Absolutely loved this recipe! I normally don’t like store bought apple butter. But my husband loves apple butter. So I decided to make this for him. I tried it and loved it too. Planning on giving my sister a container of it because she loves apple butter too. I know she’ll love it. Thank you for a great recipe.
Mmmm Mmmmm good. Thank you for this healthy version of apple butter! I am making this right now and cannot wait to have it tomorrow on my toast with some peanut butter. I am finding all you recipes hit all the right notes for me and my family
I used large crabapples before. Wonderful tartness and taste. I add a little honey if too tart. Or I use half crabapples and half delicious apples….yellow or red.
I have this in the slow cooker right now !!! Smells amazing!! In the last hour of cooking and I sampled a bite OH MY YUMMY!! Can not wait til I can eat it for breakfast tomorrow!!
I’m in the middle of making my second batch! This time, I’m using some apples we picked that are smaller and more tart, along with some local sweet apples. As I taste it after blending, it’s just as sweet and yummy.
My regular slow cooker is big. I cook roasts in it usually, and it’s kind of oblong, so difficult for my immersion blender since this recipe only fills it about halfway. But my Instant Pot is only 3 quarts, so too small. Plus, I’d like more. Can this recipe be doubled safely? Please let me know!
The hardest part is peeling. I don’t find that regular peelers work very well, and neither does my apple corer. So, I just slice them around the core and peel with a knife. It’s just time consuming. But the result is fantastic. And, I can eat all the ingredients, which, on my restrictive diet, is amazing. Thank you!
I’m SO happy that you’ve enjoyed the recipe, Sondra! I haven’t tried doubling this myself, but I think it would work fine. If you decide to try it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
I had made a different apple butter recipe previously, and I can say this version is hands down superior. It was so simple and made our house smell fantastic. I elected to use honey crisp apples for that perfect sweetness. I can’t wait to share it with my family. For me, it easily made 2 jars.
I’ve been craving apple butter for a few months now. I’m always hesitant to buy it because I’ve never found one that tastes like it did when I was growing up. I happened upon this recipe and decided to make it. I’m so happy I did! The flavor reminds me of my childhood. After it cooled some, I grabbed a slice of bread and generously spread it with peanut butter then topped it with this wonderful apple butter. WHAT A TREAT ?
I varied two things. I added pancake syrup in place of the pure maple syrup. And I added the vanilla and salt immediately after I puréed it. I followed everything else exactly as written. Thank you for sharing this recipe. It will become a permanent go to recipe.
Hi Kristin! I’m sorry but I haven’t tried making this in a smaller batch so I’m not sure how it might work out. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Hubby likes this so much I had to make some more! Didn’t have fresh apples so I used home canned applesauce. It was a nice short cut. A pint of my applesauce weighs about a lb so 3 jars made one recipe. Next year I will have to make much more!! Thank you for a lovely recipe!
Hi Erin, I’m in the process of making your apple butter recipe.
Is it necessary to boil the jars after filling them with the apple butter?
Thank you, Theresa
Hi Theresa, I didn’t really create this as an apple butter canning recipe, although I think it would work well for it. For safety, be sure to follow proper canning procedures, or seek out a recipe designed for canning.
This recipe is a must try! It was my first time making apple butter and it was so easy and turned out amazing. I was looking for a healthier recipe and was so happy when I came across this one! So far we’ve had the apple butter on apple bread, in yogurt, and on top of ice cream. It’s delicious on everything. I will definitely be making this again!
Absolutely loved this recipe! I normally don’t like store bought apple butter. But my husband loves apple butter. So I decided to make this for him. I tried it and loved it too. Planning on giving my sister a container of it because she loves apple butter too. I know she’ll love it. Thank you for a great recipe.
I’m so happy to hear that this recipe was a hit, Crystal! Thank you for taking the time to share this kind review!
Mmmm Mmmmm good. Thank you for this healthy version of apple butter! I am making this right now and cannot wait to have it tomorrow on my toast with some peanut butter. I am finding all you recipes hit all the right notes for me and my family
Thank you for taking the time to share this kind comment, Barb! I hope you enjoyed the recipe!
This is the most delicious apple butter ever!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Rasbhari! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Hi Erin! Love your recipes!
Do you think this apple butter recipe would work using crabapples?
Rosanna, crabapples are super tart, so I’m afraid I can’t recommend them here.
I used large crabapples before. Wonderful tartness and taste. I add a little honey if too tart. Or I use half crabapples and half delicious apples….yellow or red.
Thanks for the feedback Di!
I have this in the slow cooker right now !!! Smells amazing!! In the last hour of cooking and I sampled a bite OH MY YUMMY!! Can not wait til I can eat it for breakfast tomorrow!!
I’m so happy to hear that, Meg! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I’m in the middle of making my second batch! This time, I’m using some apples we picked that are smaller and more tart, along with some local sweet apples. As I taste it after blending, it’s just as sweet and yummy.
My regular slow cooker is big. I cook roasts in it usually, and it’s kind of oblong, so difficult for my immersion blender since this recipe only fills it about halfway. But my Instant Pot is only 3 quarts, so too small. Plus, I’d like more. Can this recipe be doubled safely? Please let me know!
The hardest part is peeling. I don’t find that regular peelers work very well, and neither does my apple corer. So, I just slice them around the core and peel with a knife. It’s just time consuming. But the result is fantastic. And, I can eat all the ingredients, which, on my restrictive diet, is amazing. Thank you!
I’m SO happy that you’ve enjoyed the recipe, Sondra! I haven’t tried doubling this myself, but I think it would work fine. If you decide to try it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
I had made a different apple butter recipe previously, and I can say this version is hands down superior. It was so simple and made our house smell fantastic. I elected to use honey crisp apples for that perfect sweetness. I can’t wait to share it with my family. For me, it easily made 2 jars.
I am so so happy to hear that Brooke, thank you for sharing!
I’m so excited to try this tomorrow! Do you think you can can this in mason jars and it would keep? Thanks for sharing this!!
Hi Meagan! I haven’t tried canning it myself, but other readers have done so with success. If you decide to try it, I’d love to hear how it goes!
Can you tell me which Apple measurement is more important the pounds or average number of apples? I am very excited to make this for the holidays.
Definitely pounds Morgan. I hope you enjoy it!
I’ve been craving apple butter for a few months now. I’m always hesitant to buy it because I’ve never found one that tastes like it did when I was growing up. I happened upon this recipe and decided to make it. I’m so happy I did! The flavor reminds me of my childhood. After it cooled some, I grabbed a slice of bread and generously spread it with peanut butter then topped it with this wonderful apple butter. WHAT A TREAT ?
I varied two things. I added pancake syrup in place of the pure maple syrup. And I added the vanilla and salt immediately after I puréed it. I followed everything else exactly as written. Thank you for sharing this recipe. It will become a permanent go to recipe.
I’m SO happy that you enjoyed it! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Hi! Would it make a big difference to the end product if the apples weren’t peeled?
Hi Hazel! You can definitely make this recipe with unpeeled apples. I hope you enjoy it!
Hi Erin, have you ever tried making this in a smaller amount? I’m worried it might burn in the crockpot if i tried to cut the recipe in half?
Hi Kristin! I’m sorry but I haven’t tried making this in a smaller batch so I’m not sure how it might work out. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
I’d like to make this to give away as Christmas gifts! How many 8oz mason jars do you think this recipe would fill up?
Hi Jordan! This makes a total of 2 heaping cups, so you are going to be able to fill at least 2. Hope this helps!
Can this recipie be water bath. Canned?
Hi Helen! I’ve never tested this out canning the recipe. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Hubby likes this so much I had to make some more! Didn’t have fresh apples so I used home canned applesauce. It was a nice short cut. A pint of my applesauce weighs about a lb so 3 jars made one recipe. Next year I will have to make much more!! Thank you for a lovely recipe!
Hi Kathleen! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Very good, very easy. I found that a bit more salt, than recommended, was needed to amp up the flavour.
Hi Angela! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Hi Erin, I’m in the process of making your apple butter recipe.
Is it necessary to boil the jars after filling them with the apple butter?
Thank you, Theresa
Hi Theresa, I didn’t really create this as an apple butter canning recipe, although I think it would work well for it. For safety, be sure to follow proper canning procedures, or seek out a recipe designed for canning.
This recipe is a must try! It was my first time making apple butter and it was so easy and turned out amazing. I was looking for a healthier recipe and was so happy when I came across this one! So far we’ve had the apple butter on apple bread, in yogurt, and on top of ice cream. It’s delicious on everything. I will definitely be making this again!
Hi Brenda! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Hi! I was wondering, is it required to puree the apple butter? I don’t have a blender, and am considering mashing it with a potato masher instead.
HI Maple! It makes it more like butter when you puree it. If you don’t have one as masher will do but it will likely be chunky. Hope you enjoy it!
I’m wanting to make this recipe to can. Can someone tell me how to can some in my canner instead of freezing it? Please and thank you.
Hi Natasha! I haven’t tried this myself but maybe someone else will chime in with some advice. Enjoy!