• I love this recipe, it sounds so delicious! Is there a substitute for butter that I could use?  Thanks! 

    Ps. Can’t wait for your cookbook to be out, I’ll be first in line!

    1. Hi Olivia, thank you so much! I think you could sub in another nut butter of your choice. I hope you love the cookie dough!

    1. Hi Monica! From a quick google search, it looks like you can follow the same process using gluten free-flour, but obviously it might taste a little different depending on what type you use. I hope you enjoy!

      1
  • Thank you for this recipe, Erin! I’m excited to try it! Will toasting the flour stovetop (until lightly browned) on a pan work, too?

    1. Hi Rosario, I haven’t tried that method myself, but I’ve seen it done before, so that’s likely an option too. I hope you enjoy the cookie dough!

    1. Hi Debora, I mention this in the post, but raw flour can carry bad germs such as E. coli, so the CDC recommends that it not be consumed raw.

  • Hi Erin,
    This sounds silly perhaps but I am going to ask anyway…could you cool some of the cookie dough and would it turn out into cookies? I like the idea of edible cookie dough that can be baked. Did you try that by chance? If not, I can try it out and report back. 

  • Eggs have never been used in biscuit recipes. Not here at least and egg nog has raw egg and that is not an issue. Not sure where you get your info from. Sugar butter and flour are biscuit not egg.

    1. Hi Dee, in the drop biscuits, I use the egg to help make them tender and ensure they rise. It’s worth it to me for lighter-than-air biscuits that don’t need rolling and are more forgiving! As for this edible cookie dough, the CDC advises against consuming raw egg in any recipe, so that is why I omit it here. Here is the information: https://www.cdc.gov/features/salmonellaeggs/index.html

  • This was tasty, but it didn’t taste like cookie dough to me. I have eaten plenty to know!  Perhaps more like a peanut butter cup. Wasn’t what I was expecting, but a delightful treat nonetheless. 

    1
  • I LOVE THIS COOKIE DOUGH SO MUCH THAT THE WHOLE RECIPE IS LOCKED INTO MY BRAIN! It is literally THE ONLY COOKIE DOUGH that turns into DOUGH and not LIQUID! I found this from a pure coincidence two weeks ago and I am so glad that I did.5 stars

  • How about using oat flour instead? I use my coffee bean grinder to pulverize oatmeal until it’s the consistency of regular flour.

    1. Hi Dylan! I have not tried to make the recipe with oat flour, so I’m afraid I don’t have any specific advice to offer. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!

  • This looks delicious! Can I use regular flour? It’s hard to find certain varieties of flour nowadays so I only have regular ol white flour. Thanks! 

    1. Hi Kate! I haven’t tried this recipe with regular flour, but you could experiment with it. Just make sure you cook the flour as directed first. I hope you enjoy it!

  • Can u substitute coconut or almond flour in stead of whole wheat flour?  I eat gluten free and would love to make this recipe. Thanks 

    1. Hi Lauri! I’ve never tried this recipe with either flour, so it would be an experiment. You could also try using gluten free flour. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to hear how it goes!

  • Can this be made low carb?, With almond flour and/or coconut flour? If so, how much of each? If one, will either one work? Does the flour (coconut &/or almond flour still need to be cooked?
    Can egg substitute be used as it’s not raw eggs? Sorry for all the questions, but I’m not sure of substitutions & use the south beach diet.
    Thank you.

    1. Hi Jill! I’ve never tried this recipe with either flour, so it would be an experiment. The almond flour would not need to be cooked. This recipe wasn’t designed to use eggs, so you do not need to include an egg substitute. You might also enjoy these Coconut Flour Cookies or Almond Flour Cookies for low-carb options. I hope this helps!

  • Made this for my Cookie Monster who also loves peanut butter, and it was a huge hit! Thanks for what has to be the 100th recipe of yours that we love, Erin!!!!5 stars

  • Yum, this is tasty! Maybe it’s because I’m reading from Canada but I don’t know what Toll House cookie dough tastes like. I was looking more for a classic vanilla-ey cookie dough recipe, this tastes more like peanut butter cookie dough so maybe the title of the recipe could use a do-over :). It is still tasty though, just not what I was after.4 stars

  • I had my twin grandsons (age 3) help make the cookie dough. Once the dough was finished, we all nibbled and nibbled and nibbled… So good! More so because it is a safe recipe with no eggs.5 stars

  • This recipe was so good I’m a high school student so this was a nice treat after testing though I would use a little less butter.5 stars

    1. Hi Natalie, I have’t tried it myself, but maybe almond extract or maple syrup. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it comes out!