In the late 60s and early 70s, when I didn’t have time to make pizza from scratch, I would throw these together. Mine always had to have pepperoni. Thanks for the trip down memory lane!
Wonderful idea! As you said, the key is toasting the split muffins slightly before adding the sauce and toppings, then returning them to the oven. Thank you for a great idea for a quick and easy lunch that my grandchildren enjoyed! I’ll be making these again!
What a DELICIOUS recipe. I am crazy about pizza but the calories are just too much, so this is the perfect solution. I made them for the first time a few days ago for my boyfriend and me and he loved them just as much. He said he never wants any other pizza again. I used turkey pepperoni since it has less fat and a bit more pizza sauce than suggested. They came out so good, I had them two days in a row. THANK YOU for all your amazing recipes, I’m so happy I came across your website and finally found the motivation and inspiration to cook.
We toast the english muffin in the toaster. Then thinly spread my husband’s homemade Italian sausage that chopped onion has been mixed into; right out to the edges so the muffin doesn’t burn. Broil till the sausage is done.
Top with pizza sauce and shredded mozzarella plus pepperoni and black olives for my husband.
Pop back under the broiler till the cheese is slightly browned. This was my mother in law’s recipe but she used seasoned hamburger.
We love these as a treat or a quick meal. Road trips ect… I’m using a jar sauce and there’s always so much left over. Can I freeze this sauce? If so how long? Thank you so much!!
I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed them, Femali! Thank you for sharing this kind review! Since I don’t know the specifics of the brand you’re using, I recommend referring to any freezing instructions on your jar of sauce or the company’s website, but most jarred sauces can be frozen. I hope this helps!
If you’re looking for one of the simplest weeknight meals that’s ultra delicious, make this recipe! This is definitely what I’ll be going for in the future when I want something good and comforting, but also something that takes little to no time to prepare!
These are a family hit!!! So easy to make and fun! Made an extra batch so that I can freeze them and have them for quick lunches! They will hear up in the air fryer super easy!
We used to make these when I was a kid and I hated them because they were so soggy in the middles. I saw someone mention muffin pizzas recently, and I had a burst of nostalgia. I decided to see if there were any suggestions about toasting or cooking them before topping and found this recipe. This worked great, other than mine were done cooking well before 10 minutes. Topped mine with pizza sauce, turkey pepperoni, pineapple, red bell pepper, and mozzarella. I would add a little bit of hot pepper flakes into the pizza sauce next time just to perk them up a little bit more.
my mother used to use cheese whiz spread some on muffin before the sauce for topping helps keep it from soggy and also add a good flavor i always wondered down the years too why my mothers tasted better then other people made them was the cheese whiz
My mom made these when I was growing up. A couple of things I’ve found that work for me: Although I don’t pre-toast the muffins, I do use spaghetti sauce in place of pizza sauce. (You get more sauce for less money and can get it with meat in the sauce and I’m all about easy.) Also, I tried to make them on those thin round slices to keep the bread to a minimum, like a thin crust pizza. The sauce does make them harder to hold than an English muffin would be. Adding Italian seasoning when I can find it makes them taste more authentic to me.
Need to review this because I’ve made English muffin pizzas for many years the standard way and they were never this good. I was looking for a little tweak and found it here!
The drizzle of olive oil when initially toasting is what took it over the top. I used EVOO and the inexpensive supermarket brand English muffins. My family was really happy! They said these were the best we ever made. Thank you very much for sharing!!
OMG! Haven’t thought of these in years!
In the late 60s and early 70s, when I didn’t have time to make pizza from scratch, I would throw these together. Mine always had to have pepperoni. Thanks for the trip down memory lane!
Peggy, they are just as delicious as ever!! And the pepperoni was spot on. Hope you enjoy them and glad it brought back happy memories!
We make these for a quick meal idea! They look so delicious!
I’m so happy to hear this, Karly! I hope you love them!
Wonderful idea! As you said, the key is toasting the split muffins slightly before adding the sauce and toppings, then returning them to the oven. Thank you for a great idea for a quick and easy lunch that my grandchildren enjoyed! I’ll be making these again!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Patti! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This is fantastic! I made it exactly as is, and it’s very, very good.
Thank you for trying this recipe and taking the time to share your success, Rewari!
yummy…!!! Thanks for sharing this easy recipe. I really like your post.
Thank you for taking the time to leave this kind review, Varun!
It looks delicious and quick, a good combination! I’ll try it, thanks for sharing :)
I hope you love the recipe, Noemi!
This was very fun to make and quick and easy! I made these and my family was like “Can I have a bite?” So, I had to make more XD
Love it. Thanks for sharing this recipe.
I’m so pleased that this was a hit, Manaia! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
What a DELICIOUS recipe. I am crazy about pizza but the calories are just too much, so this is the perfect solution. I made them for the first time a few days ago for my boyfriend and me and he loved them just as much. He said he never wants any other pizza again. I used turkey pepperoni since it has less fat and a bit more pizza sauce than suggested. They came out so good, I had them two days in a row. THANK YOU for all your amazing recipes, I’m so happy I came across your website and finally found the motivation and inspiration to cook.
Joey, I am so pleased to hear it! Thanks for sharing this lovely review!
We toast the english muffin in the toaster. Then thinly spread my husband’s homemade Italian sausage that chopped onion has been mixed into; right out to the edges so the muffin doesn’t burn. Broil till the sausage is done.
Top with pizza sauce and shredded mozzarella plus pepperoni and black olives for my husband.
Pop back under the broiler till the cheese is slightly browned. This was my mother in law’s recipe but she used seasoned hamburger.
I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed the recipe, Valerie! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
We love these as a treat or a quick meal. Road trips ect… I’m using a jar sauce and there’s always so much left over. Can I freeze this sauce? If so how long? Thank you so much!!
I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed them, Femali! Thank you for sharing this kind review! Since I don’t know the specifics of the brand you’re using, I recommend referring to any freezing instructions on your jar of sauce or the company’s website, but most jarred sauces can be frozen. I hope this helps!
If you’re looking for one of the simplest weeknight meals that’s ultra delicious, make this recipe! This is definitely what I’ll be going for in the future when I want something good and comforting, but also something that takes little to no time to prepare!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Allie! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Thanks for this recipe! Delish! When defrosting can I pop them into the microwave instead of the overn? Thanks!
Hi Gail! You probably could. The microwave just tends to make the muffin chewier then toasting them. Hope you enjoy it!
I make the English muffins pizzas for my husband, he loves them! Thank you for the recipe 😀
Hi Lin! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
These are a family hit!!! So easy to make and fun! Made an extra batch so that I can freeze them and have them for quick lunches! They will hear up in the air fryer super easy!
Hi Dawn! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Delicious!! Would t change a thing!
Hi Maggie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
We used to make these when I was a kid and I hated them because they were so soggy in the middles. I saw someone mention muffin pizzas recently, and I had a burst of nostalgia. I decided to see if there were any suggestions about toasting or cooking them before topping and found this recipe. This worked great, other than mine were done cooking well before 10 minutes. Topped mine with pizza sauce, turkey pepperoni, pineapple, red bell pepper, and mozzarella. I would add a little bit of hot pepper flakes into the pizza sauce next time just to perk them up a little bit more.
Hi Essess! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
These were delicious! I can’t count the number of homemade pizzas I’ve thrown out and these came out perfectly. Thank you for sharing your ideas.
Hi Sonya! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
my mother used to use cheese whiz spread some on muffin before the sauce for topping helps keep it from soggy and also add a good flavor i always wondered down the years too why my mothers tasted better then other people made them was the cheese whiz
I hope you enjoy this version Kyle!
My mom made these when I was growing up. A couple of things I’ve found that work for me: Although I don’t pre-toast the muffins, I do use spaghetti sauce in place of pizza sauce. (You get more sauce for less money and can get it with meat in the sauce and I’m all about easy.) Also, I tried to make them on those thin round slices to keep the bread to a minimum, like a thin crust pizza. The sauce does make them harder to hold than an English muffin would be. Adding Italian seasoning when I can find it makes them taste more authentic to me.
Glad it brings back memories for you Mary Kay!
I haven’t had these pizzas in years and wanted a refresher idea on how to make them
YAY, so glad to hear it!
Need to review this because I’ve made English muffin pizzas for many years the standard way and they were never this good. I was looking for a little tweak and found it here!
The drizzle of olive oil when initially toasting is what took it over the top. I used EVOO and the inexpensive supermarket brand English muffins. My family was really happy! They said these were the best we ever made. Thank you very much for sharing!!
Hi Joanne! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!