• Good flavor, but I was a little disappointed there weren’t more oats in these. Based on the picture of them in the article I assumed they would be more oat based. But the texture is very cake like & they are yummy even without the icing!4 stars

  • LOVE THESE! they were exactly what i was craving. easy enough to make with a baby in one arm too. i added dark chocolate chips! will definitely be making these again!5 stars

  • This is a very good, very easy recipe. I used brown sugar and added pecans, and on a couple batches added chocolate chips. Great holiday cookies. I didn’t frost them. Maybe next time.5 stars

  • I don’t know what I did wrong, but my batter was more the consistency of a thick pancake or muffin batter. However, the flavor is delicious and we’ll just have to see how they turn out!

    1. Hi April! I’m sorry to hear that! It’s hard to know what went wrong without being in the kitchen with you. Hope you were still able to enjoy them!

  • Best cookie recipe ever!!! And so easy! I made these for Thanksgiving and I’m still making them by request!!! The flavor is unbelievably delicious and they’re perfect with raisins and walnuts!
    You’re the best!👍🏻😋❤5 stars

  • Is something off in the ingredients list? I was careful to get the portions correct but the dough is soupy — not dry at all. Haven’t decided yet how to fix this.

    1. I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Pamela. The amounts are correct and have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.

    2. I am making this recipe right now, and my batter is also very soupy. I did substitute Bob’s Red Mill gluten-free flour (and added xanthan gum) instead of using the white whole wheat flour. I just added an extra half a cup of quick oats hoping that will do the trick and it seems to look promising…

      1. Hi Karen, it does sound like (from your feedback) the gluten-free flour is not acting like a good 1:1 substitute for this particular recipe. Let us know how it goes!

  • These are delicious. I used all the substitutes to make them dairy free and they came out perfectly delicious!

    Question- has anyone used this recipe for gluten free cookies. Wondering what the conversion is?5 stars

  • These were quite delicious, at first the dough was more like batter and so I looked at comments and decided to add a bit more oats about 1/4 of a cup (quick oats because I ran out of rolled) and a tablespoon more flour. Then I fridged the dough for about 7 min. They turned out really good!
    My younger brother said these were probably the best pumpkin cookies he’s ever had, and that something coming from him, as he’s a bit of a cookie conisour. So I will be making them again.

    I had a theory on why they were a bit batter-like, do you think that if the coconut oil wasn’t completely cooled off when you add the sugar that it’d melt some of the sugar and thus be more liquidy??4 stars

    1. So glad you enjoyed them, Vanessa. It’s really hard for me to know for sure why your batter came out that way, since mine came out very thick. Doubling checking that only an egg yolk was used and no other ingredients were substituted?

      1. Yes, I doubled the recipie so I only used egg yolks and no whites, and the only substitution was honey with a dash of maple flavoring for half of the maple syrup.

        Needless to say everyone really liked them and wants me to make them again 😁

  • I’m excited to make these. My question is. Can I use AP flour?? Since I don’t have whole wheat flour. TIA.

    1. Hi LuAnn! Yes, anytime the recipe says white whole wheat flour, it can be substituted with all-purpose flour! Hope this helps and enjoy!

  • Made these with my daughter, and she had fun scooping the dough onto the trays. They baked up a little more cake-like than a regular cookie, but we didn’t mind at all. Warm out of the oven, they were really good with a glass of milk.5 stars

  • Wow, these came out softer than I expected, but I actually liked that. The pumpkin flavor is gentle, not too strong, and the spice level is just right. I froze a few, and they held up pretty well when thawed.5 stars

  • I could not taste any pumpkin.I had to add another 1/4c oatmeal to thicken them up. No way could I have rolled them in a ball.I will not be making them again.I was so looking forward to them.2 stars

    1. Hi Aria! I’m so sorry to hear that you had problems with the recipe. For the pumpkin it is going to depend on which brand is use and the color of the pumpkin puree. The deeper the color, the better the outcome, as pumpkin itself doesn’t have much flavor. Just checking that the whole egg wasn’t used in this recipe? When looking at the step by step recipes could you tell me at which point it looked different? Just trying to help you troubleshoot this!

  • These cookies came out really nice and soft. I added a few chocolate chips to half the batch, and those disappeared first. The pumpkin spice flavor is there but not overpowering, which is perfect for me.5 stars