Hi Candise! I’m afraid the consistency won’t be right without the half-and-half especially. You could experiment by swapping in something like cashew milk for the whole milk, but I think you’ll need the half-and-half. You could try using full-fat coconut milk instead of the half-and-half, but that would alter the flavor. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
My husband and I are recently (and begrudgingly) dairy free for health reasons. Are there any dairy free milks that you can recommend to work with this? (Should also note, my husband is also tree-nut free). Thanks so much, I love all of your recipes!
Hi Kate! I’m afraid the consistency won’t be right without the half-and-half here. I’d recommend trying my Healthy Hot Chocolate recipe instead (make sure your chocolate is also dairy-free). I hope this helps!
Seriously, the most decadent and delicious hot chololate I have ever had the pleasure of tasting. So easy to make and sooooo tasty. Highly recommend trying this recipe.
Allison
Thankyou Erin!!
Question: Have you ever tried to double this? I might need more than 6 servings, so wondered if it would need longer to cook if doing that?
Also, most recipes I saw had sweetened condensed milk, but I was happy to find one that didn’t since I don’t want it to be too sweet, just a good chocolate flavor that beats the hot chocolate packets. Is this recipe a good fit for that?
Hi Kristi! I haven’t tried it myself but tt will depend on the size of your crockpot if a double batch will fit. I don’t believe you would need to add any additional cooking time. As far as flavor this has a good balance for me. Hope this helps!
Most recipes call for sweetened condensed milk, which we didn’t have on hand, so I picked this recipe to make today. I used my good Ghirardelli chocolate and it was so bitter it was virtually undrinkable. My husband added more sugar to make his cup palatable, but the rest of us couldn’t drink it, even with added marshmallows. We’re very disappointed with it.
I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Andrea. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!
If you’re a chocoholic like me, then you absolutely need to try this Crockpot Hot Chocolate! It’s the perfect way to satisfy your chocolate cravings. It’s so rich and decadent, and the flavor is out of this world. I can’t wait to make it again!
There’s nothing quite like a warm mug of homemade Crockpot Hot Chocolate on a cold winter day. This recipe is so easy to make and it tastes amazing. I love that I can customize it to my liking.
Oh wow!! I just made this tonight!! Yummy!! I’m making it ahead of time for our gathering. I can’t wait for everyone to try it, I hope it heats up well!
Very well received by my whole family, also a lot of fun to do together. I would recommend it for people looking for easy bonding time over the cold holidays. Enjoy!
Whoa, this is a super thick, rich, and creamy hot recipe! It’s so good, definitely a treat to be had in moderation but great for a crowd. I have doubled this recipe in my slow cooker for groups and everyone loves it. Wonderful recipe and super simple.
I made this last night for a group of middle school/high school girls. I can’t even begin to tell you how much they loved it. I thought I would have tons of leftovers as I doubled the recipe to be safe. Well, I ran out and had to quickly make a 3rd batch and it was also wiped out!
I’m looking for a sugar free hot chocolate/cocoa recipe and when I Google recipes it doesn’t seem to give me anything. After reading all the comments on this recipe I’ve just got to try it but I’m wondering if it would be as good if I use Splenda equivalent to the sugar- does anyone know?
Looks and sounds delicious, Erin! Have you tried non-dairy milk such as almond or oat for this recipe? Thank you!
Hi Candise! I’m afraid the consistency won’t be right without the half-and-half especially. You could experiment by swapping in something like cashew milk for the whole milk, but I think you’ll need the half-and-half. You could try using full-fat coconut milk instead of the half-and-half, but that would alter the flavor. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
My husband and I are recently (and begrudgingly) dairy free for health reasons. Are there any dairy free milks that you can recommend to work with this? (Should also note, my husband is also tree-nut free). Thanks so much, I love all of your recipes!
Hi Kate! I’m afraid the consistency won’t be right without the half-and-half here. I’d recommend trying my Healthy Hot Chocolate recipe instead (make sure your chocolate is also dairy-free). I hope this helps!
Can I make this hot chocolate in the Crock-Pot the day before an event and then reheat in the Crock-Pot the next day on a low setting?
Sure Teresa! Cheers!
Cue “Sleigh Ride” – this was the most DELICIOUS and simple hot chocolate. It delivered the “comfy, cozy” vibe I was looking for this holiday week.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Ashley! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Seriously, the most decadent and delicious hot chololate I have ever had the pleasure of tasting. So easy to make and sooooo tasty. Highly recommend trying this recipe.
Allison
Thankyou Erin!!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Allison! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This is a fantastic party idea and we drank up the ‘tester batch’ in one day! Simply delicious!
Hi Lela! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Question: Have you ever tried to double this? I might need more than 6 servings, so wondered if it would need longer to cook if doing that?
Also, most recipes I saw had sweetened condensed milk, but I was happy to find one that didn’t since I don’t want it to be too sweet, just a good chocolate flavor that beats the hot chocolate packets. Is this recipe a good fit for that?
Hi Kristi! I haven’t tried it myself but tt will depend on the size of your crockpot if a double batch will fit. I don’t believe you would need to add any additional cooking time. As far as flavor this has a good balance for me. Hope this helps!
Most recipes call for sweetened condensed milk, which we didn’t have on hand, so I picked this recipe to make today. I used my good Ghirardelli chocolate and it was so bitter it was virtually undrinkable. My husband added more sugar to make his cup palatable, but the rest of us couldn’t drink it, even with added marshmallows. We’re very disappointed with it.
I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Andrea. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!
INCREDIBLE! Best hot chocolate we’ve ever had. It was so creamy and friends all loved it.
Hi Macy! So glad to hear you enjoyed it! Thank you for your kind review!
I am in chocolate heaven topped with marshmallows! Whoel family went crazy for this. Thanks Erin!
Yay! Thank you Nadine!
If you’re a chocoholic like me, then you absolutely need to try this Crockpot Hot Chocolate! It’s the perfect way to satisfy your chocolate cravings. It’s so rich and decadent, and the flavor is out of this world. I can’t wait to make it again!
Yes! Thank you Aimee!
I just made a batch and OMG it is absolutely the best Hot Chocolate I have ever had!!! I am saving some for tomorrow to take to my parents.
Yay! Thank you Jane!
There’s nothing quite like a warm mug of homemade Crockpot Hot Chocolate on a cold winter day. This recipe is so easy to make and it tastes amazing. I love that I can customize it to my liking.
Makes me so happy to hear, thank you Janice!
Oh wow!! I just made this tonight!! Yummy!! I’m making it ahead of time for our gathering. I can’t wait for everyone to try it, I hope it heats up well!
Great to hear! Thank you Kaila!
If I drive about 40 minutes to work, will the hot chocolate be OK in the crock pot if I make it before I leave?
Hi Shay, as long as it stays warm, it should be fine. Enjoy!
Very well received by my whole family, also a lot of fun to do together. I would recommend it for people looking for easy bonding time over the cold holidays. Enjoy!
Yay! Thank you Lacey!
This is delicious. I made it for a Christmas party. I was asked to make it again for a gathering at a friend’s house. Kids and adults loved it.
Whoa, this is a super thick, rich, and creamy hot recipe! It’s so good, definitely a treat to be had in moderation but great for a crowd. I have doubled this recipe in my slow cooker for groups and everyone loves it. Wonderful recipe and super simple.
So glad you enjoyed it, Lexie!
I made this last night for a group of middle school/high school girls. I can’t even begin to tell you how much they loved it. I thought I would have tons of leftovers as I doubled the recipe to be safe. Well, I ran out and had to quickly make a 3rd batch and it was also wiped out!
My sister-in-law and I did the chocolate bar for church using you recipe to huge success! Thank you for such a great recipe!
Great to hear, thank you Nancy!
I’m looking for a sugar free hot chocolate/cocoa recipe and when I Google recipes it doesn’t seem to give me anything. After reading all the comments on this recipe I’ve just got to try it but I’m wondering if it would be as good if I use Splenda equivalent to the sugar- does anyone know?
Hi Tracy, I honestly don’t know how it would taste. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!