor was delicious, but my sauce wasn’t dark like yours is in your pictures. Is it the mushrooms that make the sauce dark?

    1. Hi Denise! The sauce does darken some from the mushrooms. I’m happy you still enjoyed the recipe without them!

  • This recipe was so simple and delicious.  I didn’t have Marsala Wine so I substituted in a Red Table Wine and the flavor was so rich.  A big hit with the family!5 stars

    1. Elizabeth, I am so so pleased to hear it! Thanks for sharing this kind review and your tweaks. It means a lot to me and is so helpful to others!

  • This was good and easy, thank you! I added a little extra salt and parmesan cheese for serving, and served over whole wheat pasta.5 stars

  • This is a good version of Chicken Marsala for the crock-pot. I would have liked the sauce to be a little thicker than it was even with adding more corn starch. Keep an eye on your chicken as mine only took 2 hours to cook. Thanks5 stars

      1. It’s cooking now, I have made this for several years and it’s the only Marsala I eat. Most restaurants use sweet, which I don’t like. To address negative comments. Bland? Adjust your seasoning, maybe you like more S&P or I tend to use Lawy’s season salt for many things that calls for S&P. Sour cream and hot sauce? this is not Mexican food. There is not a Italian restaurant that would add that to a chicken or veal Marsala. The key if you read the recipe is it’s a healthier version with no cream. If the slurry didn’t make it thick enough, make a double batch (I usually do) and that does the trick. Not need to add cream. Overdone and dried out chicken? Did you overcook it in the pan? Recipe clearly states, you are browning (basically searing it) the outside and the chicken will not be cooked through because it cooks in the crockpot for a couple of hours. It also states cooking time will vary depending on the size of your chicken and varies from crockpot to crockpot. So it’s up to you to keep a eye on the cooking time and when the chicken reaches the proper temp. Because over cooked chicken breast are not enjoyable but it’s not the recipes fault. This recipe rocks! For those who did not enjoy, that’s a shame. But the fault is not with the recipe.5 stars

  • Delicious and so very easy. I followed the recipe as written and served it over rice. The whole house smelled fantastic and it was a bit hit with the family. Perfect, thank you!5 stars

  • Sounds delicious! Going to try this on guests this weekend. If I want more sauce is it a problem to double the sauce ingredients?5 stars

    1. Hi Lesli! I haven’t tried this myself, but it should work fine as long as everything fits in your crockpot. I hope you enjoyed it!

  • This was so yummy! The prep only took me 15 minutes, and then I cooked it for 3 hours. So delicious! (I actually used Marsala cooking wine because it was all I could find) and it still turned out amazing! I paired it with GF noodles and it was the perfect pairing!5 stars

    1. I am going to make this recipe today and I only have Marsala cooking wine. I am glad to hear the flavor was still good. I can’t wait to try this.

    1. Hi Kathleen! I haven’t tried doubling this myself, but you could experiment with it as long as everything fits into the crockpot. I hope you enjoy it!

  • Great recipe and so easy to make! Will definitely make it again and again. I’m so glad that we’re now able to save recipes on your website. Thank you for that! Love your cookbook too!5 stars

  • Made this for my Niece (a new Momma) and her husband. It was super simple, and it smelled divine! I used chicken broth for the cornstarch slurry–only substitution I made. Question: can you use boneless chicken thighs? If so, how long would you recommend for cooking time? Thanks so much for the fabulous recipe.5 stars

    1. I’m so happy that you enjoyed it! Thank you for sharing this kind review! You can use chicken thighs. Cook them on LOW for 4 to 5 hours or until they reach an internal temperature of 165 degrees F.

  • This was so easy to make and it was delicious the whole family enjoyed it. I served it with brown rice and a dinner salad.

    When looking for the Marsala Wine Dry its by the vinegars in the grocery store. Just an fyi!!

    Enjoy!!!!5 stars

  • It turned out good. I had button mushrooms so used those in place of the cremini. It was done at 2 hours. Next time will thicken the sauce in a pot instead of the slow cooker.5 stars

  • I followed this recipe very precisely and my meal didn’t come out good at all. Chicken was way overcooked and the Marsala sauce did not thicken at all, even after 3 tbsp of cornstarch. Like I said, I’m very disciplined with recipes and followed this step by step. Not sure what went wrong here!1 star

    1. I’m sorry this recipe didn’t work out for you, Max. It’s hard to know what went wrong without being in the kitchen with you. Myself (and others) enjoy this recipe, so I really wish it would of been a hit for you too!

    1. Hi Patricia! It’s totally up to you if you want to double the sauce. I am unsure how it’s going to change the cook time for this recipe. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

    1. Hi Jen! I would not recommend doing that. The chicken won’t be completely cooked after step 3 and it is not safe to leave it half uncooked overnight.