• I made this with sweet potatoes instead and it was delicious! Maybe a bit too much vinegar, but I loved all the egg and the taste was divine!5 stars

  • This was an excellent recipe. I made it the same way but also added a little dry dill. Thank you for sharing this. It’s better than regular salad with Mayo!5 stars

      1. Made double batch for a 4th of July picnic today…it was a hit! Even those who normally don’t care for potato salad gave it rave reviews. Everyone agreed it made a great change from the usual. Thanks for another delicious spot-on recipe! Made as written 😊5 stars

    1. Hi Janet, I stopped including sodium info because it can vary so much depending upon what products you used, and I found a lot of conflicting info online, so ultimately I didn’t feel comfortable publishing it because sometimes it wasn’t even in the ballpark. If you’d like to calculate it yourself, there are lots of free tools online (myfitnesspal.com is popular). I hope that helps!

      1
  • I’ll give it a whirl but with full-fat yogurt. I’m sure it’s just as healthy. I use it in everything that uses low/no-fat yogurt. :)
    LOVE green onions! Thanks for this healthy version!

  • Made this for me and my dad for our bbq.. I don’t eat mayo so I tried this out.. dad’s not big on Greek yogurt but he said it was ok.. the dijon was too much and over powered everything else.. I ended up adding some chive cream cheese; I love that stuff and it calmed it down.. I think I’ll just stick to German tater salad..3 stars

    1. I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Kimberly. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!

  • I plan to try this for an upcoming family dinner. However, I am not a huge fan of garlic and am looking at options with respect to using it. Is there some sort of substitute? Can I just reduce the amount. Can I leave it out entirely without a substitute?
    Looking forward to making this regardless of the response.

  • Made exactly as recipe but I had no capers and I used full fat yogurt. Very nice taste. Saved it and will definitely make again.5 stars

    1
  • Made this exactly as described and it is excellent! Didn’t end up using the last of the dressing as it was enough with the first bit. You’re so right about the celery salt – makes the difference! Thanks so much.5 stars

    1
  • We had this recipe for dinner. Loved it! My picky husband loved the change from the traditional mayo version. Thank you for sharing!!5 stars

  • This was great! I made exactly according to the recipe, even though I knew I had some folks who didn’t like yogurt, onions and capers. All seemed to enjoy it, including the picky eaters.5 stars

  • Hi Erin,
    This recipe is a winner! We don’t like mayo so I was thrilled to find your recipe. This is our second time making this and it’s wonderful. This time we had to use chives instead of green onions and it is still great! We don’t do low/non fat so if anyone’s curious it’s great with full fat Greek yogurt.
    Thanks for creating and sharing this winning recipe!
    Best,
    Jen5 stars

    2
  • Made double batch for a 4th of July picnic today…it was a hit! Even those who normally don’t care for potato salad gave it rave reviews. Everyone agreed it made a great change from the usual. Thanks for another delicious spot-on recipe! Made as written 😊5 stars

  • THIS potato salad recipe is SO delicious!!! I can’t decide if it’s the garlic or what but this is just fantastic. Good way to use up our eggs from our hens… and the yogurt dressing is spot on. Only changes were using full fat Fage Greek yogurt and prosecco wine vinegar and full size potatoes (all of which are what I had on hand). Thank you so much for this recipe!!!

  • I made this and it is fine but mayo is basically oil,eggs, and vinegarso the ingredients are basically all here anyway.

    1. Hi Nara! Glad you enjoyed it! Using the non-fat Greek yogurt actually lightens this up a bit, along with the other ingredients giving this a classic taste. Hope this helps!

  • This is the second time I’ve made this recipe, but I only use one garlic bulb and I add a bunch of fresh dill. Serve it with homemade turkey barbecue sandwiches on The 647 sandwich rolls. Makes for a great dinner.5 stars

  • I halved this recipe, but used 2 hard-boiled eggs and 1 1/2 tablespoons of capers. This was amaaaazing! After having it the once, I’ve decided to bring it to my work’s potluck next month. Love how low calorie it is, but still jam-packed with flavor. Also, my boyfriend has never liked a potato salad, but said it has to go into our regular rotation.5 stars

  • Hi everybody. I just made this truely fat free. I skipped the oil all together don’t need it in there. I also took out the egg yolks and just used the egg whites. So cholesterol free spud salad, which I never thought possible in a million year. When I make my spud salad I cut up the spuds smaller, but not to small. But omfg it tastes soooo good.

    To the person who came up with this, thank you very much from the bottom of my heart. Now I can eat spud salad again without it killing me. Anybody with high cholesteral can eat this.5 stars

    A stainless steel bowl of potato salad with herbs and creamy dressing sits on a kitchen countertop.

      1. Oh forgot to mention in my review. I also added cut up small raddish to it as an extra flavor and crunch, might be a good thing to add to your list as an extta ingredient. And sorry I didnt use your name in there, I was just so excited to make this today i didnt notice your name. Thanks again.5 stars

  • Wow, this is really good! Found that I really didn’t need much more of the sauce at end, but I can see where some people would prefer it. Only complaint is that it took me about an hour and 15 minutes to make, not 40 minutes. Guess I’m just slow and inefficient!5 stars

    1. Glad you enjoyed the salad, Kim! I also don’t think it has anything to do with inefficiency. My methods in the kitchen might be just a different and that’s okay! Thanks again!