Hi Francisca! I haven’t tested it out with yogurt so I am not sure that would work. Yogurt is thicker than buttermilk. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!
I believe this comment about the usage of “cups” indicates they are used to metric baking measurements. Metric is more accurate anyhow, so we all definitely appreciate it when it’s included—not to mention most of the world used metric. I used to turn up my nose to metric, but eventually was humbled when I became an avid baker. Thanks for the INCREDIBLE lemon cake recipe!!!
Hi Amy! Correct, but we needed to know if it was for the cake flour, powdered sugar or the buttermilk because the weight would be different depending on the ingredient. So glad you enjoyed it! Thank you!
’m sorry this didn’t come out perfectly for you, Ginger! Were you using a glass or ceramic pan? Glass conducts heat very differently than metal, so that will change how the cake bakes and can make it become dry. Also, if you baked the cake in a 9-inch pan (vs the 8 inch in the recipe) that can cause it to cook more quickly too. Every oven is also different. It might be that your oven runs a little hot. I recommend using an oven thermometer, just to be safe.
This cake was delicious!! I don’t usually like icing because they are often too sweet but this lemon icing was delicious! I made lemon curd with the leftover egg yolks and put a layer of lemon curd and the lemon icing on top of each other in the middle layer! It was just for my husband and I so I am probably going to end up freezing a lot of it.
This was suuuuch an amazing cake!!! I didn’t use cake flour because it was a lil last minute and still turned out so well. Have had so many people from the birthday hit me up for more baking or the recipe! Thank you
This is one of the best cakes I’ve ever had in my life. I did not know I could physically create something this enjoyable. This needs to be someone’s wedding cake. My 4 year old initially asked for a blueberry cake for his birthday, but I gently steered him towards this because I trust Erin. (Is that bad?) He loved it so much!!
I asked 3 neighbors and all anyone had were dark 9-inch pans. But it was so fine! My mom showed me the spring-back-when-touched technique Erin mentions here, so we just kept checking! One pan was maybe more full and just took longer.
The most tedious thing was trying to trim parchment circles the right size and then butter those and not mess up the existing butter/flour coating. Do they sell parchment circles? There must be a hack. Maybe I’m just a lazy baker. But it was all very worth it. I will be eating leftover lemon icing off graham crackers for days.
No need to buy round parchment. Take a piece of parchment. Place the bottom of your cake pan on the parchment and draw a circle around it. Cut the circle and place inside the pan!
I have made this recipe many times, my son LOVES lemon cake. I personally use about 1/2 the sugar in the frosting, but I really prefer all frosting less sweet. It’s easy, it has come out good every single time. I currently have a sheet cake in the oven for a birthday party, not sure how it’ll come out. I did 1.5 the recipe, fingers crossed.
Hi Maeve! I see you decreased the amount of sugar in the frosting as you don’t like things too sweet. Neither do I! So I’m wondering if the cake itself wasn’t too sweet for your taste with 1.5 cups of sugar?
After making and eating this, I realized I didn’t have a really good lemon cake recipe until now. Recently I acquired two 6 inch tin lined copper cake pans, to pair with two others I owned in the same size. Now that I have four, I wanted to try this recipe. From the explicit instructions, I could tell this cake had the chance to be exceptional, and it is. My first attempt at this had me making three six inch layers, which was ideal for the amount of batter. Next time, I think I will use all four pans, so I can have two, 2 layer cakes when I bake. This became an instant favorite at first bite! Thank you for your generous sharing of this amazing recipe.
I made this for my daughter’s first and second birthday. This year she is old enough to say she wants a strawberry cake but I am steering her toward this one again! Such a delicious spring/summer dessert!
I have made this cake many many times. It is a big favorite of my families. Today I am making it for my husband’s memorial service has this was his favorite cake.
Hi Danielle! Readers have reported they have used this recipe to make 24-26 standard-size cupcakes. Bake at the same temperature for about 16 minutes. Be sure to use paper liners so they don’t stick. Some have even said they did mini cupcakes. You would bake at the same temperature but just decrease the time. Hope this helps!
I absolutely love the flavour of this cake and frosting – it’s my go to lemon cake recipe. However, I have loads of problems with the thickness of the frosting. It is always so runny and it’s hard to keep the lemon flavour and thickness so you can use it to pipe on cupcakes. I always end up having to add loads more sugar which isn’t ideal or I have to reduce the cream cheese content.
Other than that, it’s delicious 😋
Hi Michelle, at which point of beating are you finding it gets runny? If it is happening before you add your extract and lemon juice then the cream cheese and butter are too soft. They should be softened but not warm. If it is after you add the liquid, try reducing it just slightly or leaving out the extract and see if that helps you.
Hi Erin! My family loved this cake – especially the frosting. It looked a bit intimidating at first, but having all the ingredients measured out and prepared in advance really helped. This is one of those recipes you want to read fully and before you start cooking. Thank you for sharing this gem! Will definitely make it again.
It’s very good. It’s the first cake I have made by myself without a box. Definitely have to wait for the cake to cool off before putting the frosting on. I was just practicing before I made one for my husband’s birthday. I love the detailed instructions. Thank you.
This recipe turned out perfectly! It was moist and the icing was creamy and delicious. Just enough lemon flavour, without being overpowering. Yum, definitely one of the best things I have made so far!
I made this for a Ladies’ Luncheon. It was the favorite of all the dishes there. The lemon flavor was wonderful!! Definitely will be saving this one for future use. Thank you for sharing!!
Made this as a mini-layer birthday cake (with 6 inch pans) using measure-for-measure Gluten Free flour (that has xanthan gum already in it). Made a full recipe of the frosting because… frosting! Only change I made was to adjust for size of cake and add some lemon oil to intensify the flavor. Tasted great but, likely due to the GF flour, it was heavy and stodgy not light and fluffy. Everyone loved it but it wasn’t up to my standards. I wonder if I should have kept the baking powder at 1 tablespoon instead of halving it? As always, thanks for great recipes!
I made 24 cupcakes with this recipe. I did not have buttermilk, lemon extract or cake flour, so I used the suggestions from the comments…all turned out super! I ended up baking them for about 20 minutes with very close watching and then testing with a toothpick! They are light, creamy and delicious!
My Kids Club kiddos will love them and be asking for the recipe!!! LOL! Thank you for this yummy recipe!!!
I have made this cake before and everybody loved it. In fact, my friend has asked me to make this cake for her daughter’s graduation; she requested a half sheet cake. Do you have any recommendations for this? 3x the recipe? Thank you!!!
So glad you enjoyed it, Kathryn. I haven’t tried it in a half sheet cake but another reader has and didn’t mention about increasing the recipe. I would think 2x would be enough. Hope this helps and let us know how it goes!
Hello, I don`t have buttermilk can I replace it with plain yogurt or Greek yogurt?
Hi Francisca! I haven’t tested it out with yogurt so I am not sure that would work. Yogurt is thicker than buttermilk. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes!
You can always add one tbsp of either lemon juice or white vinegar per cup of milk to make it similar to buttermilk.
Also if you have heavy whipping cream, keep mixing it until it turns to butter. The liquid around the butter is buttermilk.
Thanks for the tip!
Dear Erin! Can you help me, how big is the “cup” in this recipe?
Hi! Sorry, I am not sure what you are asking me. How big is the cup? For which ingredient are you asking about?
I believe this comment about the usage of “cups” indicates they are used to metric baking measurements. Metric is more accurate anyhow, so we all definitely appreciate it when it’s included—not to mention most of the world used metric. I used to turn up my nose to metric, but eventually was humbled when I became an avid baker. Thanks for the INCREDIBLE lemon cake recipe!!!
Hi Amy! Correct, but we needed to know if it was for the cake flour, powdered sugar or the buttermilk because the weight would be different depending on the ingredient. So glad you enjoyed it! Thank you!
I baked this cake, but found that it was fluffy but dry. What could I have done wrong or what could be missing?
The frosting is awesome though!
’m sorry this didn’t come out perfectly for you, Ginger! Were you using a glass or ceramic pan? Glass conducts heat very differently than metal, so that will change how the cake bakes and can make it become dry. Also, if you baked the cake in a 9-inch pan (vs the 8 inch in the recipe) that can cause it to cook more quickly too. Every oven is also different. It might be that your oven runs a little hot. I recommend using an oven thermometer, just to be safe.
This cake was delicious!! I don’t usually like icing because they are often too sweet but this lemon icing was delicious! I made lemon curd with the leftover egg yolks and put a layer of lemon curd and the lemon icing on top of each other in the middle layer! It was just for my husband and I so I am probably going to end up freezing a lot of it.
Hi Katie! So glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for this kind review!
This was suuuuch an amazing cake!!! I didn’t use cake flour because it was a lil last minute and still turned out so well. Have had so many people from the birthday hit me up for more baking or the recipe! Thank you
So happy that it worked well for you despite using cake flour! Thank you Rosie!
absolutely fantastic! I’ve made this twice to rave reviews. made exactly per recipe, to die for!!! yumyumyum
Thank you, Diane!
This is one of the best cakes I’ve ever had in my life. I did not know I could physically create something this enjoyable. This needs to be someone’s wedding cake. My 4 year old initially asked for a blueberry cake for his birthday, but I gently steered him towards this because I trust Erin. (Is that bad?) He loved it so much!!
I asked 3 neighbors and all anyone had were dark 9-inch pans. But it was so fine! My mom showed me the spring-back-when-touched technique Erin mentions here, so we just kept checking! One pan was maybe more full and just took longer.
The most tedious thing was trying to trim parchment circles the right size and then butter those and not mess up the existing butter/flour coating. Do they sell parchment circles? There must be a hack. Maybe I’m just a lazy baker. But it was all very worth it. I will be eating leftover lemon icing off graham crackers for days.
That’s so great! Thank you Sharon, and YES! They do sell parchment paper circles. Here’s a link to them: https://amzn.to/48XwIcF (affiliate)
No need to buy round parchment. Take a piece of parchment. Place the bottom of your cake pan on the parchment and draw a circle around it. Cut the circle and place inside the pan!
Thanks for the tip, Susan!
I have made this recipe many times, my son LOVES lemon cake. I personally use about 1/2 the sugar in the frosting, but I really prefer all frosting less sweet. It’s easy, it has come out good every single time. I currently have a sheet cake in the oven for a birthday party, not sure how it’ll come out. I did 1.5 the recipe, fingers crossed.
Thanks for this recipe!
Great to hear! Thank you Maeve!
Hi Maeve! I see you decreased the amount of sugar in the frosting as you don’t like things too sweet. Neither do I! So I’m wondering if the cake itself wasn’t too sweet for your taste with 1.5 cups of sugar?
After making and eating this, I realized I didn’t have a really good lemon cake recipe until now. Recently I acquired two 6 inch tin lined copper cake pans, to pair with two others I owned in the same size. Now that I have four, I wanted to try this recipe. From the explicit instructions, I could tell this cake had the chance to be exceptional, and it is. My first attempt at this had me making three six inch layers, which was ideal for the amount of batter. Next time, I think I will use all four pans, so I can have two, 2 layer cakes when I bake. This became an instant favorite at first bite! Thank you for your generous sharing of this amazing recipe.
Makes me so happy to hear, thank you Clarity!
I made this for my daughter’s first and second birthday. This year she is old enough to say she wants a strawberry cake but I am steering her toward this one again! Such a delicious spring/summer dessert!
Makes me so happy to hear, thank you Faith!
I have made this cake many many times. It is a big favorite of my families. Today I am making it for my husband’s memorial service has this was his favorite cake.
I am so sorry to hear that, Jill. Warmest hugs.
Can I follow this recipe for cupcakes? If so will it make the standard 24 cupcakes?
Hi Danielle! Readers have reported they have used this recipe to make 24-26 standard-size cupcakes. Bake at the same temperature for about 16 minutes. Be sure to use paper liners so they don’t stick. Some have even said they did mini cupcakes. You would bake at the same temperature but just decrease the time. Hope this helps!
I absolutely love the flavour of this cake and frosting – it’s my go to lemon cake recipe. However, I have loads of problems with the thickness of the frosting. It is always so runny and it’s hard to keep the lemon flavour and thickness so you can use it to pipe on cupcakes. I always end up having to add loads more sugar which isn’t ideal or I have to reduce the cream cheese content.
Other than that, it’s delicious 😋
Hi Michelle, at which point of beating are you finding it gets runny? If it is happening before you add your extract and lemon juice then the cream cheese and butter are too soft. They should be softened but not warm. If it is after you add the liquid, try reducing it just slightly or leaving out the extract and see if that helps you.
Hi Erin! My family loved this cake – especially the frosting. It looked a bit intimidating at first, but having all the ingredients measured out and prepared in advance really helped. This is one of those recipes you want to read fully and before you start cooking. Thank you for sharing this gem! Will definitely make it again.
So happy to hear you enjoyed it, Chyntia!
It’s very good. It’s the first cake I have made by myself without a box. Definitely have to wait for the cake to cool off before putting the frosting on. I was just practicing before I made one for my husband’s birthday. I love the detailed instructions. Thank you.
Yay! Makes me so happy to hear, Amanda!
This recipe turned out perfectly! It was moist and the icing was creamy and delicious. Just enough lemon flavour, without being overpowering. Yum, definitely one of the best things I have made so far!
So glad you enjoyed it, Aubrey! Thank you!
I made this for a Ladies’ Luncheon. It was the favorite of all the dishes there. The lemon flavor was wonderful!! Definitely will be saving this one for future use. Thank you for sharing!!
Yay! Thank you Terri!
Made this as a mini-layer birthday cake (with 6 inch pans) using measure-for-measure Gluten Free flour (that has xanthan gum already in it). Made a full recipe of the frosting because… frosting! Only change I made was to adjust for size of cake and add some lemon oil to intensify the flavor. Tasted great but, likely due to the GF flour, it was heavy and stodgy not light and fluffy. Everyone loved it but it wasn’t up to my standards. I wonder if I should have kept the baking powder at 1 tablespoon instead of halving it? As always, thanks for great recipes!
Thanks for the feedback, Mark! Yes I’d suggest keeping it at 1 tablespoon. Thanks!
Still my favorite lemon cake recipe, so moist and flavorful.
Looks fabulous Judy! Thank you!
I made 24 cupcakes with this recipe. I did not have buttermilk, lemon extract or cake flour, so I used the suggestions from the comments…all turned out super! I ended up baking them for about 20 minutes with very close watching and then testing with a toothpick! They are light, creamy and delicious!
My Kids Club kiddos will love them and be asking for the recipe!!! LOL! Thank you for this yummy recipe!!!
So glad to hear it came out for you, Joyce! Thanks for letting us know!
I have made this cake before and everybody loved it. In fact, my friend has asked me to make this cake for her daughter’s graduation; she requested a half sheet cake. Do you have any recommendations for this? 3x the recipe? Thank you!!!
So glad you enjoyed it, Kathryn. I haven’t tried it in a half sheet cake but another reader has and didn’t mention about increasing the recipe. I would think 2x would be enough. Hope this helps and let us know how it goes!