• This looks like such a perfect healthy bread recipe! I usually don’t make my own bread because I always mess it up but I wouldn’t mind trying again using this recipe! Love the added poppy seeds too.

    1. You will be far more sucessful than you think Natalie! Pulling homemade bread out of the oven is just the best feeling. You should totally go for it :)

  • Homemade bread scares the pants off me but this recipe seems manageable due to the tips you outlined. Fingers crossed!

    1. Nicole, you can totally do this! Yeast breads used to scare me too, until I gave them a go and saw how truly easy bread baking can be. I’m sure you’d rock this recipe!

  • Gooorgeous loaf of bread! This came out perfectly. I love your tips…makes me feel like I might actually be able to make this :D5 stars

      1. Hi Maureen!
        Just checked — It is a “TruTemp” meat thermometer that I originally purchased at Target. Any old brand will do though! Glad you asked :)

  • What a great idea to use cornmeal in your soaker! I’ve never done that before, but I’m tempted to try it because this bread sure looks delicious!! :)

    1. The cornmeal is fantastic Yvonne. It disperses all throughout and makes for a killer slice of bread. You should totally go for it! Thanks so much for your comment. Hope you enjoy!

  • This is such a pretty dough….I love how dark and wheaty it is and like you said, you have to be patient with wheat and give it time. And the rewards are worth it!

  • This recipe is basically exactly what I’m looking for, except I loooove my bread machine (okay.. and walking away and totally forgetting I was making bread until it’s magically done). What are your thoughts on this in a bread machine? I have a whole wheat setting with an extended rise time.

    1. Hey Kelly!
      To be honest, I have never used a bread machine. Are you usually able to translate recipes directly? If yes, so long as you stick with the long rise time and include the vital gluten + the soaker, I don’t see why it wouldn’t work. This bread is so crazy good, I would say it is worth a shot! Let me know how it goes for you. I’d love the info for future reference!

  • This bread was astonishingly easy and delicious. I especially appreciated that you included the temperature for doneness. The “thump” method has never worked for me, but my 190 degree loaf was perfect. Do you think this same temp. would work for the rosemary olive oil bread? Thank you!5 stars

    1. Kathryn, this made my day! I adore this bread, and I’m so happy that you enjoyed it too. I agree that temperature is the best method, and I’m glad you asked about my Rosemary Olive Oil Bread. 190 degrees is perfect, and I’ve updated the recipe to reflect this. If you make the Rosemary bread, prepare yourself: your kitchen will smell like heaven :) Thanks again and have a wonderful day!

  • can you leave out the brown rice? Seems like a lot of extra time to cook rice just for this recipe only to use 3 tbsp of it

    1. Hi Heather! Great question. You can simply substitute the rice for an equal amount of rolled oats. I usually use leftover rice, and if I don’t have any, go the oat route or make a small amount of rice in the microwave. I hope that helps and that you enjoy the bread!

  • I am trying this recipe in my bread machine right now…a few more hours to go! I will let you know how it turns out. Probably not quite as good as made with your own two hands but I had to try it. Thanks Erin!

    1. I’m sure it’s going to be delicious Erin! I can’t wait to hear what you think. Have a great day and enjoy the bread!

  • It tastes awesome but I don’t think it rose completely because it did not fill the loaf pan and was a little misshapen; maybe the yeast needs to be adjusted when using a bread machine or the extended rise time wasn’t quite enough in the machine! Anyway, thanks for the soaking tip and the recipe! I will play with the yeast a little and see what happens next time, or just try making it by hand :)5 stars

  • well, it doesn’t look as pretty as yours :) but it smells delish! I used quinoa instead of cornmeal (wasn’t sure if it needed to be cooked quinoa or not & the only cooked I had was cooked with veggie broth so I used uncooked & hoped it would poof up during the soaker stage…not so much) & rolled oats on top (next time i’ll press them in as they just fall off). But i’m sure it tastes great!

    Mine was also only 1 1/2 hours for first rise & less than 1/2 hour for second! I checked it at half an hour and it was already 1 1/2 inches above the rim!5 stars

    1. Heather, I’m so so so excited that you tried this bread! Every kitchen and rising environment is different—I’m actually jealous that your dough rise more quickly than mine will! I think the raw quinoa will be great and add nice texture. Enjoy every bite, and thanks again :)

    1. Pete, thank you so much for telling me that! Makes me feel like I am in good company :-) I will come visit if I’m ever in the area!

  • I have been looking for a good 100% whole wheat multi grain bread recipe for a while now…and this one is perfect!! I used quinoa instead of the cornmeal. And I also subbed in some golden flax seeds, sesame seeds, buck wheat groats, and chia seeds in the soaker. And I used coconut sugar instead of brown sugar. Topped it with some of the flax, sesame, and chia seeds and it’s AMAZING!! 

    Thank you so much for sharing! I’m going to put together some of the orange coconut chia pudding for in the morning!5 stars

    1. Kateland, I am so, so excited to hear this, and I think the swaps you made sound delicious. Thanks for trying the recipe and taking time to leave your review. I truly appreciate it!

  • I make this in my bread maker and it turns out great. I substitute almond milk for the buttermilk.  I also omit the brown sugar and just add a teaspoon of agave or honey and it tastes great toasted with avocado or almond butter. Thanks for the recipe! 5 stars

    1. Heather, I’m so happy to hear that, and it’s great that it worked in your bread machine too. Thanks so much for trying the recipe and taking time to leave your review. I truly appreciate it!

  • I made this amazing Magic Multigrain Whole Wheat Bread, and it is on my list of weekly recipes. The bread was great with the chili, and I know it will be great alone, as toast, for a sandwich, or any other way I eat it. Great recipe!  Thanks!

  • Looks great !! But I am allergic to wheat  rice. Potato  and corn. I have experimented with your oat bread it really good. But need a good sandwich bread. Can you help ??  Any  would
    Be appreciated.  Thanks

    1. Hi Vanessa! I apologize, but I haven’t been baking bread as much the past few years, and I don’t have experience making one from scratch without these ingredients. I would suggest an online recipe search, and use a recipe from a source that is reliable. King Arthur Flour is a great example, so I would start there. I hope that is at least a little helpful!

  • Made this yesterday with no changes and it turned out beautiful and very tasty! I’m still a novice with yeast bread, but the instructions made it foolproof!5 stars

  • I make this on the regular so here are some time saving hacks. Make a big batch of rice and portion out in separate ziploc bags. Measure out grains for soaker and place in separate ziploc bags. Place in one gallon bag and pop in freezer to keep your starter kit all in one place. I’ll usually prep about 6 batches and I always double the recipe to make two loaves as I cut and freeze the loaves. If you don’t want to soak overnight, I’ve found microwaving the grains for a minute with the water to start activating them works great. Usually I start at 8a. Around 2p, I mix my bread and let rise until 4p, when I shape into loaves and bake at 5p. I can’t recommend this recipe enough – so healthy and delicious with a great crumb and consistent results. Don’t skip the buttermilk – I tried milk mixed with vinegar and the bread is far better with buttermilk. Not even comparable.5 stars

    1. Unfortunately I have not tried it with this recipe, so you would be experimenting. Let me know how it goes!