• Made three of these for Thanksgiving 2021. For the first time, I did not have to cover the crust while baking! This pie was noticed by everyone for not having such a strong nutmeg taste! Recipe going into my favorite file. Thank You!
    PS: I did use the frozen pie crust that you roll out. I let thaw and placed in the pie pan. I did not pre-bake. Also used my chicken’s fresh eggs and a good vanilla. So Excited, its a Perfect Pie!5 stars

  • Thank you so much for this fantastic recipe! It is really delicious. I doubled the recipe and baked the potatoes whole for a few hours instead of boiling them. I refrigerated it overnight and the next morning it was amazing! 100% recommend!5 stars

  • Do you think I could sub out the pie crust, and add a biscuit base instead? Maybe have it take on more of a sweet potato slice rather than a pie?
    Thanks!

    1. hi Gloria, maybe. This is not something I’ve experimented with or tested so I can’t say for sure. If you decide to experiment let me know how it goes!

  • I followed this recipe and this pie tasted AMAZING! My 10 yr old daughter is a very tough critic & passionately honest & she loves this pie! Thanks for making it easy & giving us a video to watch!5 stars

  • Thanks so much Erin for these wonderful recipes! We loved this pie
    P.S: Sweet potatoes are my favorite food and I have been searching for ways to make more things with them5 stars

  • Hi there! I’m using sweet potatoes from my garden this year, which are a tad smaller than what you typically see in the grocery store. About how many cups or weight (grams) does two large sweet potatoes come out to be? Just want to be sure my ratios are correct. This recipe sounds wonderful! LOVE the additions of the bourbon and marshmallow!

    1. Hi Danielle! I didn’t measure my sweet potatoes in cups or weight, but you will need 2 cups cooked sweet potato for this pie. Hope you enjoy it!

  • Hi Erin, I’m making this sweet potato pie for Thanksgiving. I’m unclear as to when to add the marshmallow cream when making the topping. Should the heavy cream and marshmallow cream be beaten together at the same time?

    1. Hi Nanci! This post has recently been updated and has no marshmallow cream. If you would like to include it, you would add it with the heavy cream. Hope you enjoy the pie!

  • I was short on time and used canned sweet potato yams. I also added extra cinnamon and nutmeg. It was delicious! Next time I will try it with fresh sweet potatoes!5 stars

  • I’ve never made or tasted sweet potato pie before but decided to make this. It was sooooo good! I did add a little extra sugar. I love the creamy goodness and light great texture.5 stars

  • I have read your recipe multiple times but I can’t see where you use the granulated sugar. I don’t see it in the picture.
    Can you help please? I sound desperate, don’t I. Sorry!
    Looking forward to making your recipe because you have such wonderful reviews.
    Thank you

  • I’ve never had a sweet potato pie before but was curious. It’s the perfect combination of sweet but not too sweet. 5 stars

  • Hey! I made this earlier and the pie is perfectly sweet and creamy. The spices are perfectly balanced, and the pie is not too dense.5 stars

  • It’s the first time I made sweet potato pie and it came out delightfully good. So good, in fact, I’m making another one in the weekend.5 stars

  • I just found this recipe and have already made it twice! It is so good, but of course, I put my own touch to it. I added more spice. We love cinnamon so I added just a touch more of the spices.5 stars

    1. Hi Angela! I’ve actually only tested the recipe with evaporated milk but doing some research it seems like there are a few things you can use as a substitute. Half and half, heavy cream, or regular milk. If you decide to experiment with one of these I’d love to know how it comes out! Thank you!

  • I think I’m missing something, is the whipped cream just whipping cream and vanilla? Is there any confectioners sugar added? If marshmallow fluff was added how much would need to be added? I very much want to make this!

    1. Hi Stephanie! The whipped cream isn’t sweetened but you could add a few tablespoons of confectioner’s sugar if you like.