1. Hi Shelly! I’m thinking you would keep the same amount, but I can’t say for sure since I didn’t test the recipe with that specific powder. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!

  • I made the jamaican chicken and had it a second time by adding pieces of fresh pineapple and it made it even better because of the sweetness of pineapple and heat from the spices….5 stars

    1. Hi Denise! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review and feedback on adding pineapple!

  • I tried this recipe and it turned out real good
    I cooked it in my cast iron pot that was hand down from my grandmother.
    Thanks a lot5 stars

    1. I made this for meal prep this week. It is so good. I happened to have found Jamaican Curry and a habanero ( no scotch bonnet though). It is so spicy but not just heat. It’s amazing. A def keeper in our rotation. No notes.5 stars

  • Delicious! Received compliments from friends. The flavor of the spices and the coconut milk made this a new favorite dish!5 stars

  • I made this delicious recipe and it was great. It was so great. My family wanted me to make it again thank you so much for this recipe.5 stars

  • My husband and I loved this recipe! We felt it needed salt and more curry. Other than that it is a keeper!5 stars

  • The BEST Curry Chicken recipe I have ever tried, hands down!! After reading over the ingredients and cooking instruction, I had a feeling it was going to be good, so I decided to follow the recipe to the T and boy was I right!! It was ABSOLUTELY delicious!!!!! Thanks you for such an awesome recipe. I can’t wait to make it again for my family.5 stars

  • Dearest Erin,
    This looks so amazing but I’m a mom of 3 with a newborn cooking above the stove will kill me right now untill I can recover !! Do you think this recipe will work in a crock pot? Help how would I adapt so I can set it and leave it to cook all day

  • Delicious! One of the best non-indian curries I’ve made. I used a heavier coconut milk so I had to cut back 25% on it. This recipe feels quite versatile.5 stars

  • Made 4 servings for meal prep for the week. My roommate was using our only big pot so I did the whole thing in a large heavy cast iron and only used 1/2 the coconut milk called for. Also subbed in chicken thighs for the breasts, added a touch of sugar and MSG. Came out amazing, seems really versatile and still was great with all the little changes I made. highly recommend this recipe5 stars

  • I served this recipe to my friends from Kingston, Jamaica and they could not believe how delicious it was. I did make some edits:

    1) Instead of Coconut Milk I used Heavy Cream. This was a game changer to the recipe. It made it luxurious and so smooth.
    2) I used Red Curry from McCormick. This particular curry is phenomenal and has less of an earthy flavor to it. The aroma is wonderful.
    3) I added fresh cut carrots.
    4) I only used one jalapeno.
    5) I used skinless boneless chicken thighs
    6) I added two Tablespoons of powdered chicken broth for more flavor. Another game changer!

    My edits, by no means take away from the deliciousness of the originator of this recipe. I’m not sure what made me click on Erin’s curry recipe but I’m sure glad that I did. Thanks for publishing it.5 stars

  • We visited the BVI about a month ago and wanted to make something Carribean style for our fellow travelers. We made your recipe and loved it! Easy to follow and very rich and tasty. I was able to find a scotch bonnet pepper and used it instead of the jalapeno/bell pepper substitution. I didn’t use cayenne or hot sauce, and the heat was perfect. Our guests loved it as well and asked for the recipe.5 stars

  • I’ve been making curry for so long and finally found a recipe that doesn’t turn out too soupy. Didn’t have full fat coconut cream, so I used evaporated milk. (The coconut will add that extra depth of flavor, so next time, for sure!) Added broccoli and carrots too. And don’t cover da pot, lest you want soup.5 stars

  • The overall recipe is nice, but 3.5 tablespoons is a crazy amount of curry for 1.25 pounds of chicken. I felt like the dish was full of silt when I was eating it, it’s extremely gritty. I had to rinse it out to salvage the rest. I wonder if it should have been 3.5 teaspoons.3 stars

    1. I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Emily.I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you. It has worked well for myself (and others) and I wished it would have been a hit for you too.

  • Thank you Erin for this fantastic recipe. First time making it and I made 3x the amount. Only suggestion would be to add 2 1/2 cans of light coconut milk because I prefer a thicker sauce. First time making curry though and I am glad I chose this recipe.5 stars