1. Hi Erin! I’m very eager to try this recipe, it looks so good & yummy! Do you have the metric version so I can try to bake? Thanks in advance!

  • Good golly Miss Molly!! I would give these 10 stars if I could. Recipe was easy to follow and cookies turned out exactly as promised. Fragrance filled the house and flavor was divine. Thank you for yet another go to recipe.5 stars

  • Hi Erin, can these be made with a butter substitute? Husband is lactose sensitive so yummy butter won’t work & we don’t want to leave him out!

    1. Hi Claire! I haven’t tried a butter substitute in this recipe myself, so you’d be experimenting. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!

  • This was the first recipe I tried from Erin and it was everything I hoped it would be…even though I was a little short on the dark chocolate and totally forgot the sea salt finish, (probably bc by son was home and I was chatting while baking)! The rise was sky high and they were the dark chocolatey gooey goodness I was hoping for!5 stars

  • Can the dark chocolate cookies be made with gluten free flour i.e. Bob’s Red Mill 1 to 1 baking flour? They look so delicious, I cannot wait to make them.
    Thank You

    1. Hi Roseann! I’ve not tested this out but usually you can use the 1:1 for substituting all-purpose flour. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

  • Hi Erin, this is not about the chocolate cookies it about your pickled onions. My whole family is addicted and I have made many jars for Xmas gifts. Everyone is asking for your recipe and raving about these onions. Thank you I love your emails. Erica. Osoyoos. B.C. Canada 🍁 🇨🇦

  • I have made these dark chocolate cookies several times. Lots of dishes and chocolate to clean up but it certainly is worth the effort. I use a small cookie scoop and get 45 +/- bite size cookies which are perfect for eating with morning coffee, evening red wine and as a perfect size snack. Thanks for sharing this great receipt with all of us.5 stars

  • AMAZING, definitely very dark but for those who like that it is the best. The consistency is almost brownie like and my new favorite chocolate cookie5 stars

    1. I tried it again as a gluten free option and they are still great! I used King Arthur gluten free cup-for-cup substitute; to account for the rice flour in the flour blend, I added 1/8 cup of water (this prevents grittiness of the rice flour). The richness of the recipe helps make the recipe stay moist.5 stars

    1. Hi Vasanth! I’ve only tested the recipe as is, so can’t say specifically how it would work. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!

      1. Hello Erin,

        I will try with flax seeds a substitute for eggs which I have tried in other recipes and they have come out well. I will substitute in your recipe and come back with the results. I am sure it will come out well

  • Hi Erin! Am very eager to try your recipe it looks so yummy! But could you help to convert them into metric measurement please? Thanks in advance!5 stars

  • So delicious! It was to many chocolate chips for my taste but that was my fault I dumped them in there to quickly without checking but that’s ann easy fix! I also reduced the sugar but very yummy!!4 stars