Hi Erin, Just wanted to let you know I did make this cake and loved it! Like you said, MOIST is the word. But not like moist from too much oil or butter, but moist from all the juicy ingredients you include, all those carrots, the pineapple, the raisins…. so good.
To make it a bit healthier, I reduced the sugar by half and found it tasted just fine (I reduce the sugar by half in all my sweet baking and not even my sweet tooth husband and in laws ever miss it, and i find it helps you appreciate the other flavors better), and also used unsweetened coconut. Due to all that moisture it took a bit longer to bake but that will probably depend on your oven. This might be my definitive birthday carrot cake recipe :) !
Ana, I am so excited to hear that you love this cake and that it turned out as wonderfully moist for you as it did for me! Great tip about the reduced sugar too. As always, it makes my day to hear that you try and enjoy my recipes. Thank you so much for letting me know!
Hi Erin, this cake looks scrumptious and I am so excited to make it for my in-laws’ Easter dinner! Quick question: can I frost the cake the evening before its eaten? Or would I need to frost it immediately before eating in case the greek yogurt causes the frosting to soak into the cake? If it is possible to frost it in advance, should I store the frosted cake in the fridge until its time to eat it? Thanks so much!
Great questions Mary! If it all possible, I would try to frost the cake the day that you serve it, though you could certainly do it several hours in advance. That way, you don’t have to put plastic wrap over it and mess up the frosting. Keep it in the fridge until an hour or so before you are ready to serve, and then you can pull it out to allow the cake to come to room temperature. I hope you all love it! Let me know if you have any other questions.
I made this today for Easter. Every one of my guests loved it! The cake has such good flavor and it was so moist. I loved how easy it was to make. You couldn’t even tell the cream cheese frosting was “light” and had yogurt in it. I’ll be making this again and again. Thank you!
Toni, this comment makes my day! This is one of my all-time favorite cakes, so it brings me special joy to hear your family enjoyed it. Happy Easter, and thanks for letting me know!
Can this cake be made with Gluten Free flour? I know Bob’s Red Mill has a 1:1 flour for the all-purpose flour but what could be substituted for the Whole Wheat Pastry Flour?
My sister has to eat gluten free and I’d really love for her to enjoy this dessert on Easter without having to make something separate for her.
Thank you Erin!
Ooh, I just saw your reply to Rebecca below. I wasn’t aware the 1:1 could be swapped with the whole wheat flour. I’ll give it a try and see how that comes out.
Thank you again!
You are welcome Toni! I’d love to hear how it comes out if you try it!
Love the ingredients you’ve incorporated…I always love to,load up the flavors in my baked goods! Recently discovered my daughter in gluten intolerant, so I am trying to convert some recipes to gluten free. Have found a large difference in taste and texture switching to gluten free flours, so I’m wondering if you have had any experience or suggestions on converting your recipe to gluten free?
Thx for any help you can give!
Hi Rebecca! That is a great question, and I’m going to be 100% honest that I am not a very experienced gluten free baker. One product I have had success with is Bob’s Red Mill 1:1 Gluten Free BakingFlour, which can be swapped for the same amount of regular all purpose or whole wheat flour. You can find it on the Bob’s Red Mill website or on Amazon here—> http://amzn.to/1LapXm0. That might not be ideal, but I hope it at least gives you an option!
Hi Maggie, I’ve never tried this recipe as cupcakes, but I know most cupcake recipes bake in 20 to 30 minutes, but this is a very moist cake, so it might turn out differently. I’d start checking at the 18-minute mark, then just keep a close eye.
Hi MJ! Whole wheat pastry flour is much finer than regular whole wheat flour, so I actually wouldn’t recommend that substitution, as the cake will probably be too dense. If you don’t have whole wheat pastry flour, I would suggest using all purpose flour instead. I hope you love the cake!
Hi! I used regular whole wheat flour and then read this comment—oops! But I tried the cake and it’s still delicious. It may be denser than your recipe, but we still ended up with a delicious cake. Thanks for the great recipe!
My sister is a die-hard carrot cake fan so when I told her I could make her a healthier version for her 26th birthday, she was all for it! Not only did this cake look beautiful (I was sad to cut into it!) but it had such great flavor! No one could tell that it was a lighter version than the typical carrot cake. It was a HUGE hit among my family and I just wanted to thank you for allowing me to eat an amazing desert and not feel guilty about it! Oh, and for giving all of us home bakers a chance to show off to our families! This will surely become my go-to carrot cake!
P.S. Do you know how the cooking time/temperature would vary if made into cupcakes?
Julia, I am thrilled to bits to hear this!!! It’s exactly the kind of comment that lights up my day :) THANK YOU!
I’ve never tried these as cupcakes, but I think it would work just fine! To play it safest, you can keep the oven temp at 350 degrees, though they will have a flatter top, or for a more domed top try 375 (the higher temp will help them rise faster, though I’m a tiny bit worried they *might* over cook on top before the middle is done—it’s just hard to say without having tried it myself). Either way, start checking at 15 minutes and go from there. If you try the cupcake route, I’d love to hear what temp/time you choose and how they turn out!
Hi Erin, I’m glad I made this and would do so again b/c the healthiness of the whole wheat pastry flour didn’t diminish the tenderness of the carrot cake and the frosting has that classic cream cheese frosting we all associate w/ carrot cake. However, for my palate, next time I make it without the cinnamon as it had a presence I don’t associate w/ carrot cake that was a bit strong for me. Also when almost done making the frosting I thought it tasted pretty sweet – & though I’m a I-love-a-brownie-sundae kind of a gal – I’m also one who’s trying to decrease my overall sugar intake and ratchet down my palate to be happier w/ less sugar. Given that and wanting more frosting on my carrot cake than shown in your photos, I opted to use @ 5+ oz. of cream cheese and almost an entire 4 oz. yogurt serving to increase the volume of frosting produced while simultaneously cutting the sweetness. It worked great. The texture still smooth and still plenty sweet. I look forward to trying other recipes of yours. :) Thanks, Susan Chapin Musicant
Hi Cynthia! I would be hesitant to recommend this, as applesauce is more liquidy and not sweet enough. The pineapple is both naturally more sweet and gives the cake the right texture. I hope you love the recipe if you decide to give it a try!
Hi Roz! Since I don’t have a medical background, I’d check with your father’s doctor. I’d hate to give you advice that isn’t correct and want to be safe!
Hi April! I’ve already cut as much fat out of this as I can, so I wouldn’t recommend applesauce, as I worry the cake would end up dry/gummy. If you wanted to experiment, you could try swapping half of the oil with the same amount of unsweetened applesauce, but it may impact the results negatively. If you decide to play around, I’d love to hear how it goes!
With just a few ingredient changes(INTENTIONALLY AND NOT;) ) the cake I made was really good….moist AND full of flavour…really tasted like MORE!
THANX FOR THE INPUT
Hi Linda! I’ve only tested this recipe as written so I wouldn’t be able to advise on what to do if using a different flour. I do have a coconut flour cake: https://www.wellplated.com/coconut-flour-cake/ Hope this helps!
WINNER! This was the perfect cake for a few reasons:
1) single layer (smaller easter gathering, didn’t need a double-decker!)
2) healthier
3) spice notes were perfect
4) moistness (like wow!)
5) everyone LOVED it :-)
My frosting was runnier than I was expecting, but it was probably my greek yogurt (super runny for some reason?), but a short rest in the fridge (plus some extra powdered sugar) fixed it!
Made this per recipie, looked great & toothpick came out clean , frosting great. BUT, when I cut into it, it was doughy! Couldn’t eat it. Very disappointed as it was a birthday cake. Don’t know what happened. Baked at 350 degrees for 40 minutes in spring pan. ???
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Dar. The method and timing has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
Hi Erin, I didn’t make the cake, but I used the frosting recipe with some homemade whipped cream folded in for my son’s first birthday cupcake. Thank you <3
Hi Erin, Just wanted to let you know I did make this cake and loved it! Like you said, MOIST is the word. But not like moist from too much oil or butter, but moist from all the juicy ingredients you include, all those carrots, the pineapple, the raisins…. so good.
To make it a bit healthier, I reduced the sugar by half and found it tasted just fine (I reduce the sugar by half in all my sweet baking and not even my sweet tooth husband and in laws ever miss it, and i find it helps you appreciate the other flavors better), and also used unsweetened coconut. Due to all that moisture it took a bit longer to bake but that will probably depend on your oven. This might be my definitive birthday carrot cake recipe :) !
thanks so much for sharing another great recipe!
Ana, I am so excited to hear that you love this cake and that it turned out as wonderfully moist for you as it did for me! Great tip about the reduced sugar too. As always, it makes my day to hear that you try and enjoy my recipes. Thank you so much for letting me know!
Hi Erin, this cake looks scrumptious and I am so excited to make it for my in-laws’ Easter dinner! Quick question: can I frost the cake the evening before its eaten? Or would I need to frost it immediately before eating in case the greek yogurt causes the frosting to soak into the cake? If it is possible to frost it in advance, should I store the frosted cake in the fridge until its time to eat it? Thanks so much!
Great questions Mary! If it all possible, I would try to frost the cake the day that you serve it, though you could certainly do it several hours in advance. That way, you don’t have to put plastic wrap over it and mess up the frosting. Keep it in the fridge until an hour or so before you are ready to serve, and then you can pull it out to allow the cake to come to room temperature. I hope you all love it! Let me know if you have any other questions.
I made this today for Easter. Every one of my guests loved it! The cake has such good flavor and it was so moist. I loved how easy it was to make. You couldn’t even tell the cream cheese frosting was “light” and had yogurt in it. I’ll be making this again and again. Thank you!
Toni, this comment makes my day! This is one of my all-time favorite cakes, so it brings me special joy to hear your family enjoyed it. Happy Easter, and thanks for letting me know!
Can this cake be made with Gluten Free flour? I know Bob’s Red Mill has a 1:1 flour for the all-purpose flour but what could be substituted for the Whole Wheat Pastry Flour?
My sister has to eat gluten free and I’d really love for her to enjoy this dessert on Easter without having to make something separate for her.
Thank you Erin!
Ooh, I just saw your reply to Rebecca below. I wasn’t aware the 1:1 could be swapped with the whole wheat flour. I’ll give it a try and see how that comes out.
Thank you again!
You are welcome Toni! I’d love to hear how it comes out if you try it!
Love the ingredients you’ve incorporated…I always love to,load up the flavors in my baked goods! Recently discovered my daughter in gluten intolerant, so I am trying to convert some recipes to gluten free. Have found a large difference in taste and texture switching to gluten free flours, so I’m wondering if you have had any experience or suggestions on converting your recipe to gluten free?
Thx for any help you can give!
Hi Rebecca! That is a great question, and I’m going to be 100% honest that I am not a very experienced gluten free baker. One product I have had success with is Bob’s Red Mill 1:1 Gluten Free BakingFlour, which can be swapped for the same amount of regular all purpose or whole wheat flour. You can find it on the Bob’s Red Mill website or on Amazon here—> http://amzn.to/1LapXm0. That might not be ideal, but I hope it at least gives you an option!
If making as cupcakes, do you have a timing suggestion? Thank you!
Hi Maggie, I’ve never tried this recipe as cupcakes, but I know most cupcake recipes bake in 20 to 30 minutes, but this is a very moist cake, so it might turn out differently. I’d start checking at the 18-minute mark, then just keep a close eye.
Not a big fan of coconut. Have you ever made this without it? If not, do you think it would still be good? Any substitutes for it?
Hi Catherine! You can simply omit it. Enjoy!
This looks absolutely wonderful and I can’t wait to try it!!! Does it matter if I just use only regular flour?Thanks a lot
Regular all-purpose flour is just fine Lulu! I hope that you love the cake.
Could you do all whole wheat flour? Does it need to be pastry flour or is regular whole wheat flour ok?
Hi MJ! Whole wheat pastry flour is much finer than regular whole wheat flour, so I actually wouldn’t recommend that substitution, as the cake will probably be too dense. If you don’t have whole wheat pastry flour, I would suggest using all purpose flour instead. I hope you love the cake!
Hi! I used regular whole wheat flour and then read this comment—oops! But I tried the cake and it’s still delicious. It may be denser than your recipe, but we still ended up with a delicious cake. Thanks for the great recipe!
My sister is a die-hard carrot cake fan so when I told her I could make her a healthier version for her 26th birthday, she was all for it! Not only did this cake look beautiful (I was sad to cut into it!) but it had such great flavor! No one could tell that it was a lighter version than the typical carrot cake. It was a HUGE hit among my family and I just wanted to thank you for allowing me to eat an amazing desert and not feel guilty about it! Oh, and for giving all of us home bakers a chance to show off to our families! This will surely become my go-to carrot cake!
P.S. Do you know how the cooking time/temperature would vary if made into cupcakes?
Thanks!!!
Julia, I am thrilled to bits to hear this!!! It’s exactly the kind of comment that lights up my day :) THANK YOU!
I’ve never tried these as cupcakes, but I think it would work just fine! To play it safest, you can keep the oven temp at 350 degrees, though they will have a flatter top, or for a more domed top try 375 (the higher temp will help them rise faster, though I’m a tiny bit worried they *might* over cook on top before the middle is done—it’s just hard to say without having tried it myself). Either way, start checking at 15 minutes and go from there. If you try the cupcake route, I’d love to hear what temp/time you choose and how they turn out!
My grandson’s favorite cake made it today for his 13. Bday. Hope he leaves a slice for me
YAY! Happy birthday to your grandson! I’m so honored that this is his favorite cake! I hope he leaves a slice for you too, Rita. :)
Carrot cake is my fave! Can another oil be used in place of Canola? Thank You!!!
Hi Gina, yes, you can use another mild-flavored oil! (Don’t use your finest extra-virgin olive oil, for example.)
Hi Erin, I’m glad I made this and would do so again b/c the healthiness of the whole wheat pastry flour didn’t diminish the tenderness of the carrot cake and the frosting has that classic cream cheese frosting we all associate w/ carrot cake. However, for my palate, next time I make it without the cinnamon as it had a presence I don’t associate w/ carrot cake that was a bit strong for me. Also when almost done making the frosting I thought it tasted pretty sweet – & though I’m a I-love-a-brownie-sundae kind of a gal – I’m also one who’s trying to decrease my overall sugar intake and ratchet down my palate to be happier w/ less sugar. Given that and wanting more frosting on my carrot cake than shown in your photos, I opted to use @ 5+ oz. of cream cheese and almost an entire 4 oz. yogurt serving to increase the volume of frosting produced while simultaneously cutting the sweetness. It worked great. The texture still smooth and still plenty sweet. I look forward to trying other recipes of yours. :) Thanks, Susan Chapin Musicant
Susan, thank you for sharing this wonderful review and your tweaks to the recipe. I’m glad to hear you enjoyed the cake!
Hi Erin, could I use applesauce to substitute for crushed pineapples?
Hi Cynthia! I would be hesitant to recommend this, as applesauce is more liquidy and not sweet enough. The pineapple is both naturally more sweet and gives the cake the right texture. I hope you love the recipe if you decide to give it a try!
Hello – is this recipe low cholesterol? My father needs a LC one and I wanted to check before making it.
Hi Roz! Since I don’t have a medical background, I’d check with your father’s doctor. I’d hate to give you advice that isn’t correct and want to be safe!
Wow! This is superb
I’m so happy that it was a hit, Carla! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Hello! Instead of canola oil can you use applesauce? If so, is it the same amount?
Hi April! I’ve already cut as much fat out of this as I can, so I wouldn’t recommend applesauce, as I worry the cake would end up dry/gummy. If you wanted to experiment, you could try swapping half of the oil with the same amount of unsweetened applesauce, but it may impact the results negatively. If you decide to play around, I’d love to hear how it goes!
With just a few ingredient changes(INTENTIONALLY AND NOT;) ) the cake I made was really good….moist AND full of flavour…really tasted like MORE!
THANX FOR THE INPUT
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Beulah! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Can you use coconut flour in place of wheat flour?An do you have to add more liquid to the recipe because your using coconut flour?
Hi Linda! I’ve only tested this recipe as written so I wouldn’t be able to advise on what to do if using a different flour. I do have a coconut flour cake: https://www.wellplated.com/coconut-flour-cake/ Hope this helps!
WINNER! This was the perfect cake for a few reasons:
1) single layer (smaller easter gathering, didn’t need a double-decker!)
2) healthier
3) spice notes were perfect
4) moistness (like wow!)
5) everyone LOVED it :-)
My frosting was runnier than I was expecting, but it was probably my greek yogurt (super runny for some reason?), but a short rest in the fridge (plus some extra powdered sugar) fixed it!
Hi Burton! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Made this per recipie, looked great & toothpick came out clean , frosting great. BUT, when I cut into it, it was doughy! Couldn’t eat it. Very disappointed as it was a birthday cake. Don’t know what happened. Baked at 350 degrees for 40 minutes in spring pan. ???
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Dar. The method and timing has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
Hi Erin, I didn’t make the cake, but I used the frosting recipe with some homemade whipped cream folded in for my son’s first birthday cupcake. Thank you <3
Great to hear, Austin! Thank you!
Can I substitute coconut oil for canola oil?
Hi Dayna, I haven’t tested it out myself, but I believe it would work. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!