Easy and delicious. Recipe was plenty moist as-is, but throw in a splash of stock if you think you need more.
The chicken cooked much faster than the carrots and potatoes, so heed Erin’s warning about over-cooking it and adjusting times for your particular slow cooker, the size of the chicken, etc. I make my own Italian seasoning which has salt, pepper and garlic (powder), so I skipped those and adjusted to taste when served.
Next time I’ll go a little easy on the lemon rind. I also threw in a couple of hands-full of sliced cabbage in the last couple of hours to add some more veggies.
Thank you, Erin…this will be a regular in my kitchen – and, nice site; very easy to use!
Cooking this right now. Just reading the reviews….there are some very rude people out there, no way this will be “tasteless” butter and garlic will see to that. I did add 1/2 an onion with about 2 tblsp more butter on the veggies and added celery as well. If it’s not completely done in the allotted time, I can fix it in a covered electric skillet or an Instant pot very quickly. Take her advice and get an instant read probe thermometer and your cooking will get a lot easier.
Hi Erin,
I have made many of your recipes and enjoy them very much. My Crockpot is made by Crockpot it is 6 quart and Programmable and Manual. I love having the choice and its new. I am at 2 hours on High and my Crock pot runs hot usually, so I was excepting to have to pull chicken early, unfortunatly at 2 hours on High my vegetables are completely raw and my chicken is raw underneath so I am bumping it up to 3 more hours on high.
I am using two skinless , boneless chicken breasts at 1.22 wt. I really think either some liquid like broth or water needs to be added and cooking time needs to be adjusted. The Chicken was completely defrosted . I’m hoping as long as I keep it on high for a total so far of 5 hours nobody will get sick- is this correct? Thank you! Its smells delicious , just not cooking so as long as I add extra time on high will chicken and veggies be safe?
Update I moved vegetables to side putting chicken to center bottom closer to butter sauce and tossed veggies around side on top of cooked and underside is cooking up! Yay! Still cooking times may have to be longer.
We loved this recipe. It was simple and ready to eat when we were. I didn’t have a lemon so substituted jarred lemon juice. Next time I’ll plan and use fresh lemon thank you
Super easy recipe! The chicken came out so tender and juicy! I did a dry rub on my chicken first with some cayenne, smoked paprika, a chicken spice blend and some other random spices/herbs. I am definitely making this again. Thank you!!
I followed this recipe as closely as possible but was minus a few ingredients, so I had to improvise. For example, I didn’t have baby carrots (we grow our own food), so I cut up whole carrots. I didn’t have Parmesan cheese or any cheese, so that was eliminated. My other half is on a low-fat diet; by virtue of that circumstance, the butter was also eliminated. I had to substitute russets for the Yukon or red potatoes. I followed the rest of the ingredients and slow cooked on low.
This is a no fuss-no-muss-quick-to-go-together recipe which I truly appreciate with all the other work that goes into homesteading. The last thing I want to do is spend two hours putting a meal together. In 1987, I gave my Crock Pot away and just purchased another. This easy recipe was a great way to dust off my crockery cooking skills.
Thank you for a great meal and hardly any kitchen time!
My family cleaned my slow cooker and hollered for more! That was just five nights ago. Wanna guess what’s in the slow cooker for tonight?! :)
Made this several times now. Twice with chicken thighs and tonight with thin chicken breasts. We really liked it with thighs but loved with the chicken breasts. I followed the recipe exact. Delicious!
Hi Jimmy, thank you for your feedback. Nothing is supposed to be submerge. The butter cooks over the chicken, the chicken should release some moisture. Hope this helps!
This recipe was a 10 plus 10 plus 10. Could not find recommended Italian seasoning used McCormick Italian seasoning. There was hardly any leftovers. I’m very picky but this was so delicious,
To anyone reading, 1.5-2 hours on high is not enough time to cook through the carrots and potatoes in a 7 qt crockpot. 3 hours later, I’m still waiting for the carrots to be cooked. I hope the author will fix the inaccurate cook time in her recipe! At least the dish smells good.
Katie, I’m sorry to hear this! Can you share what brand of crock pot you have and what size you cut your carrots and potatoes? The recipe is accurate for the models I have tested this recipe in.
I made this recipe because I had everything on hand. Since it’s a recipe from Erin, I knew that it was going to be delicious, but also familiar since it uses ingredients I’ve used hundreds – if not thousands – of times before. I was WRONG! What a surprise! This recipe is delicious and nothing like anything I’ve made. Is it the honey? The cayenne? The butter or the lemon? All of the above? All I know is that this will be another Erin recipe that goes into rotation. Thank you for another delicious (and healthy) dish, Erin!
I’m in the middle of making this, everything is in the crockpot and it has been on for about an hour or so and it occurred to me that perhaps I was supposed to stir it up or do I just leave it sitting with the veggies on the bottom and the chicken on the top?
Hi Lucy, when the chicken is done cooking, remove it to a plate, and cover with foil to keep warm.
Test the vegetables to see if they are tender. If they are not yet tender, give them a stir, re-cover the slow cooker. You’ll find these directions in Step 4 and 5. Hope this helps!
I have made this recipe about 50-60 times, it is my husband’s favorite, most requested dinner! Just a tip for others who use boneless skinless chicken breasts ~ I have FINALLY found the best way to keep the chicken~moist and sooo tender! I put the breasts in FIRST, at the bottom of the slow cooker, then I put in the carrots and potatoes etc. I also use about 1-1.5 cups of chicken broth along with the butter (as listed in recipe). (I cooked it on LOW for approx. 6 hours.)
Thank you so much for sharing this recipe with all of us!
Easy and delicious. Recipe was plenty moist as-is, but throw in a splash of stock if you think you need more.
The chicken cooked much faster than the carrots and potatoes, so heed Erin’s warning about over-cooking it and adjusting times for your particular slow cooker, the size of the chicken, etc. I make my own Italian seasoning which has salt, pepper and garlic (powder), so I skipped those and adjusted to taste when served.
Next time I’ll go a little easy on the lemon rind. I also threw in a couple of hands-full of sliced cabbage in the last couple of hours to add some more veggies.
Thank you, Erin…this will be a regular in my kitchen – and, nice site; very easy to use!
Hi Tom! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Made this for dinner tonite and my husband asked me to make it again! Thought it was delicious. Great recipe.
Hi Debbie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Cooking this right now. Just reading the reviews….there are some very rude people out there, no way this will be “tasteless” butter and garlic will see to that. I did add 1/2 an onion with about 2 tblsp more butter on the veggies and added celery as well. If it’s not completely done in the allotted time, I can fix it in a covered electric skillet or an Instant pot very quickly. Take her advice and get an instant read probe thermometer and your cooking will get a lot easier.
Hi Graham! Thank you so much for your kind comment! I really appreciate it! So glad you enjoy the recipe!
Hi Erin,
I have made many of your recipes and enjoy them very much. My Crockpot is made by Crockpot it is 6 quart and Programmable and Manual. I love having the choice and its new. I am at 2 hours on High and my Crock pot runs hot usually, so I was excepting to have to pull chicken early, unfortunatly at 2 hours on High my vegetables are completely raw and my chicken is raw underneath so I am bumping it up to 3 more hours on high.
I am using two skinless , boneless chicken breasts at 1.22 wt. I really think either some liquid like broth or water needs to be added and cooking time needs to be adjusted. The Chicken was completely defrosted . I’m hoping as long as I keep it on high for a total so far of 5 hours nobody will get sick- is this correct? Thank you! Its smells delicious , just not cooking so as long as I add extra time on high will chicken and veggies be safe?
Update I moved vegetables to side putting chicken to center bottom closer to butter sauce and tossed veggies around side on top of cooked and underside is cooking up! Yay! Still cooking times may have to be longer.
Hi Maria! When in doubt always, always temp your chicken to make sure it has reached the right internal temperature before serving. Hope you enjoy it!
We loved this recipe. It was simple and ready to eat when we were. I didn’t have a lemon so substituted jarred lemon juice. Next time I’ll plan and use fresh lemon thank you
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Karen! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Super easy recipe! The chicken came out so tender and juicy! I did a dry rub on my chicken first with some cayenne, smoked paprika, a chicken spice blend and some other random spices/herbs. I am definitely making this again. Thank you!!
Hi Dee! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Delicious!!! I forgot to add the yogurt and cheese but it was delicious without! This recipe is a winner!
Hi Kayla! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I followed this recipe as closely as possible but was minus a few ingredients, so I had to improvise. For example, I didn’t have baby carrots (we grow our own food), so I cut up whole carrots. I didn’t have Parmesan cheese or any cheese, so that was eliminated. My other half is on a low-fat diet; by virtue of that circumstance, the butter was also eliminated. I had to substitute russets for the Yukon or red potatoes. I followed the rest of the ingredients and slow cooked on low.
This is a no fuss-no-muss-quick-to-go-together recipe which I truly appreciate with all the other work that goes into homesteading. The last thing I want to do is spend two hours putting a meal together. In 1987, I gave my Crock Pot away and just purchased another. This easy recipe was a great way to dust off my crockery cooking skills.
Thank you for a great meal and hardly any kitchen time!
My family cleaned my slow cooker and hollered for more! That was just five nights ago. Wanna guess what’s in the slow cooker for tonight?! :)
Glad it worked out for you Annie!
Made this several times now. Twice with chicken thighs and tonight with thin chicken breasts. We really liked it with thighs but loved with the chicken breasts. I followed the recipe exact. Delicious!
Hi Melanie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I would make this recipe again. We absolutely loved it. Made for an evening when coming off the boat during camping.
Thank you Betty!
5 tablespoons of butter was nowhere near enough or I missed something, but nothing was submerged in liquid. Added Chicken broth
Hi Jimmy, thank you for your feedback. Nothing is supposed to be submerge. The butter cooks over the chicken, the chicken should release some moisture. Hope this helps!
I’m making this right now. Im using frozen chicken thighs and hope it will all come together at the same time. Also will release more liqud
Let me know how it went, Kim!
This recipe was a 10 plus 10 plus 10. Could not find recommended Italian seasoning used McCormick Italian seasoning. There was hardly any leftovers. I’m very picky but this was so delicious,
Makes me so happy to hear, Nancy! Thank you!
To anyone reading, 1.5-2 hours on high is not enough time to cook through the carrots and potatoes in a 7 qt crockpot. 3 hours later, I’m still waiting for the carrots to be cooked. I hope the author will fix the inaccurate cook time in her recipe! At least the dish smells good.
Katie, I’m sorry to hear this! Can you share what brand of crock pot you have and what size you cut your carrots and potatoes? The recipe is accurate for the models I have tested this recipe in.
This worked exactly as written, thanks!
Great! Thank you Penelope!
This worked exactly as written, thanks!
Thank you Caralen!
I would make this recipe again! Tasty and really easy with boneless, skinless thighs.
Thank you Wendy!
Could this be made with sweet potatoes?
Hi Leslie, yes! Swap the diced white potatoes for 3/4-inch diced sweet potatoes. Enjoy!
I made this recipe because I had everything on hand. Since it’s a recipe from Erin, I knew that it was going to be delicious, but also familiar since it uses ingredients I’ve used hundreds – if not thousands – of times before. I was WRONG! What a surprise! This recipe is delicious and nothing like anything I’ve made. Is it the honey? The cayenne? The butter or the lemon? All of the above? All I know is that this will be another Erin recipe that goes into rotation. Thank you for another delicious (and healthy) dish, Erin!
Thank you so much for your kind words and review, Erica! Glad it was a hit!
I’m in the middle of making this, everything is in the crockpot and it has been on for about an hour or so and it occurred to me that perhaps I was supposed to stir it up or do I just leave it sitting with the veggies on the bottom and the chicken on the top?
Hi Lucy, when the chicken is done cooking, remove it to a plate, and cover with foil to keep warm.
Test the vegetables to see if they are tender. If they are not yet tender, give them a stir, re-cover the slow cooker. You’ll find these directions in Step 4 and 5. Hope this helps!
I have made this recipe about 50-60 times, it is my husband’s favorite, most requested dinner! Just a tip for others who use boneless skinless chicken breasts ~ I have FINALLY found the best way to keep the chicken~moist and sooo tender! I put the breasts in FIRST, at the bottom of the slow cooker, then I put in the carrots and potatoes etc. I also use about 1-1.5 cups of chicken broth along with the butter (as listed in recipe). (I cooked it on LOW for approx. 6 hours.)
Thank you so much for sharing this recipe with all of us!
So happy to hear this recipe is such a hit for you, T Porter! Thank you for the tip!