• Great question Allie! Regarding nutritional info, this is something that I’ve actually started adding to all of my new recipes, effective January 2016 (you’ll see it in the recipe box at the bottom). Unfortunately, it’s pretty time consuming, so I’m unable to go back and add it to past recipes. If you’d like the nutritional info for any of my older recipes (or really any other recipe or food), you can actually calculate it yourself for free at myfitnesspal.com (this is how I calculate the new recipes on my blog). I’m sorry I can’t give you the information for this exact recipe, but I hope that My Fitness Pal will be a helpful resource for you.

    1. Hi Margie! The recipe is right above the comments section in the recipe box. You should be able to see it. If you can’t, I would suggest refreshing the page. I hope that helps!

  • These look and sound so good! I love that they contain many of the traditional ingredients without being loaded down with sugar and butter. Wish I had one to enjoy after my lunch today! ;)

  • Never made these using a banana but will try it…..these look really good….can’t have regular chocolate chips, so I will use white chocolate chips…. but was wondering what I could use instead of 1/4 cup of cocoa powder ? Wonder if you could buy white cocoa powder ??? If you know or any of your fans know I would appreciate it…..

    1. I’m afraid I’ve never heard of white cocoa powder, and I don’t know that it actually exists, since white chocolate isn’t made out of cocoa beans the way regular chocolate is (it’s mostly sugar, milk, and cocoa butter). I wish I could help you there. You could try omitting the cocoa powder entirely and adding a bit more oats, though it would be an experiment. I’m sorry I can’t help you more—I’ve never tested this recipe without chocolate or cocoa.

      1. Hi, I was wondering the same thing, how to skip the cocoa and keep the consistency right. Do you think dehydrated milk could work?

        1. Hi Ivana, I really can’t say because I haven’t experimented with it. If you decide to, let me know how it goes!

  • Erin- thank you! These cookies have been a lifesaver in my first two weeks as a mom. I made a batch before baby arrived and stuck them in the freezer for middle-of-the-night breastfeeding treats. Once my husband discovered them, we ran out quickly. Our second (double) batch just disappeared, too. So good! 5 stars

    1. Katie, I am so excited to hear this!! Thanks so much for trying the recipe and taking time to leave this review. Congrats also on your new baby :)

  • These were yummy! I confess I was out of honey and banana but already committed so I used 3 tsp maple syrup. I added 1.5 chia seeds as I am trying to get kids fiber intake up slowly. 
    I can’t wait to make these with the honey and banana(a great excuse to make them again)!5 stars

    1. Kelly, I am so glad that you and the kids enjoyed these. Maple syrup is a great swap, and the chia seeds sound like a smart addition. Thanks for taking time to leave your review!

  • Hi Erin. Thanks so much for dis wonderful way of making healthy cookies. But I will like to know how to preserve them apart from the freezing method.I want to make them for sale but wondering how to package and still keep dem fresh and healthy,should they remain after the day of production. Thanks.5 stars

    1. HI Janet! You can store in them in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 10 days. I think they would still taste great the next day :)

    1. Hi Jennifer! Did you use a particularly runny peanut butter or the kind that has to be refrigerated? Those don’t usually set at room temperature, which could cause soft cookies. Have you tried putting them in the fridge to firm up? It’s also possible that the oats were slightly undermeasured or that the honey was slightly overmeasured. But all is not lost! I suggest storing them in the freezer, letting them sit at room temperature for a few minutes to soften slightly when you’re ready to eat them, and enjoying them cold! They actually taste pretty good that way!

  • I was craving the no bake cookies and curious about whether I could make a healthy version.  I’m so glad I found your recipe.   I have all the ingredients except honey and I don’t really use honey for anything else.  Do you think I could leave it out?  If so, what do you recommend I do differently?  I have pure stevia extract.  What about an extra banana?  Also, using almond butter instead of peanut butter wouldn’t make a difference would it?  Thanks!  I look forward to checking out your other healthy recipes.5 stars

    1. Now I’m craving no bake cookies too, Jean! I have never tried this recipe without the honey, but I worry that the cookies wouldn’t bind together properly without that sticky, syrupy ingredient. Take a look at Kelly’s comment a few comments up…she tried the recipe with maple syrup and chia seeds, if you’d like to experiment with her substitutions! Almond butter may work (I haven’t tried this either!) if it’s pretty solid at room temperature. If it’s a runny kind, the cookies may not be very firm. Hope that helps!

    1. Hi Crystal, cocoa powder is built right into the recipe! If you mean adding more cocoa powder than the 1/4 cup called for, I don’t know for sure. I haven’t tried them that way, so you’d be experimenting. My only concern would be that adding more of a dry ingredient may cause the cookies to turn out a little dry and crumbly. I hope you enjoy them!

  • True, I did not read every ingredient. I’ll try it just as it is and see how things go. Thank you.

    I crave no bake cookies like no one’s business since I had some while visiting a friend recently. I want a healthy alternative to sugar for sure. I’m hoping this will do it for me.

  • No-bakes are my toddler son’s favorite cookie,  but I’m not comfortable with letting him have as much sugar as thee original recipe calls for.  These are perfect for both of us. Just made them and we both love them! Thank you so much! 5 stars

  • I made these for my husband, since he looooves no bakes but I don’t like making his grandma’s recipe because there’s so much sugar it makes my teeth hurt! Apparently I can’t compete with grandma (can anyone compete with their husband’s grandma??) because he wasn’t a huge fan but I LOVE THESE. I couldn’t stop licking the spoon as I was forming them and they’re even better once they set! I guess it’s ok he doesn’t like them because now there’s more for me! Definitely plan on making these again!5 stars

    1. Kate, I’m so glad to hear you enjoyed the cookies. You’re absolutely right that there’s no competing with grandma, but I guess the silver lining is that there are more cookies for you! Thanks so much for sharing this awesome review!

  • I am new to the gluten free world. Is this recipe gluten free? If not, what would I need to change to make it so? 

    1. Hi Jen, the recipe as written is gluten free, but if you or the person you’re making these for has a serious gluten allergy, like celiac, you’ll want to make sure that all of your ingredients are certified gluten free to be safe. I hope you enjoy the cookies!

  • These look so good!  Can you make them without the coconut oil?  I can’t have any oils so was wondering if there’s a substitution?

    1. Hi Jara! The coconut oil helps the cookies hold together and set up. The closest substitute is unsalted butter. I hope you enjoy them if you try them!

  • Just tried these–absolutely delicious–thank you so much!!! I really needed this so I have something healthy for Thanksgiving and Hanukkah. It’s not worth it making junk food and then feeling bad. I also like this recipe b/c the ingredients is much more affordable than some other healthy treats! Thanks again!!!5 stars