• Completely obsessed with this recipe. Made it exactly as the recipe called for. Don’t underseason!
    This is my new go-to comfort food recipe. My husband hates it when meals repeat too soon but he has asked me twice in the last 10 days to make it again.5 stars

    3
  • Absolutely love this recipe! I made it ahead of time and froze for future visitors during the holidays. Followed the recipe and freezing instructions. Everyone enjoyed it, even the picky eaters. Will definitely make again!5 stars

    1. Great recipe, easy to follow! I made it exactly as written and it turned out really well. Everyone was impressed with the result!5 stars

  • To start with, I’m not really a fan of squash but our new garden has been prolific and my wife wanted to do an acorn squash recipe. I happend to use Johnsonville mild ground sausage (not brats) and didn’t have Allspice so I substituted a Chinese Five Spice that is likely similar. Wow, it was GREAT!!!!! One modification for next time is we’ll do 3/4 lb of sausage (instead of a lb) and add some diced bell peppers. We love how the recipe is as is though!5 stars

  • We planted squash this year but I picked it too soon so changed course and use the filling for stuffed peppers. Even though we didn’t have stuffed squash, my husband said, these were the best stuffed peppers I’ve ever made. The filling, even without the squash, was AMAZING!
    Thanks for the recipe. We will try the squash once they are ripe but will also keep the filling recipe to use again with stuffed peppers.5 stars

  • I bought too many acorn squashes and carnival squashes so I’m so glad I found this recipe to use them with! Such great flavors, the fresh sage especially really ties it together. A lot of chopping, so if you can get a cheap veggie chopper it saves SO much prep time. The carnival squash could have benefited from another 10 minutes of roasting time, but it still was soft enough. The acorn squash turned out very tender. Elegant, comforting, beautiful, everyone including our toddler loved it.5 stars

    Halved squash filled with a seasoned meat mixture, topped with grated cheese, on a baking sheet.

  • This recipe is a keeper. I had to make a bunch of substitutions with what I had on hand — used Koginut squash and used cranberries, pecans and mixed grains to sub for mushrooms and to make up for not quite enough sausage. Loved the tip for dealing with the stem — how have I never heard this before?? All worked out great, next time — and there will be a next time! — will do it as written.5 stars

    1. Hi Renate! Yes, I believe it could but I haven’t tried it myself. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it goes.

  • It mentions adding the fresh herbs twice after using only ground nutmeg and allspice to season the sausage. What fresh herbs? The sage that never gets added in the steps? Lol

    1. Hi Shaun, Step 4 states to “add the herbs and ¼ cup Parmesan.” This is the part where it is added to the recipe. It’s listed in the ingredients as 1 tablespoon chopped fresh sage thyme, or a mix. Step 5 states to “Sprinkle with additional fresh herbs as desired.” that is also listed in the ingredients as 1 tablespoon chopped fresh sage thyme, or a mix (plus additional for serving). (Same ingredient as Step 4 just using the additional for serving) Hope this helps!

  • This is a FABULOUS recipe. Even with my picky family!!! I only did 1 thing different… The filling was sooooo good and sweet, I omitted the allspice, nutmeg and ginger. Ty,ty,ty for helping my family final agree on a great meal!!5 stars

  • Erin,

    This is a fantastic dish!
    My edits:
    1. Half ground pork Italian sausage and half ground turkey.
    2. I didn’t remove the pumpkin. I just put it on top.
    3. I added goat cheese crumbles to the filling.
    4. I toasted the pumpkin seeds and topped the stuffed squash with them. It added an extra taste and texture.
    I also halved the recipe to cook for 2 people. It was SOOOO GOOD!!!
    Thanks for sharing!5 stars

    Stuffed butternut squash half topped with melted cheese and parsley on a white plate, garnished with seeds and herbs.

    1
  • Yum! My husband doesn’t like acorn squash and loves this. Looking forward to trying the spicy sausage and maybe adding some roasted nuts. Thanks5 stars

  • Sweet can’t purchase Either Spicy Itali Sausage here where I live Nor can we buy those mushrooms. Sincerely Wish you would list I Alternate suggestions.

    1. It’s your lucky day, Ingrid! Our recipes are so adaptable that you can use any kind of sausage you’d like along with any mushroom you find. Hope you enjoy it!

  • We made this and it was insane. Had to microwave squash in a hurry, but the ingredients and spice are 10/10. Keeping this forever.

  • This is SO good! The leftovers are also great!! I had it for supper last night and just had it again for brunch, loved it so much!5 stars

  • I have been making this recipe for years, just made it again today! I freeze half for later. It freezes beautifully. We enjoy it so much. Filling and delicious. Thank you!5 stars