I love this kind of thing, that is – Not time critical in its prparation.
I should do this again. I have in the past, ages ago. I have no idea why not since?
Have made this twice with tilapia, and it’s just delicious! Getting ready to make it again tonight, and wanted to let you know what a great recipe this is. Love that you add variations, too. Thanks!!!
Can you bake it at 350 degrees? I need my oven at that temp for something else I’m making. How long should I bake it for at lower temperature? Guessing about 30 minutes.
Debbie, I’ve only baked fish at a higher temp, but I think that would be fine. You’ll just need to extend the time by a few minutes. I’d check early to make sure the fish doesn’t overcook. I hope you enjoy it!
Delicious! Easy. A total winner. Served this twice in two weeks to guests and it was a hit. Really easy to prepare. I served it with warm sour dough garlic bread and salad. The bread was useful to mop us the delicious sauce .
how do I check fish is done without opening pouch, it was still translucent, too hot to reseal pouch,
Can I use probe thermometer and poke a hole in pouch?
Hi David! Mine are normally done at the baking time so I never really have to check. I’ve not used a probe thermometer before on these. If you decide to experiment let me know how it goes!
I agree with David. The instructions say “12-15 minutes until fish is fully cooked through and flakes easily with a fork.” First, 6 oz filets can be different thicknesses (requiring more or less cooking time) and second, how do you know if it’s fully cooked and flakes easily unless you open the packet. If it’s not fully cooked, you have to wrap it back up.
Hi Laura, I do understand what you are saying but the instructions are written based on how I tested the recipe. If there is any question as to if the fish is done, you will need to open it and take a peak.
Absolutely amazing! This is a favourite recipe in our house. I love to cook but have a newborn and look for easy recipes. This is a crowd pleaser for sure too.
This was delicious! I rarely leave reviews, but such a simple recipe yet it turned out so flavorful. I just followed the recipe as is. Family loved it too. Thanks!
This was so simple to make plus clean up was a breeze! I didn’t have a shallot so I used part of a leek and I used spinach, bok choy, and asparagus for the veggies. The first two were steamed too much for all four of us’ liking but we still enjoyed the flavors! I would definitely make this again with more asparagus and experiment with other veggies.
Just made your recipe for my husband & I for dinner. He loved it! Since we have so much yellow squash and zucchini from the garden, I sliced some of those very thin and placed the fish on that rather than greens. Other than that, I followed your recipe and it was delicious! I was worried it might not be done since I couldn’t see inside the parchment pockets, but it was cooked perfectly!
Thank you!
Great recipe. I stick with the parchment paper, the timing, and the oven temperature. So far, have tried it with salmon, pike, burbot, and lake trout. Have switched out the veggies for fennel fronds, pea shoots, cucumber slices. whatever would work from the garden, really. Thanks for a good recipe
I’ve made this before with Chilean Sea Bass and it was great but tried it with Halibut and it was dry and kind of tough. They were thicker slices so I left them in the oven longer. Was the failure because of being in the oven longer (over-cooked) or was it something with the fish itself? Got it from Whole Foods (they were out of Sea Bass).
Glad it worked well with the sea bass, Megan. I would try cooking it for the suggested amount of time, then checking it before adding any more cook time, just to be sure it doesn’t over cook. Hope this helps!
I love this kind of thing, that is – Not time critical in its prparation.
I should do this again. I have in the past, ages ago. I have no idea why not since?
Thanks for this kind comment, James! I hope you enjoy the recipe if you try it!
This fish was so moist and flavorful! I’m new to baking with fish but this method made it super easy. Thank you!
I’m so pleased to hear that you enjoyed this recipe, Danielle! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Have made this twice with tilapia, and it’s just delicious! Getting ready to make it again tonight, and wanted to let you know what a great recipe this is. Love that you add variations, too. Thanks!!!
I’m so happy to hear that you’ve enjoyed this recipe, Kelly! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Can you bake it at 350 degrees? I need my oven at that temp for something else I’m making. How long should I bake it for at lower temperature? Guessing about 30 minutes.
Debbie, I’ve only baked fish at a higher temp, but I think that would be fine. You’ll just need to extend the time by a few minutes. I’d check early to make sure the fish doesn’t overcook. I hope you enjoy it!
This was absolutely delicious! I made it with Chilean sea bass and it was perfect! The flavors are chefs kiss!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Sarah! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Delicious! Easy. A total winner. Served this twice in two weeks to guests and it was a hit. Really easy to prepare. I served it with warm sour dough garlic bread and salad. The bread was useful to mop us the delicious sauce .
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Tina! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
do you have a bread bowl and soup recipe to pair with the fish en papilliot?
Hi Cyndy! You can find all my soup recipes here: https://www.wellplated.com/category/recipes-by-type/soupsstews/. I hope you find something that sounds tasty!
how do I check fish is done without opening pouch, it was still translucent, too hot to reseal pouch,
Can I use probe thermometer and poke a hole in pouch?
Hi David! Mine are normally done at the baking time so I never really have to check. I’ve not used a probe thermometer before on these. If you decide to experiment let me know how it goes!
I agree with David. The instructions say “12-15 minutes until fish is fully cooked through and flakes easily with a fork.” First, 6 oz filets can be different thicknesses (requiring more or less cooking time) and second, how do you know if it’s fully cooked and flakes easily unless you open the packet. If it’s not fully cooked, you have to wrap it back up.
Hi Laura, I do understand what you are saying but the instructions are written based on how I tested the recipe. If there is any question as to if the fish is done, you will need to open it and take a peak.
Absolutely amazing! This is a favourite recipe in our house. I love to cook but have a newborn and look for easy recipes. This is a crowd pleaser for sure too.
Hi Lisa! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I would like to try this with rainbow trout. Can Vegan I Cann’t Believe It’s Not Butter be used as a substitute for Land of Lakes butter?
Hi George, although I haven’t tried it, I am sure you can use any butter you’d like! Hope you enjoy it!
Thanks Erin
This was delicious! I rarely leave reviews, but such a simple recipe yet it turned out so flavorful. I just followed the recipe as is. Family loved it too. Thanks!
Hi Dani! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Hi! Would frozen fish that’s been thawed work for this recipe?
Hi Hazel! It should work! Enjoy!
It will. I used this recipe to cook thawed barramundi and it was delicious
Thanks for the tip, Chris!
Used cod, salad base of kale & romaine, sprig of thyme.
Hi PhillyMama! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This was so simple to make plus clean up was a breeze! I didn’t have a shallot so I used part of a leek and I used spinach, bok choy, and asparagus for the veggies. The first two were steamed too much for all four of us’ liking but we still enjoyed the flavors! I would definitely make this again with more asparagus and experiment with other veggies.
Hi Lynn! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Just made your recipe for my husband & I for dinner. He loved it! Since we have so much yellow squash and zucchini from the garden, I sliced some of those very thin and placed the fish on that rather than greens. Other than that, I followed your recipe and it was delicious! I was worried it might not be done since I couldn’t see inside the parchment pockets, but it was cooked perfectly!
Thank you!
Hi Patty! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Made this tonight and it was a hit. I used freeze dried dill instead of parsley because we love dill with fish. Thanks for the new way to cook fish.
Glad to hear you enjoyed it, Becky!
What a great recipe!
I served it to several “I don’t like fish” guests and they asked for seconds!!
Yay! Love to hear that! Thank you!
Great recipe. I stick with the parchment paper, the timing, and the oven temperature. So far, have tried it with salmon, pike, burbot, and lake trout. Have switched out the veggies for fennel fronds, pea shoots, cucumber slices. whatever would work from the garden, really. Thanks for a good recipe
So glad to hear you are enjoying the recipe and method! Thank you!
We absolutely loved it!
Thanks Steve!
I’ve made this before with Chilean Sea Bass and it was great but tried it with Halibut and it was dry and kind of tough. They were thicker slices so I left them in the oven longer. Was the failure because of being in the oven longer (over-cooked) or was it something with the fish itself? Got it from Whole Foods (they were out of Sea Bass).
Tips anyone?
Glad it worked well with the sea bass, Megan. I would try cooking it for the suggested amount of time, then checking it before adding any more cook time, just to be sure it doesn’t over cook. Hope this helps!