Husband gave it 8 “wow, this is a great dish” compliments–6 during the meal and 2 afterwards. He thought it was a dish worthy of being served in a ritzy restaurant and loved the sauce with the green beans. He would have given it 6 stars out of 5 if he could. I don’t have a big oven proof skillet so I browned the chicken and pulled the sauce together with the green beans in a skillet, then transferred to a pyrex casserole dish. Not quite 1 dish but not bad. Thanks for another great recipe, Erin!
I had only 2 chicken thighs so I added beef polish sausage to my asparagus-shiitake mushroom veggie mix. I thought I truly mangled the recipe, but it is delicious. The sauce is yummy regardless of the meat. Thank you!
I am thrilled with the coconut milk instead of cream – wow! What a silky twist with the lemon. I used asparagus for an incredible win, win, win! Thank you for, yet again, another fine meal!
This was so incredibly good!! I put it over cauliflower rice to help eat as much sauce as possible. Super easy being in one pan. Will definitely make this again.
Hi Erin, this recipe was fabulous. I’m super picky and I loved everything about this recipe. It was so delicious and easy to make. I’m keto and do IF so this easily kept my carbs in check. It was filling even without any side dishes or bread. I will definitely be adding this to my rotation of favorite meals. I’m so glad I tried this recipe.
Thank you.
I now know the recipe behind the phrase ‘Winner, winner, chicken dinner!’ Like literally every other recipe I’ve made from this site this is AMAZING! My 5 year old brother – who like nothing but pizza and ice cream – said ‘I actually like this chicken!’ WILL WONDERS NEVER CEASE? My mind is blown! The problem is, I’m writing a review for every recipe I make. Soon, I’m going to run out of glowing things to say. Would you be mad if I had a default ‘amazing recipe’ review? Anyway, this is yet another going on the dinner schedule! Love that it limits the dishes, too!
A very tasty, easy recipe with limited prep and next to no cleanup! Bonus all around. My husband loved it and couldn’t say enough about how delicious it was. I will definitely serve this again and again.
It was very tasty. I will be making this recipe again, but would like advice on how to get the sauce a bit thicker. I used the full fat coconut milk, but it really didn’t thicken up.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Becki! Thank you for sharing this kind review! I haven’t tried thickening this sauce myself, but you could experiment with letting it simmer uncovered for a bit on the stovetop before adding the chicken back in and baking it.
Thank you for the suggestion, Erin. I will try that next time!
I truly love this recipe! I’m making it again for some folks that aren’t fans of coconut, so I’d like to use dairy of some sort. Would you recommend heavy cream or half and half?
Hi Adam! Another reader has reported success with using cream in this recipe. I’d suggest using a reduced amount. Start with 3/4 cup, then if you want it more saucy, pour in some extra at the end. I hope this helps!
Has anyone tried making this with broccoli florets? I was planning on making chicken piccata with a side of roasted (frozen) broccoli tonight but I’m thinking maybe I should try this instead because it sounds really good!
Excellent meal. Love a one pot dish that everyone can eat. I used dairy free butter for my allergy son and it was great. My 5 year old said “this is the best meal of all the other meals”. That’s one heck of a compliment!
Made this wiwitwiwith asparagus instead of green beans. It was excellent! I have not used coconut milk in recipes that were not going to be coconut flavored and I was a little concerned, but this really did not have a coconut flavor. The lemon and other seasonings flavored the rich sauce.
This is my family favourite recipe. I have made it several times already and each time there is no leftovers!! I love the lemon part of this recipe makes it so good with the coconut milk. I am a big fan of coconut milk (healthier and less fattening than cream). Please don’t skip searing the chicken as that’s the trick to having that smoky smell. I tried with flat beans, asparagus and okras. I liked the combination with okras the best!! Thanks Erin for such a great and simple recipe. Hope to try your other healthy recipes!! I am all in for healthier version recipes.
Can I sub cream for the coconut milk
Definitely Jana! I’d use a reduced amount. Start with 3/4 cup, then if you want it more saucy, pour in some extra at the end.
We made this on Friday night and it was delicious. Served with a baguette and it was the perfect ending to a busy week.
Hooray! Thanks for reporting back, Kara. I’m glad you enjoyed it!
Husband gave it 8 “wow, this is a great dish” compliments–6 during the meal and 2 afterwards. He thought it was a dish worthy of being served in a ritzy restaurant and loved the sauce with the green beans. He would have given it 6 stars out of 5 if he could. I don’t have a big oven proof skillet so I browned the chicken and pulled the sauce together with the green beans in a skillet, then transferred to a pyrex casserole dish. Not quite 1 dish but not bad. Thanks for another great recipe, Erin!
Thank you so much Beverly. What a compliment! I am so pleased. I really appreciate the 5 star rating too. It’s super helpful for others as well!
Erin – this recipe was a huge hit with the whole family and super easy to make! Even my super-picky 5 year old loved it.
Katie-Rose, so so sooo happy to hear it, thank you!!
I had only 2 chicken thighs so I added beef polish sausage to my asparagus-shiitake mushroom veggie mix. I thought I truly mangled the recipe, but it is delicious. The sauce is yummy regardless of the meat. Thank you!
Vicki, thanks for sharing your tweaks! I’m glad you enjoyed it.
I am thrilled with the coconut milk instead of cream – wow! What a silky twist with the lemon. I used asparagus for an incredible win, win, win! Thank you for, yet again, another fine meal!
Hooray! I’m glad this recipe was a hit, Brenna. Thanks for taking the time to share this review!
Erin could you do the whole dish on top of the stove instead of baking. My oven is not working. Or maybe crockpot.
Hi Kay, I have not tried that myself, but I think you could experiment if your oven is not working!
This was so incredibly good!! I put it over cauliflower rice to help eat as much sauce as possible. Super easy being in one pan. Will definitely make this again.
Katie, thanks for sharing this review! I’m glad it was a winner.
So delicious. ? Will be making again!
I’m glad you loved it, Jenn! Thanks for taking the time to share this review!
Hi Erin, this recipe was fabulous. I’m super picky and I loved everything about this recipe. It was so delicious and easy to make. I’m keto and do IF so this easily kept my carbs in check. It was filling even without any side dishes or bread. I will definitely be adding this to my rotation of favorite meals. I’m so glad I tried this recipe.
Thank you.
I’m SO happy that you enjoyed it, Lucy! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I now know the recipe behind the phrase ‘Winner, winner, chicken dinner!’ Like literally every other recipe I’ve made from this site this is AMAZING! My 5 year old brother – who like nothing but pizza and ice cream – said ‘I actually like this chicken!’ WILL WONDERS NEVER CEASE? My mind is blown! The problem is, I’m writing a review for every recipe I make. Soon, I’m going to run out of glowing things to say. Would you be mad if I had a default ‘amazing recipe’ review? Anyway, this is yet another going on the dinner schedule! Love that it limits the dishes, too!
Hi Kassidy! You MADE my day with this incredibly kind review! I’m so happy your brother enjoyed this recipe too!
A very tasty, easy recipe with limited prep and next to no cleanup! Bonus all around. My husband loved it and couldn’t say enough about how delicious it was. I will definitely serve this again and again.
Patti, this means so much to hear. I really appreciate your taking time for this review!
It was very tasty. I will be making this recipe again, but would like advice on how to get the sauce a bit thicker. I used the full fat coconut milk, but it really didn’t thicken up.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Becki! Thank you for sharing this kind review! I haven’t tried thickening this sauce myself, but you could experiment with letting it simmer uncovered for a bit on the stovetop before adding the chicken back in and baking it.
Thank you for the suggestion, Erin. I will try that next time!
I truly love this recipe! I’m making it again for some folks that aren’t fans of coconut, so I’d like to use dairy of some sort. Would you recommend heavy cream or half and half?
Thanks for sharing!!!
Hi Adam! Another reader has reported success with using cream in this recipe. I’d suggest using a reduced amount. Start with 3/4 cup, then if you want it more saucy, pour in some extra at the end. I hope this helps!
Loved it !!!! Will make again for sure.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Tammy! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Delicious! Served with coconut rice. Reused the extra sauce with shrimp and pasta the next night.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Tonya! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Has anyone tried making this with broccoli florets? I was planning on making chicken piccata with a side of roasted (frozen) broccoli tonight but I’m thinking maybe I should try this instead because it sounds really good!
Hi Lynn! I haven’t tried it myself, but I think it would be delicious served alongside my Roasted Frozen Broccoli recipe. I hope this helps!
Excellent meal. Love a one pot dish that everyone can eat. I used dairy free butter for my allergy son and it was great. My 5 year old said “this is the best meal of all the other meals”. That’s one heck of a compliment!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Lindsay! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Made this wiwitwiwith asparagus instead of green beans. It was excellent! I have not used coconut milk in recipes that were not going to be coconut flavored and I was a little concerned, but this really did not have a coconut flavor. The lemon and other seasonings flavored the rich sauce.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Shay Ann! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This recipe is delicious, the lemon makes everything else taste better.
Hi Kathleen! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Loved this recipe! It’s super easy and doesn’t need too many ingredients. Highly recommend it!
Hi J! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This is my family favourite recipe. I have made it several times already and each time there is no leftovers!! I love the lemon part of this recipe makes it so good with the coconut milk. I am a big fan of coconut milk (healthier and less fattening than cream). Please don’t skip searing the chicken as that’s the trick to having that smoky smell. I tried with flat beans, asparagus and okras. I liked the combination with okras the best!! Thanks Erin for such a great and simple recipe. Hope to try your other healthy recipes!! I am all in for healthier version recipes.
Hi Leonie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!