I have one more question:
Do you know how long can I keep the stew under the “keep warm” setting of the insta pot?
I never used this setting and have no experience/knowledge about it.
I was trying to see if you think it will be possible to make it the night before, keep it under “keep warm” setting, and then add the cornstarch, water and peas right before serving.
I dont want the potatoes to fall apart of course
Hi Nathan, the keep warm setting works well, but I wouldn’t recommend doing it overnight. I would be worried the meat would get tough. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!
Question:
I would like to make this in my crockpot or oven. Do you have a recipe for either of those? Probably crockpot would be better to tenderize meat? Sounds so good. Please reply!
I use tomato paste from a tube, instead of a can. If you use the can paste and have leftover paste, you can portion the paste into a ice cube tray or whatever freezer tray you may have and freeze the paste for other uses.
Would add a bit more flavor. Deglaze w red wine b4 onions. Follow rest but add fresh rosemary sprigs and thyme. Fresh better than dried. Lastly tube tomato paste. Will help thicken.
The stew tastes better with the tomato sauce which I forgot a couple of times. also made it with dried veggies instead of regular veggies. I like the stew better with regular veggies.
This is so so good. My new go to stew. I cook the meat for 25 minutes, do a quick release then add the carrots and halved small potatoes. Cook for another 10 minutes. Comes out perfect every time. Thanks for a delicious recipe!!!
This beef stew is perfection! the meat is exceptionally tender and the flavor is great. A good neutral beef stew, the way it should be! I don’t add peas because we aren’t fond of them.
I’m not normally a stew person because I live in a hot climate. I tried this recipe because my husband made a brisket that was pretty tough and dry and I thought maybe making it into an instant pot stew might save it. I had everything needed to make this recipe so I thought I would give it a try. It was so good! My husband loved it. The ruined brisket was awesome in the stew. I made it a second time today with a chuck roast that I found at the store that was marked down for quick sale. This one was great too! It will definitely be in the rotation when it’s not too hot out.
This recipe is awesome! My family love its. We eat venison in our household, so I have swapped the beef for venison. Still great.
I am wanting to make this recipe for a Meal Train in which the family asks for no tomatoes but tomato paste is fine. They are following a cancer diet because the dad has cancer, sadly. How can I swap the tomato sauce for paste? Any recos?
Hi Virginia, the only thing I could suggest is to mix the paste with water before you add it to the recipe, but it’s not the same. The paste is concentrated puree where all of the water is removed during the cooking process vs with the sauce the water content is higher. Let me know if you decide to experiment.
hi! I’ve made this before and its delicious! tonight i only have a bag of mixed frozen veggies – will they still work or do i need to change the cook time?
I made this for supper this evening with some honey butter croissants and it was a hit! This was the best stew I’ve made in that short amount of time. Thank you for the recipe, Erin!!
Really good, but also really clear instructions. I like how you tend to cover those little “what if” questions we might have about freezing, other types of potatoes, etc.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Ethan. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
Omg. This might be the best beef stew I’ve ever made in my entire life. The meat melts in your mouth. I will make this over and over again.
So glad to hear, Alyssa! Thank you!
Great flavours but I used russet potatoes and they fell apart. I would make this again but prepare the potatoes separately to avoid this.
Glad you were still able to enjoy it, Monica!
it was SOOOOO good!!!
Thanks so much, Tm!
Its very delicious and easy to make!
Took me almost 2.5 hours overall but im always a slow cook.
I have a question- the peas flavor was a little too strong for me. Do you have a recommendation for an alternative? Maybe beans or chickpeas?
Hi Nathan! So glad you enjoyed it. Chickpeas would be cook as they are more mild in taste.
Thank you for your reply Erin!
I have one more question:
Do you know how long can I keep the stew under the “keep warm” setting of the insta pot?
I never used this setting and have no experience/knowledge about it.
I was trying to see if you think it will be possible to make it the night before, keep it under “keep warm” setting, and then add the cornstarch, water and peas right before serving.
I dont want the potatoes to fall apart of course
Thank you!
Hi Nathan, the keep warm setting works well, but I wouldn’t recommend doing it overnight. I would be worried the meat would get tough. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!
The whole family enjoyed this with the mushroom variation you suggested.
Great to hear, Maddy! Thank you!
Question:
I would like to make this in my crockpot or oven. Do you have a recipe for either of those? Probably crockpot would be better to tenderize meat? Sounds so good. Please reply!
Hi Patricia! Here is my crockpot version: https://www.wellplated.com/crockpot-beef-stew/
I use tomato paste from a tube, instead of a can. If you use the can paste and have leftover paste, you can portion the paste into a ice cube tray or whatever freezer tray you may have and freeze the paste for other uses.
Yes, that is a great trick I use too! Thank you!
Would add a bit more flavor. Deglaze w red wine b4 onions. Follow rest but add fresh rosemary sprigs and thyme. Fresh better than dried. Lastly tube tomato paste. Will help thicken.
Thank you McFly!
The stew tastes better with the tomato sauce which I forgot a couple of times. also made it with dried veggies instead of regular veggies. I like the stew better with regular veggies.
Thanks for the feedback, Donna!
This is so so good. My new go to stew. I cook the meat for 25 minutes, do a quick release then add the carrots and halved small potatoes. Cook for another 10 minutes. Comes out perfect every time. Thanks for a delicious recipe!!!
So glad to hear, Liz! Thank you!
This beef stew is perfection! the meat is exceptionally tender and the flavor is great. A good neutral beef stew, the way it should be! I don’t add peas because we aren’t fond of them.
Glad you enjoyed it, Jackie! Thank you!
I’m not normally a stew person because I live in a hot climate. I tried this recipe because my husband made a brisket that was pretty tough and dry and I thought maybe making it into an instant pot stew might save it. I had everything needed to make this recipe so I thought I would give it a try. It was so good! My husband loved it. The ruined brisket was awesome in the stew. I made it a second time today with a chuck roast that I found at the store that was marked down for quick sale. This one was great too! It will definitely be in the rotation when it’s not too hot out.
So glad to hear, Jodi! Thank you!
This recipe is awesome! My family love its. We eat venison in our household, so I have swapped the beef for venison. Still great.
I am wanting to make this recipe for a Meal Train in which the family asks for no tomatoes but tomato paste is fine. They are following a cancer diet because the dad has cancer, sadly. How can I swap the tomato sauce for paste? Any recos?
Hi Virginia, the only thing I could suggest is to mix the paste with water before you add it to the recipe, but it’s not the same. The paste is concentrated puree where all of the water is removed during the cooking process vs with the sauce the water content is higher. Let me know if you decide to experiment.
hi! I’ve made this before and its delicious! tonight i only have a bag of mixed frozen veggies – will they still work or do i need to change the cook time?
It should work, Cara! I don’t think you would need to adjust the timing. Let me know how it goes!
too good
Thank you!
I made this for supper this evening with some honey butter croissants and it was a hit! This was the best stew I’ve made in that short amount of time. Thank you for the recipe, Erin!!
So glad to hear, Tana!
The whole family enjoyed this with the mushroom variation you suggested.
Great to hear, thank you Maddy!
Really good, but also really clear instructions. I like how you tend to cover those little “what if” questions we might have about freezing, other types of potatoes, etc.
Thank you so much, Kathy!
Excellent! I used the mushroom swap for peas like you mentioned. I used shiitake mushrooms. Made it twice. The family loved it.
So happy to hear it worked well for you, Maddy! Thank you!
Vegetables were mush – this does not need 35min. Sad
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Ethan. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
I make this so much and love it.
Thank you Lindsey!