Sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, James. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
This was a very flavorful and easy recipe. I made it in the slow cooker and used boneless, skinless chicken thighs. It was lunch for four days. My husband brings his lunch to work and his office has a microwave available. He said it was delicious. I made it just as listed, except did not add garlic cloves; I served it on rice. This dish fits well into our Weight Watcher Program! Thank you for posting.
This was delicious! I served it with feta and a Greek salad and my husband, my son and myself loved it! Definitely saving the recipe to make again. I cooked it on high for 1.5 hours, chicken wasn’t quite up to temperature, so I put it back for another 30 min – next time will do just an extra 15.
My family absolutely loves this recipe. I substitute sun dried tomatoes for the peppers & add about 1/4 C orzo about 30 min before we eat. Sooooo yummy!!!
I do cook mine longer than what the recipe says & the chicken just falls apart.
Serve w/ crusty bread. 🤗
I did this with thighs and put it on angel hair. I have an instant pot so getting the peppers, onions, and olives beside the chicken instead of on top was tricky, but I did high for 3:30 and it came out juicy and delicious.
BEYOND DELICIOUS 😍 my partner and I absolutely loved this dish and it went great over couscous. Next time we’re going to add a little tzatziki to add a little kick!
My wife & daughter were returning from a weekend trip, so I wanted a crockpot chicken recipe that we had not tried before. This one was spectacular & everyone loved it. It took very little time to prep and this will become one of our regulars. Well done Erin!
Such a great base recipe Erin. We’re in Australia and we bulked it up with lots of broccoli florets and diced stems, lemon wedges and a cup of vegeta vegetable stock powder with warm water at the 2 hour time (on low). Added 1 cup of Orzo so soak up the lemony garlic pepper flavours about 10 mins before serving. This was so darn delicious I just had to say this is an easiest base recipe to explore any flavour combos. Definitely making it many ways into the future ❤️❤️
Absolutely Delicious! This recipe was a great base for a vegetarian version. I omitted the chicken. I added artichokes, capers, sun dried tomatoes to your recipe. I have a salty/savory feta that I make out of tofu.
The first time, I had this over pasta – delicious. The second time over quinoa.
I slather it in my tofu feta and my goodness this is so good. Thanks for the recipe. I will be making this regularly.
When the occasion happens that I have a meat eater to feed, I’ll make an extra batch of the red wine vinegar dressing and marinate the chicken for a few hours and then broil it for their plate.
This was wonderfully mouthwateringly delicious and it is now my top 3 recipe.
A tip for those who experience issues with liquid in the pot – do not overcrowd your pot. If your pot is too small for 2 lbs of chicken, you may want to scale down to 1 lb.
Don’t forget to drain the peppers, do chop the onion, and if you’re half way through cooking and the liquid has collected, use a ladle to scoop it out! I also cooked my chicken longer than the recipe calls for. Each crockpot is different!
Love this recipe and it’s a regular in my rotation. I use chicken breast and shred it at the end and then serve it over basmati rice w/naan on the side. We love the juice so I double those ingredients. Delicious!
Good flavor but waaay too oily. I used chicken thighs (with skin) and it came out tasting good, but was really wet. I’ll adjust the amount of oil next time!
Delicious! I used boneless skinless thighs and didn’t add quite as much lemon as the recipe called for but it was still good. I love how satisfying this meal is without being complicated. My son loved it and asked for leftovers for his lunch. Thank you, Erin!
Did this recently change from being a slow cooker recipe?? I had this in my dinner queue for the month and this doesn’t look like the recipe I planned for…
The marinade made the chicken so tender, flavorful and juicy. I made this recipe last night and served it with homemade focaccia bread topped with cherry tomatoes from my garden. So good! Btw I love your website and recipes! It’s my go to for classic dishes and for some new food adventures. Thank you!
So simple and honestly it is amazing. I really love it with boneless skin on chicken thighs or breasts. Made this along with herb potatoes and iceberg salad it was a delicious meal.
Even after searing the chicken before, putting it in the slow cooker, the chicken turned to leather. This is not a good recipe at all.
Sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, James. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
This was a very flavorful and easy recipe. I made it in the slow cooker and used boneless, skinless chicken thighs. It was lunch for four days. My husband brings his lunch to work and his office has a microwave available. He said it was delicious. I made it just as listed, except did not add garlic cloves; I served it on rice. This dish fits well into our Weight Watcher Program! Thank you for posting.
Hi Michele! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This was delicious! I served it with feta and a Greek salad and my husband, my son and myself loved it! Definitely saving the recipe to make again. I cooked it on high for 1.5 hours, chicken wasn’t quite up to temperature, so I put it back for another 30 min – next time will do just an extra 15.
Hi Allison! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
My family absolutely loves this recipe. I substitute sun dried tomatoes for the peppers & add about 1/4 C orzo about 30 min before we eat. Sooooo yummy!!!
I do cook mine longer than what the recipe says & the chicken just falls apart.
Serve w/ crusty bread. 🤗
Hi Kathy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review and feedback on changes!
Hi Kathy, I’m curious – did you add additional liquid for the orzo? Thank you!
I did this with thighs and put it on angel hair. I have an instant pot so getting the peppers, onions, and olives beside the chicken instead of on top was tricky, but I did high for 3:30 and it came out juicy and delicious.
That’s great to hear! Thank you!
Thanks Charles! Was hoping someone would post and try this!
BEYOND DELICIOUS 😍 my partner and I absolutely loved this dish and it went great over couscous. Next time we’re going to add a little tzatziki to add a little kick!
Yay! Thank you Matthew!
Very tasty but chicken dried out cooking it for 3 1/2 hours on High.
Next time three should do the trick!
Thanks for the feedback Andrea!
Loved this recipe. Will definitely make it again.
Great to hear, thank you Sylvie!
My wife & daughter were returning from a weekend trip, so I wanted a crockpot chicken recipe that we had not tried before. This one was spectacular & everyone loved it. It took very little time to prep and this will become one of our regulars. Well done Erin!
So glad you enjoyed it, John! Thank you!
Such a great base recipe Erin. We’re in Australia and we bulked it up with lots of broccoli florets and diced stems, lemon wedges and a cup of vegeta vegetable stock powder with warm water at the 2 hour time (on low). Added 1 cup of Orzo so soak up the lemony garlic pepper flavours about 10 mins before serving. This was so darn delicious I just had to say this is an easiest base recipe to explore any flavour combos. Definitely making it many ways into the future ❤️❤️
Great idea, thank you Tracy!
Absolutely Delicious! This recipe was a great base for a vegetarian version. I omitted the chicken. I added artichokes, capers, sun dried tomatoes to your recipe. I have a salty/savory feta that I make out of tofu.
The first time, I had this over pasta – delicious. The second time over quinoa.
I slather it in my tofu feta and my goodness this is so good. Thanks for the recipe. I will be making this regularly.
When the occasion happens that I have a meat eater to feed, I’ll make an extra batch of the red wine vinegar dressing and marinate the chicken for a few hours and then broil it for their plate.
Glad to hear you enjoyed it, Tammy!
This was wonderfully mouthwateringly delicious and it is now my top 3 recipe.
A tip for those who experience issues with liquid in the pot – do not overcrowd your pot. If your pot is too small for 2 lbs of chicken, you may want to scale down to 1 lb.
Don’t forget to drain the peppers, do chop the onion, and if you’re half way through cooking and the liquid has collected, use a ladle to scoop it out! I also cooked my chicken longer than the recipe calls for. Each crockpot is different!
Thanks for the tips, Emi! Glad you enjoyed it!
Love this recipe and it’s a regular in my rotation. I use chicken breast and shred it at the end and then serve it over basmati rice w/naan on the side. We love the juice so I double those ingredients. Delicious!
Thanks Crystal!
Can I add baby potato’s directly to the crockpot with the chicken? Do you think it would work? I’d like to make it all in one, if possibke
Hi Sammy, I’m sure you could. I’d check out this method for cook times: https://www.wellplated.com/crockpot-chicken-and-potatoes/ ENJOY!
Good flavor but waaay too oily. I used chicken thighs (with skin) and it came out tasting good, but was really wet. I’ll adjust the amount of oil next time!
Thanks for the feedback, Olivia!
Delicious! I used boneless skinless thighs and didn’t add quite as much lemon as the recipe called for but it was still good. I love how satisfying this meal is without being complicated. My son loved it and asked for leftovers for his lunch. Thank you, Erin!
Great to hear, thank you Mylene!
Did this recently change from being a slow cooker recipe?? I had this in my dinner queue for the month and this doesn’t look like the recipe I planned for…
Hi Missy! Nope, this is a new version. Here is the slow cooker version: https://www.wellplated.com/slow-cooker-greek-chicken/ Enjoy!
The marinade made the chicken so tender, flavorful and juicy. I made this recipe last night and served it with homemade focaccia bread topped with cherry tomatoes from my garden. So good! Btw I love your website and recipes! It’s my go to for classic dishes and for some new food adventures. Thank you!
Thank you so much, Harper!
So simple and honestly it is amazing. I really love it with boneless skin on chicken thighs or breasts. Made this along with herb potatoes and iceberg salad it was a delicious meal.
Thank you Helen!
This use to be a slow cooker recipe but it’s changed. Any chance I can get the old recipe?
Hi James, Here is the slow cooker version: https://www.wellplated.com/slow-cooker-greek-chicken/ Enjoy!