The whole family loved this easy to put together recipe! Even our kids, that are usually picky eating potato skin, eat the whole thing without any complaint but compliments. This one is a keeper! Towing Aurora Colorado
This was delicious and so easy. I used a medley of fingerling potatoes, red, white, purple. It was nice to have that flavor variety. I used 1/2 tsp of thyme per the recipe, made sure to flip every 10 minutes, and added the parmesan after it was done. I will definitely be making again.
Finger licking fingerlings! Sorry for the bad joke but seriously my family is going to be happy with this on the dinner table, especially my 3 year old.
I wanted to change it up for my lunch meals so, I prepped these with sauteed chicken breast. And, even though they are still potatoes, fingerling potatoes just “feel” different lol I followed this very easy recipe exactly (sans the Parm…I’m staying away from the dairy) and they came out perfectly! Even days later, they were still moist!
I made this tonight as I was cooking a steak. They were delicious. Was a good way to use my fingerling potatoes the neighbour gave us. Will definitely make again. The Parmesan cheese and parsley just were the finishing touch.
Made these for the “family gathering” on grandma’s 95th birthday.
Pot luck but everyone was given one dish to make. I got potatoes. At first I thought scalloped but my sister got meat-so we conspired. She tried the air fried pork loin with a raisin sauce. I did the potatoes and with a desset of mile high pie (lime this time).
No potatoes left at all. Everyone was back for seconds. I used parmesian and a mix of oregano/thyme on half and the other half sprinkled with steak spices. (spicey and hot).
Shared the recipe with at least 10 cousins. Great idea. I willl jave to search this site for more recipes.
My garlic burned. I was skeptical up front but followed the directions as written. Burnt garlic is bitter plus it was a waste of my time chopping it up. Next time I will add the garlic later (perhaps last 5 minutes) and maybe lower the oven temp. My fingerling potatoes cooked in just 15 minutes so the garlic burned in less time than that.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Susan. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
If you do have any of these lovely potatoes left and need to freeze them they can be just sauteed with a fried egg on top! quick meal and saves wasting good food.
These are BOMB! I used one good-sized clove of garlic and it was perfect as to not completely erase the taste of those buttery fingerlings. Also if you have any leftovers (I had just a few), reheat in an air fryer and you will be very happy. Thank you Erin!
I made these with a chicken dish I made for my friends. They loved them so much they said this is now a staple. Favorite potatoes! And easy. Good with or without the cheese.
Love all the tips and have good success with your roasted veggies recipe. Do you have any guidance on the best way to roast green beans along side the potatoes?
Hi Jess, here is my recipe for roasted green beans: https://www.wellplated.com/roasted-green-beans/ You’ll see they roast at a higher temperature for a shorter amount of time. So if you do add them to your potatoes, you’ll likely have to cook them longer than the suggested time in my original green bean post. Hope this helps!
These turned out really good and were super easy to make with my little ones around. They helped wash the potatoes and spread them on the tray. The flavor was simple but tasty, and I liked that it wasn’t too greasy. My kids dipped theirs in ketchup and finished everything.
The whole family loved this easy to put together recipe! Even our kids, that are usually picky eating potato skin, eat the whole thing without any complaint but compliments. This one is a keeper! Towing Aurora Colorado
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Alice! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This was delicious and so easy. I used a medley of fingerling potatoes, red, white, purple. It was nice to have that flavor variety. I used 1/2 tsp of thyme per the recipe, made sure to flip every 10 minutes, and added the parmesan after it was done. I will definitely be making again.
Hi Debbie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
These came out well but cooked in just twenty minutes! I think the Parmesan and parsley really bring them together.
So glad to you enjoyed it Jenny! Thank you for this kind review!
Finger licking fingerlings! Sorry for the bad joke but seriously my family is going to be happy with this on the dinner table, especially my 3 year old.
So glad you enjoyed the potatoes, Jenny! Thank you for this kind review!
I wanted to change it up for my lunch meals so, I prepped these with sauteed chicken breast. And, even though they are still potatoes, fingerling potatoes just “feel” different lol I followed this very easy recipe exactly (sans the Parm…I’m staying away from the dairy) and they came out perfectly! Even days later, they were still moist!
Hi T! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
OMG !!!!! I bet you could dip those potatoes in a egg wash and then bake using your dip would be AMAZING…Thanks for sharing.
Thanks Jake! Hope you enjoy them!
I’ve tried many roasted potato recipes, but this one is the absolute best! Perfectly crispy potatoes, every time. 5 stars!
Hi Mila! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Very good. Went over well at our cookout. Followed your recipe except for parsley (didn’t have any).
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Rosemary! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I made this tonight as I was cooking a steak. They were delicious. Was a good way to use my fingerling potatoes the neighbour gave us. Will definitely make again. The Parmesan cheese and parsley just were the finishing touch.
Hi Linda! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Loved this recipe.
Used extra virgin olive oil, minced fresh garlic , fresh thyme,and salt.
Hi Marguerite! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Delicious! Easy to make, quick for a weeknight dinner, and absolutely delicious!
Hi Marsha! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Delicious! This recipe is a keeper! Mine did not turn out dry as another person’s did. My family loved them! Thank you!
Hi MB! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Made these for the “family gathering” on grandma’s 95th birthday.
Pot luck but everyone was given one dish to make. I got potatoes. At first I thought scalloped but my sister got meat-so we conspired. She tried the air fried pork loin with a raisin sauce. I did the potatoes and with a desset of mile high pie (lime this time).
No potatoes left at all. Everyone was back for seconds. I used parmesian and a mix of oregano/thyme on half and the other half sprinkled with steak spices. (spicey and hot).
Shared the recipe with at least 10 cousins. Great idea. I willl jave to search this site for more recipes.
Hi Carol! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Perfect and oh so tasty!
Hi Lucia! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
My garlic burned. I was skeptical up front but followed the directions as written. Burnt garlic is bitter plus it was a waste of my time chopping it up. Next time I will add the garlic later (perhaps last 5 minutes) and maybe lower the oven temp. My fingerling potatoes cooked in just 15 minutes so the garlic burned in less time than that.
I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with the recipe, Susan. The amounts, flavorings and timing have worked well for myself (and others) so I wished it would have been a hit for you too! I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you.
If you do have any of these lovely potatoes left and need to freeze them they can be just sauteed with a fried egg on top! quick meal and saves wasting good food.
Thanks for the tip Gwen!
These are amazing. I cooked them longer because my family liked them really crisp. Will definitely make them again.
Yay! Thank you Elise!
These are BOMB! I used one good-sized clove of garlic and it was perfect as to not completely erase the taste of those buttery fingerlings. Also if you have any leftovers (I had just a few), reheat in an air fryer and you will be very happy. Thank you Erin!
Yay! Thank you Terry!
I made these with a chicken dish I made for my friends. They loved them so much they said this is now a staple. Favorite potatoes! And easy. Good with or without the cheese.
So glad to hear you enjoyed it, Carla! Thank you!
Love all the tips and have good success with your roasted veggies recipe. Do you have any guidance on the best way to roast green beans along side the potatoes?
Hi Jess, here is my recipe for roasted green beans: https://www.wellplated.com/roasted-green-beans/ You’ll see they roast at a higher temperature for a shorter amount of time. So if you do add them to your potatoes, you’ll likely have to cook them longer than the suggested time in my original green bean post. Hope this helps!
These turned out really good and were super easy to make with my little ones around. They helped wash the potatoes and spread them on the tray. The flavor was simple but tasty, and I liked that it wasn’t too greasy. My kids dipped theirs in ketchup and finished everything.
So glad you enjoyed them, Callie! Thank you!