Hi Tricia, the recipe isn’t very saucy to begin with, so adding more milk when doubling is a good tip if you would like it more on the saucy side! Thank you for trying the recipe, and I hope you enjoy it if you give it another go with your adjustment!
Ashley, not that I am aware of! Personally, I think the honey would be too sweet (and it’s not a flavor I usually put with potatoes), so I’d stick to either plain or to a goat cheese with herbs.
Kacey, you could try dicing cream cheese and dotting it between the layers. I haven’t done that myself because I happen to be a goat cheese lover so you’d be experiementing, but think it would be worth a try!
Hi Brittany, I haven’t tried it myself, but I think you could swap cream instead. Since it’s thicker than milk, you may need a little extra to evenly distribute it over the potatoes. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Oh my gosh! These potatoes are the most delicious ones I’ve ever had. I made these to take to my son and daughter-in-laws house for Christmas dinner. They were a huge hit and I received many compliments. I doubled the recipe, added about 3/4 cup of milk and they turned out perfect. I really should have tripled it as there was not one bit left over. I will definitely be making these again.. I have to add these are very easy to make as well.
First of all, I love goat cheese! …so knew this recipe was worth a try. No it is not exactly the same as traditional scalloped potatoes, all saucy and such, but oh my goodness this was delicious. Perfection really. We loved it. Thank you for this recipe!
The flavor was amazing, but my potatoes weren’t done. I followed the directions to a tee even using a mandoline. I even left them in 3 minutes longer to make sure the tops were browned.
Andrea, I’m sorry to hear that! Different pans conduct heat differently so that might be why, and it could also be possible that even with a mandoline, your potatoes were still thicker than the ones I used. If this happens again, you can simply cover the pan and keep on baking them until they are tender. Glad you liked the flavor!
Loved these scalloped potatoes with goats cheese. I couldn’t find Yukon gold potatoes so I used Russet, even though Erin doesn’t recommend them and they turned out great.
I would prefer to Pin a receipt right away to my board. For whatever reason I get all these other receipts
That I do not want. A real waste of my time. I just removed my name so why would you request it again.
Hi Jacqueline, I have no idea what you are saying. I have not requested anything. If you are trying to pin this to Pinterest, all you have to do is hit the Pin it for later button right under the very first photo. If you are having other issues, please send screenshots to hello@wellplated.com so we can help you get it fixed, if it is something on our end.
I absolutely loved this dish. Will add it to ” My Favorites recipes” section.
Thanks soooo much.
I’m so happy to hear the Lori! Thanks so much for trying the recipe and letting me know how it turned out for you.
If you double this recipie, you have to almost triple the milk. I only doubled it and it made no sauce, it was very dry.
Hi Tricia, the recipe isn’t very saucy to begin with, so adding more milk when doubling is a good tip if you would like it more on the saucy side! Thank you for trying the recipe, and I hope you enjoy it if you give it another go with your adjustment!
Has anyone tried making this with honey goat cheese?
Ashley, not that I am aware of! Personally, I think the honey would be too sweet (and it’s not a flavor I usually put with potatoes), so I’d stick to either plain or to a goat cheese with herbs.
I layered the rosemary in with the potatoes and added bits of bacon….it was devine!
That does sound delicious, Brooke! I’m so glad you enjoyed the recipe!
Trying to use up what I have around the house. How do you think some big Idaho potatoes would taste. I don’t have golds right now.
Hi Amy, I think you could use the potatoes you have on hand! I hope you enjoy the potatoes.
Do you think almond milk would work in place of the whole milk?
Daniele, I think that the potatoes would be more thin and less creamy. I’d recommend sticking with whole milk for this one. It’s worth it!
what would be a good substitute for goat cheese? (can’t STAND the flavor!)
Kacey, you could try dicing cream cheese and dotting it between the layers. I haven’t done that myself because I happen to be a goat cheese lover so you’d be experiementing, but think it would be worth a try!
Adding goat cheese was brilliant! So creamy and yummy!
This is an amazing side dish! I loved every bite.
Yummy! Such a delicious recipe! I have made scalloped potatoes before but in between layers I have used Ricotta Cheese. It is also so delicious.
Hi Erin! I have some heavy whipping cream in my fridge, will that work or should I buy some milk? Thank you!
Hi Brittany, I haven’t tried it myself, but I think you could swap cream instead. Since it’s thicker than milk, you may need a little extra to evenly distribute it over the potatoes. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Oh my gosh! These potatoes are the most delicious ones I’ve ever had. I made these to take to my son and daughter-in-laws house for Christmas dinner. They were a huge hit and I received many compliments. I doubled the recipe, added about 3/4 cup of milk and they turned out perfect. I really should have tripled it as there was not one bit left over. I will definitely be making these again.. I have to add these are very easy to make as well.
Donna, HOORAY! I am so so happy to hear this. Thank you so much for taking time to leave this review too!
Donna, I am so pleased to hear this. THANK YOU for sharing this lovely review!
My new favorite side dish recipe! I’ll be dreaming about this until I make it again!
WHooo hooo! Thank you, thank you!
Incredible! We ate this as a main dish of 4 servings.
I’m so happy to hear that this was a hit, Beth! Thank you for taking the time to share this kind review!
First of all, I love goat cheese! …so knew this recipe was worth a try. No it is not exactly the same as traditional scalloped potatoes, all saucy and such, but oh my goodness this was delicious. Perfection really. We loved it. Thank you for this recipe!
I’m so pleased that you enjoyed this recipe, Cindy! Thank you for taking the time to share this kind review!
Delicious!! And easy!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Megan! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
The flavor was amazing, but my potatoes weren’t done. I followed the directions to a tee even using a mandoline. I even left them in 3 minutes longer to make sure the tops were browned.
Andrea, I’m sorry to hear that! Different pans conduct heat differently so that might be why, and it could also be possible that even with a mandoline, your potatoes were still thicker than the ones I used. If this happens again, you can simply cover the pan and keep on baking them until they are tender. Glad you liked the flavor!
Loved these scalloped potatoes with goats cheese. I couldn’t find Yukon gold potatoes so I used Russet, even though Erin doesn’t recommend them and they turned out great.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Jenny! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I would prefer to Pin a receipt right away to my board. For whatever reason I get all these other receipts
That I do not want. A real waste of my time. I just removed my name so why would you request it again.
Hi Jacqueline, I have no idea what you are saying. I have not requested anything. If you are trying to pin this to Pinterest, all you have to do is hit the Pin it for later button right under the very first photo. If you are having other issues, please send screenshots to hello@wellplated.com so we can help you get it fixed, if it is something on our end.
Delicious and fun to prepare. My family loved these potatoes! Incorporating goat cheese was a hit. Thanks, Well Plated!
Hi Danielle! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!