1. Hi Lisa! Red lentils and yellow lentils are very delicate, so while they are great for Indian curries like dal, they become mushy in soup and are less desirable. Hope this helps!

  • Outstanding recipe and one that we’ve been making on repeat! Perfect for the colder months. Love the flavor that the fire-roasted tomatoes contribute, and it’s heavenly with parmesan as you recommended! Another healthy and delicious recipe to add to our rotation. Thank you Erin! :)5 stars

  • Haven’t made it yet but can tell it will be outstanding. I know the base recipe is super healthy … but the idea of some bacon really sounded like a natural to me and I may opt to cheat a little. Curious Erin … if I opt for bacon, how much do you think would be a good amount?

    1. Hi Bill! Sounds tasty! Maybe about 4 slices? If you decide to experiment with bacon, I’d love to know how it goes!

  • Flavors were amazing. Left it vegan for our daughter and added the Parmesan individually to our bowls. I think my lentils might have been old, because it took over 90 minutes for them to get Al dente. I probably will soak first next time, since the bag I had in the pantry is very large. Will definitely make again!5 stars

  • Fantastic recipe, so flavorful and so easy to make. I didn’t know lentil soup could be so delicious. It also freezes perfectly. I made a big batch just to keep it in the freezer for the future.5 stars

  • Absolutely delicious! I got distracted and forgot to turn the temp down to simmer so mine ended up closer to a thick stew but still so tasty with the perfect spice blend. I think I found my new meal prep recipe!5 stars

  • One of my good friends sent this recipe to me and it’s been in my favorites ever since. It’s so delicious, feels like a warm hug and I don’t feel guilty when I get seconds! My favorite way to spice it up is to put a fried egg on top; trust me, chef’s kiss!5 stars

  • This is the best soup recipe I have ever made, cooking instructions are clear, ingredients are perfect and always on hand. This is perfect. Thank you for sharing this. It is now officially a staple in this house5 stars

  • I made this recipe today. Let’s just say that we have a new favorite soup. This was amazing! I served it with a grilled cheese sandwich.5 stars

  • What a delicious soup! It was perfect for this cold weather. Even my husband, who doesn’t like lentils, enjoyed it. My three kids also asked me to add it to our meal rotation. Thanks for a great recipe.5 stars

  • Delicious soup! I serve it often for guests with some crusty bread and salad. Everyone loves it. Sometimes if we have leftovers we end up making a pie the next night, just puff pastry on the bottom and mashed potato and cheese on top. It was amazing and there was none left! Great meal for young kids.5 stars

  • I absolutely love this recipe! I’ve made it twice now- the second time I made it I froze half to take on a camping trip and it was so nice to have around the campfire. We made some garlic bread to serve with it, but it would be equally as delicious on its own!5 stars

  • Had a great time cooking this with my Mom. We live in different states, but still love to cook together on FaceTime. This recipe is cozy and wholesome, I made a double batch to eat all week long for lunch with some crunchy toasted bread!5 stars

  • I made this yesterday and it is delicious! I added a Parmesan cheese rind like I do with a lot of soups. It was so easy to make and comforting on a cold snowy day. I simmered for longer than the recipe says because my lentils were too firm. Other than that I followed the recipe. Thank you Erin for a nutritious and delicious soup!5 stars

  • I made the lentil soup recipe today and it is now in the fridge awaiting to be served tomorrow night for dinner with a green salad and open faced grilled cheese pcs. I can hardly wait to taste it. I had a really good time prepping and making it. I will definitely add mushrooms next time but I wanted to make it according to your recipe this 1st time. Thank you!5 stars

  • Terrific recipe ! The addition of honey and just a pinch of pepper flakes added a secret boost in flavor . Straight forward instructions are always a plus . Definitely a keeper recipe for us .5 stars