• Really tasty! I had to saute low to caramelize, it was burning too quick for me even though I was standing right there. I personally would add more onions for the second cook, the ratio of broth to onion “strings” was off for me. Delicious recipe, but all your recipes are delicious.5 stars

  • I doubled the recipe  and it turned out wonderfully. Served it for the big game today with some smoked pork sliders. Was a big hit. Thank you!!5 stars

    1. WHOOO HOOO! CJ, soooo happy to hear you all enjoyed it. Thank you for letting me know and sharing this lovely review!

  • Very tasty soup, great recipe. But I made one (pretty big) change : I didn’t use my instant pot! I thought it was more likely to overcook the onions that way. So I doubled the recipe and made it on the stovetop in a large pot. 
    I’ve made it 3 times now because my family loves it. I purée the leftovers and use it to make the tastiest beef stew ever (according to me and my family at least).  
    Thanks for the recipe. Love your site! 5 stars

    1. YAY! Thank you for taking the time to share this kind review and your alternative cooking method! I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe!

  • OMG I’ve been having the most intense French Onion soup craving and this totally fit the bill! I was a little concerned because I ended up using about 9 onions after following the 2.5 lbs the recipe called for, but they reduced down to a normal amount and all was right with the world. I made this for lunches this week but my wife and I are about to polish this off tonight! Thank you for this wonderful recipe!5 stars

  • Am using twice the recommended onions and am also  using both red onions and vidalia onions. Great results. One of our favs5 stars

  • I think carmelizing in a pan works better, added sherry, a little brown sugar and more dried thyme. Turned out great !5 stars

  • Yum! We didn’t have bayleaf or thyme, so left those out. Used 4 large onions, and 1/2 cup salted butter because yum. No red wine, so used Rose. Decided I was too lazy to saute the final mix of beef broth (no bone broth either) so put the IP on the soup function for 15 minutes and then quick release. No baguette or Gruyere, so used a sub bun and some Bothwell aged cheddar. So good, worth the scalds to my tongue, and I’m not sharing this with hubby – it’s all mine! Can’t wait to try it with a heartier bread like rye.5 stars

      1. Or sure what went wrong but my inions definitely did not caramelize. Transferred the cooked down onions to the slow cooker I hope I can get them golden and delicious.

        1. Brittany, I am sorry to hear that! Onion caramelization goes pretty slowly, so they may have just needed more time. I hope you loved the soup in the end.

  • Onions carmelized beautifully. Had lots of liquid at the end that didn’t thicken. I even left out one container of the bone broth. Any suggestions as to how to thicken at the end?4 stars

    1. Hi Abby! The soup is meant to be liquidy and brothy, and I’ve found most traditional French onion soups to be like that, especially so that it soaks up easily into the bread. I hope you were still able to enjoy the soup!

      1. Just made this for my dads bday dinner with the family and i have to say i added a roast cooked it in the Insta pot first then caramilzed onions in a skillet and added everything in recipe and went again in the insta pot the meat added a lot to the soup and made it even better! Very hearty for sure!!5 stars

  • This is honestly one of the best recipes I have found on the internet. My husband and I just are half a pot for dinner and will have the rest for dinner tomorrow. Thanks for sharing!5 stars

  • Love the recipe, the wife and I are walking around the house squinting though from the onion smell… any tips to beat this??

    1. Hi Nate! I’m sorry, I do not have this problem with the onion smell and can’t control it unfortunately. A simple Google search should lead to some answers on how to rid of the smell. Hope this helps!

  • -This recipe, when cooked as directed is tasteless. If you hit the “print recipe” button, the directions omit the flour/thickening step. I added worsteshire, extra thyme, kosher salt and coarse black pepper. It was o.k. but this recipe is going in the garbage. Don’t waste your time.

    1. Hi Carol! This recipe doesn’t have directions for a flour/thickening step, so I am confused as to what you are referring to. As I’ve mentioned in previous comments, this soup is meant to be liquidy/brothy.

  • I am planning to make this later in the week. Quick question: we don’t drink alcohol. I have successfully subbed balsamic vinegar for red wine in a beef stew recipe. Do you this balsamic vinegar will work in place of the wine in this onion soup? Thank you for all you wonderful recipes.4 stars

    1. Hi Chris! I stopped including sodium info because it can vary so much depending upon what products you used, and I found a lot of conflicting info online, so ultimately I didn’t feel comfortable publishing it because sometimes it wasn’t even in the ballpark. If you’d like to calculate it yourself, there are lots of free tools online (myfitnesspal.com is popular). I hope that helps!

  • I found it actually took me more time to make French Onion Soup in the Instant Pot vs. on the stovetop. Stovetop, I can coax a lot more flavor from the onions and truly get them caramelized vs. what I can in the IP. IP just had blond, cooked onions instead of something with a deep rich color and flavor.3 stars

    1. I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, John. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!

  • I’d like to make this soup 3X’s the recipe. Will it fit in my 6 qt instant pot? Also, should I cook that many onions in batches?

    1. Hi Donna! I don’t believe a triple recipe would fit in that size instant pot. If you end up experimenting, let me know how it goes!

  • This was a great recipe for a first timer, especially! I love your recipes ❤️ I added more seasoning and a little Dale’s near the end. I also used Texas toast with Swiss melted on top and it was delicious!!! My adult son gave it 5 stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️5 stars