• Hi Erin,

    Thank you for the recipe, it is great! Last time I made it, turned out soooo good I had to make it again. This time I added sweet potatoes and it turned out too sweet. Do you have any suggestions of what to add to make it not so sweet? More Worcestershire, perhaps?

    1. Hi Sarah! I think I would stick to using the recommend red potatoes if the sweet potatoes are too sweet for you. Enjoy!

    2. I’m sure the stew will be delicious but there was nothing easy about this recipe. When I get a recipe off the internet, I follow it on my phone. The way the directions are written, it’s not easy to quickly scan to the next steps. I found I had to keep scrolling back and forth to the ingredient amounts. Do not wait to cut up all the vegetables!
      Cut them in advance! I did that and still felt harried trying to follow and move onto the next step. I’m sure it will be delicious, I haven’t eaten it yet. The flavors seem good. It took 1.25 hours to prepare. There’s a lot of chopping and cooking on the stove before moving to the crockpot. That to me doesn’t qualify as easy.3 stars

      1
      1. I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Dana. There is a “jump to recipe” button that takes you to the recipe where you can also print it. Hope this helps!

        1
        1. I actually thought the opposite. The directions were very clear and with a lot of detail. Typically, with any recipe you have to scroll to the amounts of the ingredients. My family loved it!

          1
    1. Hi Aliso, it shouldn’t be overcooked if you are way under the minimum cook time. There are lots of variables to why your meat might not come out, I try to cover as much as I can in the blog post. Honestly I would keep in it for the 6 1/2 hours on low and check it then. Hope this helps!

  • I made this all in my instant pot, used the saute setting to brown the beef and saute the vegetables, then pressure cooked for 120 minutes on high. I used a petite sirah for the wine (what I had on hand) and wow, this stew is delicious!5 stars

  • November 22nd, 2023. The weather just turning a bit chilly and I really wanted to have a dinner that was true comfort food, healthy and restorative for the body and mind. I just finished my serving or shall I be truthful and say I had three and I may go for four, it was that incredibly good. I made it gluten free by using millet flour and arrow root for a thickener and it was simply superb, superb. Warm, filling, comforting and so so good. If you have ever seen the movie Julie/Julia and Julie was making Julia’s stew and when she tasted it she just moaned in ecstasy and this recipe brought that moment to life for me. I love food, can you tell? Thank you Erin for a wonderful sharing. Highly recommend! Mmmmmmm, I’m still moaning in ecstasy and YES, I’m going back for another bowl…. such a piglet I am….but I love it!

    Oh, I found the recipe easy to follow. I have my computer screen facing the kitchen so I can continually refer back to it as I need to after reading it.

    Okay, I’m off to indulge!5 stars

      1. Hi! Hoping for certain timely help. I cooked my stew on low for eight hours overnight in my instant pot in the slow cook setting and my vegetables are still hard, but my meat is really cooked almost a little bit too much. Where did I go wrong here?

        1. Hi Danielle, I’m sorry I do not have any experience with using the instant pot (slow cooker setting) for this stew, so I am unable to know what might of gone wrong. I will say that you definitely want your veggies cut on the smaller side, they should be smaller than the pieces of beef. Hope this helps!

  • I actually thought the opposite. The directions were very clear and with a lot of detail. Typically, with any recipe you have to scroll to the amounts of the ingredients. My family loved it!

  • Question…why saute the veggies first? Many slow cooker stew recipes just call for putting them in the slow cooker after browning the meat. Seems like an unnecessary step?

    1. It boost the flavor. I’m definitely in favor of doing all of the steps laid out in the recipe, but you could skip it if you’d like. Enjoy!

  • This was so good! I couldn’t parsnips this time around so just added some more potatoes. And I completely forgot the peas until I was already on my last bowl of leftovers. :( Next time!5 stars

  • This recipe was absolutely incredible and so easy!! I can’t believe how delicious it is! The meat is so tender and flavorful and it made my house smell great all day! I can’t wait to try more of your recipes!☺️5 stars

  • This is my first time making stew and this recipe knocked it out of the park. My husband and I are actually obsessed. I didn’t have very high expectations since it was my first time and I thought, “How good can stew actually be?” Incredible, turns out. It completely hit the spot. The only thing I did differently was the sub for wine, as I didn’t want to buy any and I hate the smell of it. Definitely making this again.5 stars

  • Love this recipe and it prompted me to order your cookbook. I hated cooking when I was younger but it’s the most therapeutic thing I do now. I like to toss my own little twist to amazing recipes I see. I added green beans, celery, in addition to the peas. Very veggie soup sounding but it was amazing and I paired it with a nice basmati rice.5 stars

  • I am new to cooking and I just got a crockpot and was excited to make beef stew for the first time. I can’t believe how amazing it turned out! The flavor was so amazing and the beef was nice and tender. This is definitely a staple and a recipe I’ll hold on too! Thank you so much for teaching me to make something so delicious. Looking forward to making more meals from this page!5 stars

  • Delicious! Tender beef and veggies in a great sauce.
    I should have given myself more time to read through the recipe steps and then prepare all ingredients. Starting the night before to prep might have been a good idea.
    But the results were worth it! My husband loved it!
    Thanks for the recipe!5 stars

  • Hi Erin!

    My daughter is fructose intolerant and can’t eat tomatoes. Can this recipe be made without the tomato paste? Thanks!

  • I am cooking this beef stew now in the slow cooker and I am sure it will taste fantastic. I am also sure there is no possible way I could have prepared it for the slow cooker in 15 minutes, it takes 16 minutes minimum to brown the beef if you have only two batches. My husband and I prepared what we could last night (peeled and chopped the carrots, sliced mushrooms I used, cut up onion, etc) and this morning it took me a good 1.25 hours or more to finish peeling and chopping and browning and measuring and adding to get it in the slow cooker. I understood and had read the directions before I started, I have cooked
    for over 50 years. I So many (almost all ) recipes underestimate, often hugely, the amount of time they take to make. When I see a time suggested I usually triple it to quadruple it or more to get the actual time. So thank you for the great recipe, I feel it will be worth the time spent but I implore recipe authors to give more realistic times. I have cooked other of your recipes and find they are great recipes, so thank you for providing them.5 stars

    1. Hi Kelli, I stopped including sodium info because it can vary so much depending upon what products you used, and I found a lot of conflicting info online, so ultimately I didn’t feel comfortable publishing it because sometimes it wasn’t even in the ballpark. If you’d like to calculate it yourself, there are lots of free tools online (myfitnesspal.com is popular). I hope that helps!

  • My family and are did not like the flavor of the stew. Followed directions exactly. We will stay with more of a mushroom flavored stew going forward. But, the meat and vegetables cooked together nicely based on the directions of the recipe. i loved the tomatoe paste and parsnips addition and will add that to mine going forward.4 stars

    1. I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Frances. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!

  • I loved that this stew was full of great veggies that I don’t typically see in stews, like parsnips. It tasted comforting, yet not too heavy. Like some other reviewers, I found the prep took me far more than the 15 minutes noted in the recipe. (To be fair, I was also fielding period questions from a three-year-old while prepping :)). I’d say realistically, it would take someone with a good amount of cooking experience more like 30-45 minutes to prep without interruptions. Thanks for the recipe!4 stars

  • This recipe was really good! I looked at the “prep” as much longer, took me about 35-40 min to chop, sear the beef and cook the veggies and sauce.5 stars

  • I love Erin’s recipes so this somehow was my fault I am sure.
    I did not have tomato paste, so left that out. I used Guiness beer.
    It lacked flavour. I tried adding more salt and pepper, but it didn’t seem to help. I added a little more Worcestershire, that didn’t seem to help either.1 star

    1. I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Kari. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!