I’ve made this recipe several times, including tonight. My family loves it but I’m not a fan. It’s watery and doesn’t have the color or consistency as the pictures. To me, it’s watered down stew over noodles. I’ll probably try it again, but every time it turns out like this, I’m more deflated.
I’m sorry to hear you are having trouble with the recipe Karla. The variety of mushroom being used can cause the dish to be watery. Also the slow cooker itself could cause the recipe to come out slightly different. Have you watched the video? At which point is it looking different than the one you see there? Hope this helps!
Tip for ff Greek yogurt- it won’t curdle if you temp it (put the ff Greek yogurt in a bowl, and add a few tbsp at a time and mix until it becomes warm, and then mix in).
This is a wonderful recipe. It is very simple and great tasting. I added some mushrooms that were in the fridge. Will surely make this recipe again soon.
Old guy who is new to cooking, and even newer to crocklife. Adventure # 6 or 7 in the crock pot recipe life was my attempt at this great feast. Followed most of the directions, but the male in me veered a bit off course. I used 2 pounds of stew beef, 12 oz. of egg noodles, and added a bunch of fresh spinach I had hanging in the fridge. Was trying to avoid any watery type of concoction, and it seemed to work. Came out amazing. I wanna go be a chef at a now. Thanks so much for your guidance in advancing my culinary efforts. 5 stars.
Absolutely delicious! I have never, ever been able to get my 3.5 year old daughter to try or eat beef. This is the first meal she’s willingly tried and loved! So thankful to have a new recipe to add to our meal list!
Had some leftover stew meat to use up and opted for this – did not disappoint! Made a few minor adjustments but found it very flavorful and the whole family enjoyed it.
I love your recipes Erin. I am not a great cook at all and have very little time to invest in cooking. I have been trying your crockpot recipes. I am wanting to know can I use New York Strip steaks int his recipe? Also I want the sauce to be thick. Do I need to add anything to make the sauce thick or just follow this recipe? Thank you for your great recipes.
I love beef stroganoff, but I normally start with cutting up chuck steak or similar. Throw it in a plastic bag with plain flour, s & P, and paprika, thyme and parsley. Shake it around until beef (bite size) is covered. Then brown on the frying pan. Then place browned steak in the Slow Cooker. Later brown onion, garlic and mushrooms in the frying pan. Throw that in for the last 40 mins. When cooked stir in sour cream, tomato paste. Voila- divine!
This is SO good, I’ve made it a few times! I always add a bunch of spinach to the crock pot for the last 10 min. The second time I made it, in the cornstarch step, I reduced it to 1/4 cup broth instead of 1/2 cup, and I replaced the yogurt with cashew cream (just blended 1 cup cashews & some water). The end result was a lot creamier/less watery than the first time I made it.
Only good thing was the steak. They yogurt does not go good inside of it. Gave it a weird sour taste. I tried it and wouldn’t make again. My kids and family didnt like either. Sorry!! I would do without the yogurt tho!
I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Joshua. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!
This recipe was so easy. It came together quickly in the slow cooker. I added the mushrooms halfway through and used sour cream instead of yogurt. This was so good and was great for the lunch the next day. This a definitely in my rotation now!! Thanks for a great recipe, Erin!!
I’ve made this recipe several times, including tonight. My family loves it but I’m not a fan. It’s watery and doesn’t have the color or consistency as the pictures. To me, it’s watered down stew over noodles. I’ll probably try it again, but every time it turns out like this, I’m more deflated.
I’m sorry to hear you are having trouble with the recipe Karla. The variety of mushroom being used can cause the dish to be watery. Also the slow cooker itself could cause the recipe to come out slightly different. Have you watched the video? At which point is it looking different than the one you see there? Hope this helps!
I liked this very much, but I would add worstershire to taste at the end. 3 tbl was too much.
Hi Sharon! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Tip for ff Greek yogurt- it won’t curdle if you temp it (put the ff Greek yogurt in a bowl, and add a few tbsp at a time and mix until it becomes warm, and then mix in).
Great tip! Thank you for sharing it Sara!
This is a wonderful recipe. It is very simple and great tasting. I added some mushrooms that were in the fridge. Will surely make this recipe again soon.
Turned out amazing! The flavor is awesome and super easy. I add lots of pepper and more garlic powder and serve with rice.
Hooray! So glad to hear it, thank you for letting me know Jillian!
Old guy who is new to cooking, and even newer to crocklife. Adventure # 6 or 7 in the crock pot recipe life was my attempt at this great feast. Followed most of the directions, but the male in me veered a bit off course. I used 2 pounds of stew beef, 12 oz. of egg noodles, and added a bunch of fresh spinach I had hanging in the fridge. Was trying to avoid any watery type of concoction, and it seemed to work. Came out amazing. I wanna go be a chef at a now. Thanks so much for your guidance in advancing my culinary efforts. 5 stars.
So happy to hear that it turned out well for you Raymond! Thank you!
This is so delicious! I used beef cheeks and the amount of fat through the meat makes it so tender.
So glad you enjoyed it Maggie! Thank you!
This was the best stroganoff I’ve ever had. I made it for only 2 people. I did add a small amount of Paprika in the recipe and it was perfect!
Yay! So happy to hear Olivia! Thank you!
Absolutely delicious! I have never, ever been able to get my 3.5 year old daughter to try or eat beef. This is the first meal she’s willingly tried and loved! So thankful to have a new recipe to add to our meal list!
So happy to hear that Michelle! Thank you!
I’m looking at this recipe and wondering if anybody has tried tri tip instead of sirloin.
Bruce, not that I know of, but I’d love to hear how it goes! Tri tip is a fattier cut, so I think it would hold up well to slow cooking.
I have it cooking as I write this with tri tip. It is my go to meat for any stew recipe, so I assumed it would work well here also.
Let us know how it goes, Jackie!
Had some leftover stew meat to use up and opted for this – did not disappoint! Made a few minor adjustments but found it very flavorful and the whole family enjoyed it.
Glad you enjoyed it, Chelsea!
I love your recipes Erin. I am not a great cook at all and have very little time to invest in cooking. I have been trying your crockpot recipes. I am wanting to know can I use New York Strip steaks int his recipe? Also I want the sauce to be thick. Do I need to add anything to make the sauce thick or just follow this recipe? Thank you for your great recipes.
Hi Glenda, I think it could work but I haven’t tested it with the strip steaks before. Also the cornstarch helps thicken the sauce. Enjoy!
I love beef stroganoff, but I normally start with cutting up chuck steak or similar. Throw it in a plastic bag with plain flour, s & P, and paprika, thyme and parsley. Shake it around until beef (bite size) is covered. Then brown on the frying pan. Then place browned steak in the Slow Cooker. Later brown onion, garlic and mushrooms in the frying pan. Throw that in for the last 40 mins. When cooked stir in sour cream, tomato paste. Voila- divine!
Thanks Caroline! We love this method the best!
Can you use cream cheese instead of greek yogurt?
Hi LL! It might work, I just haven’t tried it myself. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
This is SO good, I’ve made it a few times! I always add a bunch of spinach to the crock pot for the last 10 min. The second time I made it, in the cornstarch step, I reduced it to 1/4 cup broth instead of 1/2 cup, and I replaced the yogurt with cashew cream (just blended 1 cup cashews & some water). The end result was a lot creamier/less watery than the first time I made it.
So glad it worked out well for you, Madeleine!
Only good thing was the steak. They yogurt does not go good inside of it. Gave it a weird sour taste. I tried it and wouldn’t make again. My kids and family didnt like either. Sorry!! I would do without the yogurt tho!
I’m sorry to hear the recipe wasn’t to your taste, Joshua. I know it’s disappointing to try a new recipe and not enjoy it. I (and many other readers) have enjoyed it, so I really wish they would’ve been a hit for you too!
This recipe was so easy. It came together quickly in the slow cooker. I added the mushrooms halfway through and used sour cream instead of yogurt. This was so good and was great for the lunch the next day. This a definitely in my rotation now!! Thanks for a great recipe, Erin!!
So glad to hear you enjoyed it, Sally! Thank you!
This worked exactly as written, thanks!
Yay! Thank you Manda!
Hi. Can I use chuck roast instead of sirloin? Also, if I sub sour cream for yogurt is it an even swap? Thanks!
Hi Amy, the chuck roast should work. Also the swap would be 1:1. Enjoy!
YAYYY Thank you so much for your response!
Let us know how it goes! Thanks!
Can this meal be frozen please? Thanks
Hi Jenny, I think it would freeze just fine! Make sure to cool it completely, then thaw overnight in the fridge. I am so glad you enjoyed it!