• I made your delicious peanut butter blossom cookies for my grandsons. It was a pre Christmas treat. My husband and I were watching them for the evening. The extra time spent on making the browned butter was well worth the effort. I also love your cut out sugar cookie recipe.5 stars

    1. The brown butter added great flavor. Also made the cookies hold together better. This my new go to recipe for these.

  • I am giving it 4 stars only because the cookie is so dry as it crumbles in your mouth. Otherwise, it is great alternative to the go-to chocolate chip cookies.4 stars

    1. Hi Kam! Two things that come to mind. Make sure to measure the flour precisely and I’d try baking them just a minute or two shorter. Thanks!

  • Made these for my neighbors this week and they were a hit with them and the kids! I always get impatient making brown butter but your note on how “the crackling will stop” when it’s almost done helped so much! Note to future bakers, don’t start late at night like I did! I didn’t read the length time and after starting realized the dough needed to sit for a minimum of 4 hours and started them late at night lol. They were worth the wait!3 stars

  • Great amount of chewiness with the perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate flavor. Thanks for the recipe, Erin!5 stars

  • These are one of my favorite holiday cookies! I love to experiment with them and added some chopped toasted pecans for extra nuttiness! The brown butter is so worth it and really takes these to another level. Just delicious!5 stars

  • I’ve been a fan of these cookies for years, but have never made them myself. Your recipe had me at BROWN BUTTER! I absolutely loved them, and I’m taking them on my cookie platter to our family Christmas party! 🎄5 stars

  • Perfect little cookies! I usually pass on this cookie because of the kiss in the middle-just an awkward bite, but these are so good! A little short on kisses so I used squares of a hershey bar. Will be making them again within the week!5 stars

  • Peanut butter blossoms are my husband favorite Christmas cookie. I’m usually lazy and just use the packaged mix, but decided to try these. They were absolutely delicious and I think I’ll probably never go back to the mix. My 4 and 6 year old also gave them “100 thumbs up!”5 stars

  • These were amazing, my kids all say they are some of their favorite Christmas cookies! It was a good thing I made a double batch too because I started late in the day so I chilled it overnight but that gave my teenage daughter too much time to sneak in and eat the dough :)5 stars

  • I make these every year and I love your updated version of browsing the butter! Gives it so much flavor. The hardest part is the chill time. But overall, Yum!5 stars

    1. Kristin, I’m sorry to hear that! It sounds like the flour might have been overmeasured since the cookies are dry. Did you fluff it up before scooping or do the spoon and sweep method? I’m glad you can enjoy them on ice cream at least!

  • My all time favorite Christmas cookie to make now! Such a huge hit with everyone. They come out so perfectly soft, chewy and delicious!5 stars

  • A fun twist on an old classic! I still don’t roll them in sugar (based purely on family preferences), but these were fantastic!5 stars

  • I used all white flour, but I would try it again with part white whole-wheat flour because I like that idea to add a bit more nutrition. The browned butter is a great idea for extra flavor. I like a smaller cookie to chocolate ratio, so I made 3 dozen cookies instead of 2 dozen. When I have made these in the past, I skip the step of rolling the balls in sugar because it is less messy for serving. The cookies do look more attractive with the glittery sugar coating. I also usually use the bagged chocolate kisses, but the real Hershey kisses are definitely tastier.5 stars

  • The brown butter in this recipe gives these cookies a much richer flavor. We followed recipe exactly and they were delicious. I highly recommend. I think next time I will try the caramel kisses…yum!5 stars

  • These cookies are the best! They are definitely a family favorite and number one on my list of cookies to make for
    Christmas!! To make mine a little festive, I sometimes roll them in red and green sugar before baking!5 stars

  • These cookies are delicious! I made the dough in advance and froze it. It was so easy to just pop the balls of frozen dough into the oven when I was ready go bake them! The cookies are delicious! I will definitely make them again.5 stars