Is there something that can be substituted for the tomatoes? Maybe chickpeas? My kids and hubby are not a fan of tomatoes when we tried this recipe as written, but the cumin roasted carrot flavor was divine!!
Hi Emily! While I haven’t tried it myself, other readers have reported success with using fewer tomatoes or none at all. You could also try extra roasted veggies, and then thin the soup with some broth. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
Try your family’s favorite tomato sauce or broth instead. Adjust salt to reflect changes. Our family does not care for canned tomatoes either, unless the acid component is cooked out.
Loved this! I chose your recipe because every other recipe I saw involved boiling the veggies in water or broth even if they were roasted first. I was drawn to the simplicity but will make this again and again for the incredible flavor. I made it my main course by adding some lentils as my garnish for a bit more protein. Thank you for the great recipe. I can’t wait to try more!
Absolutely delicious! So rich and creamy! Made it for lunch and paired it with a grilled cheese on a cold afternoon. This kids gobbled it right up. Perfect way to use my garden carrots! Will be making this in the future! Thanks for sharing such lovely recipe :)
Boy was this a ride! OK so, I had some tomatoes to use up and decided to roast them with the other veggies instead of using canned ones. I also took another commenter’s advice about replacing the cream with full-fat coconut milk.
It turns out that the bulk of the moisture in this soup must come from the canned tomatoes, because it came out much too thick for my immersion blender to handle. I about tripled the amount of coconut milk. Then it started getting too coconutty, so I added some chicken broth my boyfriend had recently made.
That solved the consistency problem, but now with all that extra coconut milk, now it almost tasted like Thai food. So I decided to lean into it and added some curry and ginger.
Tl;dr – y’all have GOT to try this variation! Blew my mind. I’m newer to cooking and I have never been this proud of anything in my life.
I wasn’t sure about all those tomatoes, but this exceeded my expectations and wap a welcome change from the standard ginger carrot soup. Also, THANK YOU for such great alternative text on your photos!!! I’m blind so having it means I actually know what the pictures are of! Thanks! And thanks for this great recipe!
I normally leave reviews, but when I was scrolling through the comments to see what possible changes I should make to the recipe I saw the negative comments. If your going to try a new recipe, your taste buds might be different. You could always adjust the recipe or move on.
I tweaked this based on what I had at home and it was absolutely amazing. Next time I will add a little more cream to thin it out.
I used 2 cans of diced tomatoes and replaced the yogurt with a cup of heavy cream. Will be putting this in my soup rotation.
I read the other reviews and at first made it without the tomato. I added 1/2 of an undrained 15oz. Can of diced tomatoes to add a bit of brightness to the luscious roasted veg. Worked perfectly and was amazing. My other changes were to use a 3lb bag of baby carrots as is, so no chopping, and thereby doubled the recipe. I added 4 C So Delicious unsweetened coconut milk and 2C veg broth. I also adore roasted garlic and roasted the entire bulb on its own wrapped in foil, let it cool and it’s easy to squeeze out the roasted garlic. Keep in mind allthe other ingredients were doubled. Delicious.
I made this today with the following changes – 1 can tomatoes, 1/2 can coconut milk, about 1 cup chicken stock and basil paste and ginger to taste. Delicious! I would not slice the onions so thin next time – I had to take them off the pan before the carrots were done.
Yummy warm notes from the roasted veg and cumin. A little thicker than I like in a soup but easily fixed with some water or broth. Will definitely make again.
I’m addicted to this soup. Making it to give away in my Xmas packages along with your pickled onions. I cannot make these onions fast enough as they disappear within days.
Thank you.
This soup is incredible! A+ from our household. My husband said, “You’re telling me this is healthy?! No way, it tastes too good!” We only had one can of diced tomatoes and another can of crushed tomatoes but it still turned out perfectly.
I thought roasting the carrots was a great idea and the kitchen smelled wonderful. For me, the addition of the tomato overwhelmed the flavour of carrot and I would not use tomato again.
The consistency wasn’t great for me and it was too thick for my immersion blender. I added nearly 2 cups of vegetable broth which was helpful, but in the future I would put this into a slower cooker post roasting for better texture. The flavor was excellent tho.
I’m sorry to hear that it wasn’t to your taste, Barbara. The recipe has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
It should be called tomato soup with only 2.5 pounds of roasted carrots and almost 4 pounds of tomatoes. Way too thick! It might make good pasta sauce, but that’s about it.
Before making, I’m wondering what type of Greek plain yogurt you use(0%, 2% or whole milk yogurt)? Which you use would also influence the Nutrition Facts(fat and kcal levels would be higher or lower). I like that you use Greek yogurt instead of cream since it is lower in fat and much higher in protein than the typical cream you usually see in carrot soup recipes.
Thanks!
This recipe nearly defeated me; I am covered from head to toe in carrot.
Soup came out good, but my small tiny magic bullet could not handle chopping the carrots. I roasted them for twice as long (and used half-frozen carrots). In addition to the onion, I also roasted a can of chickpeas and half a cauliflower (more vegetarian-friendly). I blended the carrots and tomatoes separately from the onion, chickpea, and cauliflower, but I had to add significant amounts of water to each blend, to create a smooth consistency.
All to say it came out delicious, but I would not recommend using a small blender (as it exploded on me). Loved the addition of greek yogurt!
Is there something that can be substituted for the tomatoes? Maybe chickpeas? My kids and hubby are not a fan of tomatoes when we tried this recipe as written, but the cumin roasted carrot flavor was divine!!
Hi Emily! While I haven’t tried it myself, other readers have reported success with using fewer tomatoes or none at all. You could also try extra roasted veggies, and then thin the soup with some broth. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
Try your family’s favorite tomato sauce or broth instead. Adjust salt to reflect changes. Our family does not care for canned tomatoes either, unless the acid component is cooked out.
Thanks for the tip Cindy!
Loved this! I chose your recipe because every other recipe I saw involved boiling the veggies in water or broth even if they were roasted first. I was drawn to the simplicity but will make this again and again for the incredible flavor. I made it my main course by adding some lentils as my garnish for a bit more protein. Thank you for the great recipe. I can’t wait to try more!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Toni! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Absolutely delicious! So rich and creamy! Made it for lunch and paired it with a grilled cheese on a cold afternoon. This kids gobbled it right up. Perfect way to use my garden carrots! Will be making this in the future! Thanks for sharing such lovely recipe :)
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Rebecca! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Boy was this a ride! OK so, I had some tomatoes to use up and decided to roast them with the other veggies instead of using canned ones. I also took another commenter’s advice about replacing the cream with full-fat coconut milk.
It turns out that the bulk of the moisture in this soup must come from the canned tomatoes, because it came out much too thick for my immersion blender to handle. I about tripled the amount of coconut milk. Then it started getting too coconutty, so I added some chicken broth my boyfriend had recently made.
That solved the consistency problem, but now with all that extra coconut milk, now it almost tasted like Thai food. So I decided to lean into it and added some curry and ginger.
Tl;dr – y’all have GOT to try this variation! Blew my mind. I’m newer to cooking and I have never been this proud of anything in my life.
Amanda, I am so glad it was a hit. Sounds delicious!
Very good! Big hit at our house!
YAY, so glad! Thanks for sharing!
I wasn’t sure about all those tomatoes, but this exceeded my expectations and wap a welcome change from the standard ginger carrot soup. Also, THANK YOU for such great alternative text on your photos!!! I’m blind so having it means I actually know what the pictures are of! Thanks! And thanks for this great recipe!
I’m SO happy that you enjoyed it, Sarah! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
The roasted flavor in this soup is the key ingredient like you say in your video. The weather temps dropped where I live and it warmed us right up.
So glad to hear that you enjoyed it! Thank you for this kind review!
I normally leave reviews, but when I was scrolling through the comments to see what possible changes I should make to the recipe I saw the negative comments. If your going to try a new recipe, your taste buds might be different. You could always adjust the recipe or move on.
I tweaked this based on what I had at home and it was absolutely amazing. Next time I will add a little more cream to thin it out.
I used 2 cans of diced tomatoes and replaced the yogurt with a cup of heavy cream. Will be putting this in my soup rotation.
Hi Briana! Thank you so much for taking the time to comment, I really appreciate it!! So glad you enjoyed the soup!
I read the other reviews and at first made it without the tomato. I added 1/2 of an undrained 15oz. Can of diced tomatoes to add a bit of brightness to the luscious roasted veg. Worked perfectly and was amazing. My other changes were to use a 3lb bag of baby carrots as is, so no chopping, and thereby doubled the recipe. I added 4 C So Delicious unsweetened coconut milk and 2C veg broth. I also adore roasted garlic and roasted the entire bulb on its own wrapped in foil, let it cool and it’s easy to squeeze out the roasted garlic. Keep in mind allthe other ingredients were doubled. Delicious.
Hi MH! So glad you enjoyed the soup! Thank you for this kind review!
I made this today with the following changes – 1 can tomatoes, 1/2 can coconut milk, about 1 cup chicken stock and basil paste and ginger to taste. Delicious! I would not slice the onions so thin next time – I had to take them off the pan before the carrots were done.
Hi Carin! Thank you for this kind review and feedback!
Yummy warm notes from the roasted veg and cumin. A little thicker than I like in a soup but easily fixed with some water or broth. Will definitely make again.
Hi Colleen! So glad you enjoyed the soup! Thank you for this kind review!
I’m addicted to this soup. Making it to give away in my Xmas packages along with your pickled onions. I cannot make these onions fast enough as they disappear within days.
Thank you.
Hi Erica! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This soup is incredible! A+ from our household. My husband said, “You’re telling me this is healthy?! No way, it tastes too good!” We only had one can of diced tomatoes and another can of crushed tomatoes but it still turned out perfectly.
Hi Jessica! So glad you enjoyed the soup! Thank you for this kind review!
I thought roasting the carrots was a great idea and the kitchen smelled wonderful. For me, the addition of the tomato overwhelmed the flavour of carrot and I would not use tomato again.
Hi Marjorie! Thanks for your feedback!
The consistency wasn’t great for me and it was too thick for my immersion blender. I added nearly 2 cups of vegetable broth which was helpful, but in the future I would put this into a slower cooker post roasting for better texture. The flavor was excellent tho.
Sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe Catherine! So glad you enjoyed the flavor!
Sorry, made it religiously to the recipe. Not for us. Only way we made it any way near enjoyable
Was to sprinkle it with it with Parmesan.
I’m sorry to hear that it wasn’t to your taste, Barbara. The recipe has worked well for myself (and others) but I know how frustrating it can be to try a new recipe and not have it work out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
It should be called tomato soup with only 2.5 pounds of roasted carrots and almost 4 pounds of tomatoes. Way too thick! It might make good pasta sauce, but that’s about it.
I’m sorry to hear you had problems with the recipe, Kay! It has worked well for myself (and others) and I wished it would of been a hit for you too.
Hi,
I would like to try this recipe but I don’t like Basil. Could I replace the Basil with dried Oregano?
Thank you in advance for your response.
Hi Leah! I’m sure it would be fine. Enjoy!
Before making, I’m wondering what type of Greek plain yogurt you use(0%, 2% or whole milk yogurt)? Which you use would also influence the Nutrition Facts(fat and kcal levels would be higher or lower). I like that you use Greek yogurt instead of cream since it is lower in fat and much higher in protein than the typical cream you usually see in carrot soup recipes.
Thanks!
Hi Joan, I typically use non-fat plain Greek yogurt. Hope you enjoy it!
This recipe nearly defeated me; I am covered from head to toe in carrot.
Soup came out good, but my small tiny magic bullet could not handle chopping the carrots. I roasted them for twice as long (and used half-frozen carrots). In addition to the onion, I also roasted a can of chickpeas and half a cauliflower (more vegetarian-friendly). I blended the carrots and tomatoes separately from the onion, chickpea, and cauliflower, but I had to add significant amounts of water to each blend, to create a smooth consistency.
All to say it came out delicious, but I would not recommend using a small blender (as it exploded on me). Loved the addition of greek yogurt!
Thanks for the feedback, Maya!