I watched your video of this recipe this morning and just knew that I needed to make this for Thanksgiving. It does sound a little out there but there’s cheese!!! We’ll be having ham so this will go well. Happy holiday planning…
This was a hit for Thanksgiving. I didn’t tell anyone what it was so I got several guesses. One of them was potatoes (before tasting) and another was apples. Actually they would probably go very well in this recipe. My brother ended up with the correct guess. It was very good and we liked it because it wasn’t super sweet. Thank you…
I knew I had to make this right away after watching the video! It’s absolutely scrumptious, and the flavors really do pair well together. This dish was made to serve with ham.
This year I hosted thanksgiving dinner well plated stile. I made healthy sweet potato casserole , which was great, and the broccoli salad was really good as well, but the side dish that I got the most mmmmms form my guests was this cheesy pineapple casserole. It was absolutely delicious! Thank you Erin for contributing to a perfect Thanksgiving! I hope you had one just the same!
I thought I would have leftovers after my husband’s family thanksgiving meal, but had to make a second dish for my family! This will be my specialty every year from now on. 🥰
We made this for Easter and it was a HUGE hit !! We also really liked your video story !!This recipe is so yummy !! My family really enjoys all your recipes !! Thanks very much !!
we make this thinner with apples, and its called apple cheese crisp! people who arent used to it always think its a sweet treat but its not! we eat it with our ham! haha i cant wait to try the pineapple!
This dish was an interesting diversion from our standard side dishes. I only had sharp, not extra sharp, cheddar, and I think the extra sharp would have given the needed oomph to make the dish outstanding. It was good, however, and the leftovers had more verve, so next time I’ll mix it the day before and let the flavors meld.
I made this to go with ham on Christmas day. It was a hit with my family. They loved it. I will be adding it to Thanksgiving dinner as well. I’m so glad I found this recipe.
This was amazing! My whole family loved it. There was none left and I wished I had made more. Only difference with mine was maple syrup instead of honey.
Oh my goodness. Pineapple is one of my favorite fruits. Looks delicious and those add-ins are tempting me big time. I love the pineapple and cheese combination
Holy moly! This is delicious! Took it as a side dish to a big family BBQ and it was loved by all. This will also be perfect for Thanksgiving and Christmas.
I just happened to have some pineapple hanging around, so I decided to look at the best place for recipes, & ran across this & we loved it! Super simple!
Made this several times for family holidays and just bought it for a work potluck. I would definitely recommend using a fresh pineapple cut in tidbit size pieces. It’s a little more work but it takes the flavor to the next level.
This is my go-to recipe for pineapple casserole. I make it every holiday and I’ve started automatically making 2 dishes of it because it’s so well-loved that every bit gets devoured. So good and the perfect side for pork chops or ham.
Made this for Thanksgiving dinner. I didn’t know if the sharp cheddar cheese would work with pineapple but it was very good. I used Town House crackers. Very buttery tasting. Delicious, Will definitely make it again.
This recipe is my favorite I have found so far. I love the mix of chunky and crushed pineapple. Not too sweet, just perfect. Highly recommend this recipe!
I watched your video of this recipe this morning and just knew that I needed to make this for Thanksgiving. It does sound a little out there but there’s cheese!!! We’ll be having ham so this will go well. Happy holiday planning…
Hi Chris! Hope you enjoy it!!
This was a hit for Thanksgiving. I didn’t tell anyone what it was so I got several guesses. One of them was potatoes (before tasting) and another was apples. Actually they would probably go very well in this recipe. My brother ended up with the correct guess. It was very good and we liked it because it wasn’t super sweet. Thank you…
Hi Chris! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I knew I had to make this right away after watching the video! It’s absolutely scrumptious, and the flavors really do pair well together. This dish was made to serve with ham.
Thank you for this kind review, Hilary! I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe!
This year I hosted thanksgiving dinner well plated stile. I made healthy sweet potato casserole , which was great, and the broccoli salad was really good as well, but the side dish that I got the most mmmmms form my guests was this cheesy pineapple casserole. It was absolutely delicious! Thank you Erin for contributing to a perfect Thanksgiving! I hope you had one just the same!
Hi Ruxandra! That made my day! THANK YOU!
I thought I would have leftovers after my husband’s family thanksgiving meal, but had to make a second dish for my family! This will be my specialty every year from now on. 🥰
Hi Laura! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
We made this for Easter and it was a HUGE hit !! We also really liked your video story !!This recipe is so yummy !! My family really enjoys all your recipes !! Thanks very much !!
Hi Laurie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Hi Erin! Can I substitute the honey with something? Can’t wait to try it, the reviews are excellent!
Hi Denise, I’ve only tested the recipe as is, but pure maple syrup might work. Hope you enjoy it!
we make this thinner with apples, and its called apple cheese crisp! people who arent used to it always think its a sweet treat but its not! we eat it with our ham! haha i cant wait to try the pineapple!
Hope you enjoy it Candace!
This dish was an interesting diversion from our standard side dishes. I only had sharp, not extra sharp, cheddar, and I think the extra sharp would have given the needed oomph to make the dish outstanding. It was good, however, and the leftovers had more verve, so next time I’ll mix it the day before and let the flavors meld.
Thanks for the feedback Claire!
I made this to go with ham on Christmas day. It was a hit with my family. They loved it. I will be adding it to Thanksgiving dinner as well. I’m so glad I found this recipe.
Hi Andrea! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This was amazing! My whole family loved it. There was none left and I wished I had made more. Only difference with mine was maple syrup instead of honey.
Hi Adeline! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This is fabulous!! Made it for thanksgiving it surprised everyone. I’m making it tonight again with ham. Can’t wait!!
Hi Meldy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Oh my goodness. Pineapple is one of my favorite fruits. Looks delicious and those add-ins are tempting me big time. I love the pineapple and cheese combination
It’s so unexpected but so good!
Holy moly! This is delicious! Took it as a side dish to a big family BBQ and it was loved by all. This will also be perfect for Thanksgiving and Christmas.
YAY Lea, so glad to hear it!
I just happened to have some pineapple hanging around, so I decided to look at the best place for recipes, & ran across this & we loved it! Super simple!
So happy to hear that Tracy, thanks!
Made this several times for family holidays and just bought it for a work potluck. I would definitely recommend using a fresh pineapple cut in tidbit size pieces. It’s a little more work but it takes the flavor to the next level.
Thanks for the tip!
I tested this one out on Friendsgiving and we love it. I will definitely serve this for Thanksgiving dinner with pork tenderloin! Super Yum!!
So happy to hear! Thank you!
So good as a side dish or a dessert! It definitely has less sweetness than other recipes, but the sweetness of the pineapple is quite enough!
Thanks for sharing!
This is my go-to recipe for pineapple casserole. I make it every holiday and I’ve started automatically making 2 dishes of it because it’s so well-loved that every bit gets devoured. So good and the perfect side for pork chops or ham.
Made this for Thanksgiving dinner. I didn’t know if the sharp cheddar cheese would work with pineapple but it was very good. I used Town House crackers. Very buttery tasting. Delicious, Will definitely make it again.
Happy to hear it’s a keeper!
This recipe is my favorite I have found so far. I love the mix of chunky and crushed pineapple. Not too sweet, just perfect. Highly recommend this recipe!