It’s funny attitudes change over the years. I grew up on stuffing, which was stuffed into the bird – and nobody ever got sick or died from it. That said, I’m not sure I’ll ever have the need to cook a whole turkey, so I would need to make my stuffing/dressing separately. This recipe sounds like a real keeper, so I’m saving it. (Thanksgiving falls during my husband’s week to cook this year, so I’m not going to worry about any of it) ?
I think that should work, Gretchen! I’d try 350*F, and I’d start checking for doneness between 30 and 40 minutes. It may take longer to set—I haven’t tried this recipe in the oven, but that’s where I would start.
Hi Erin.. thank you for all the great recipes you share with us. I am a stuffing lover, and this sounds delicious. However, the finished product looks dry. I like stuffing that holds together… This looks like it’s loose. Maybe just the pictures?
Hi Cat! This is very moist and holds together nicely, with crispy edges as described. It might just be the pictures, because it’s not crumbly at all. I hope you enjoy the recipe if you try it!
This recipe really sounds good. The family really likes a little sausage in their dressing. Could you put cooked sausage in this recipe? I have made many of your delicious recipes. Thanks
This came out excellent! I totally should have checked how much it made, but if I was a snacker the amount of leftovers wouldn’t have been a problem anyway. :D
Hi Louise, I haven’t tried this myself, but it should work to reheat the stuffing in the oven the day of. I’d put it in a casserole dish, cover with foil, and bake until warm. You can take the foil off for the last few minutes if you’d like it to crisp up a bit. I hope you enjoy!
Hi Louise, I had another thought/recommendation! If I were you, I would add everything to the slow cooker dry the day before, except the liquid. You could then stir together the liquid and pour it in just before cooking. I probably wouldn’t recommend cooking it all the way through then reheating it because of the shape—the outsides will be crispy, so it would be oddly shaped transferred out of the crock pot and into a pan to reheat. I hope that helps!
Erin, took this in my Crock Pot, (started at home & completed at families home) and EVERYONE Raved!! I definitely will bring this next year AND The next along side someone else’s traditional dressing! It was so easy. I bought an inexpensive artisan bread, let it dry (cubed) over night and it was so moist and delectable after ‘testing’ in Crock Pot, just an hour after cooking. Did do it on LOW, and I coulda eaten the whole Pot by myself; but what’s the fun in that..if you don’t get to hear the ‘yummy noiss’ Everyone makes when they try it?! ?
Hi Jacqueline, that would be a major experiment, and I’m afraid I don’t have any specific guidance. You may also be interested in this cornbread stuffing (you could omit the sriracha if you want): https://www.wellplated.com/cornbread-sausage-stuffing/
Made this for Thanksgiving using GF bagels for the bread. It was fantastic. It had the most delicious aroma and had everyone asking when dinner would be! Was easy to do most of it before today, and freed up the stove and oven for other things. Definitely will be making it again.
Hi Nat! I’ve only tried to make this recipe in the slow cooker, so I’m afraid I don’t have any specific advice to offer for the Instant Pot. I hope you love the recipe if you try it!
LOVE this recipe! I do however add a sage flavored sausage and reduce the sage a bit, it is a family hit every year. Easy to make and more oven space for other things.
Hi Natasha, I haven’t tried it with bagged stuffing but it might work. The only issue I see is that sometimes the bagged stuffing cubes are smaller pieces than the ones you see here. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Not a single quantity of anything is listed except 1 apple.
You mention adding broth.
Which one ? How much ?
Onion- White ? Yellow ?
Eggs- How many ?
I’m sure this is delicious, but I can’t make it with the information provided and I’m not going to guess at it.
I’m sorry to hear you are having trouble, Julian. It seems like you are only looking at the blog post. You’ll need to go to the recipe card for the entire recipe. You had to scroll past it to comment, or you can click the “jump to recipe” button that is provided at the top of the screen. Hope this helps!
My son can’t have onions and celery. Last yr did some cornbread and cranberries. Soso.
This time maybe 2 breads, cranberry, apple, and mushrooms. Maybe sweeten the mushrooms a tiny bit? What do u think?
Sage, thyme, parsley? Salt and pepper. Egg and chicken broth.
It will lost some flavor without the onions and celery, so I’d then recommend increasing the amount of herbs. You can experiment with 2 different types of bread (though cornbread will get soggy). I’ve only tested the recipe as written, but it you try some substitutes, I’d love to hear how it goes!
For some reason this recipe did not work for me. I used a sourdough artisan loaf, dried it in the oven etc. Everything was made as written. The stuffing more or less congealed into a goopy mass and turned grayish color. I think it would have been better in the oven. Possibly?
It’s funny attitudes change over the years. I grew up on stuffing, which was stuffed into the bird – and nobody ever got sick or died from it. That said, I’m not sure I’ll ever have the need to cook a whole turkey, so I would need to make my stuffing/dressing separately. This recipe sounds like a real keeper, so I’m saving it. (Thanksgiving falls during my husband’s week to cook this year, so I’m not going to worry about any of it) ?
Susan, I hope you both enjoy it if you do give it a try! :)
Suggestions on putting this in Dutch oven and in the oven instead? My crock pot bit the dust and I’m dying to make this! Temps or how long? Thanks!
I think that should work, Gretchen! I’d try 350*F, and I’d start checking for doneness between 30 and 40 minutes. It may take longer to set—I haven’t tried this recipe in the oven, but that’s where I would start.
Hi Erin.. thank you for all the great recipes you share with us. I am a stuffing lover, and this sounds delicious. However, the finished product looks dry. I like stuffing that holds together… This looks like it’s loose. Maybe just the pictures?
Hi Cat! This is very moist and holds together nicely, with crispy edges as described. It might just be the pictures, because it’s not crumbly at all. I hope you enjoy the recipe if you try it!
This recipe really sounds good. The family really likes a little sausage in their dressing. Could you put cooked sausage in this recipe? I have made many of your delicious recipes. Thanks
Hi Rosemary, yes I think you could add in cooked sausage! I hope you enjoy it. Thanks so much for your kind comment!
This came out excellent! I totally should have checked how much it made, but if I was a snacker the amount of leftovers wouldn’t have been a problem anyway. :D
Jessi, I’m so glad to hear you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave this wonderful review!
Hi Erin this recipe sounds good but could it be made ahead and then reheated in the oven day of. Louise.
Hi Louise, I haven’t tried this myself, but it should work to reheat the stuffing in the oven the day of. I’d put it in a casserole dish, cover with foil, and bake until warm. You can take the foil off for the last few minutes if you’d like it to crisp up a bit. I hope you enjoy!
Hi Louise, I had another thought/recommendation! If I were you, I would add everything to the slow cooker dry the day before, except the liquid. You could then stir together the liquid and pour it in just before cooking. I probably wouldn’t recommend cooking it all the way through then reheating it because of the shape—the outsides will be crispy, so it would be oddly shaped transferred out of the crock pot and into a pan to reheat. I hope that helps!
Erin, took this in my Crock Pot, (started at home & completed at families home) and EVERYONE Raved!! I definitely will bring this next year AND The next along side someone else’s traditional dressing! It was so easy. I bought an inexpensive artisan bread, let it dry (cubed) over night and it was so moist and delectable after ‘testing’ in Crock Pot, just an hour after cooking. Did do it on LOW, and I coulda eaten the whole Pot by myself; but what’s the fun in that..if you don’t get to hear the ‘yummy noiss’ Everyone makes when they try it?! ?
I’m so glad to hear this recipe was a success too, Sandy! Thanks so much for sharing how it went!
Thoughts on adding Italian sausage to this and subbing with cornbread? Please let me know what you think regarding moisture. Thanks!
Hi Jacqueline, that would be a major experiment, and I’m afraid I don’t have any specific guidance. You may also be interested in this cornbread stuffing (you could omit the sriracha if you want): https://www.wellplated.com/cornbread-sausage-stuffing/
Thanks for the rec, Erin!
Made this for Thanksgiving using GF bagels for the bread. It was fantastic. It had the most delicious aroma and had everyone asking when dinner would be! Was easy to do most of it before today, and freed up the stove and oven for other things. Definitely will be making it again.
Thanks for reporting back, Valeri! I’m happy to hear it was a winner!
I have an instant pot. I don’t think it will close with the towel to absorb the moisture. Any ideas or thoughts? Thank you!
Hi Nat! I’ve only tried to make this recipe in the slow cooker, so I’m afraid I don’t have any specific advice to offer for the Instant Pot. I hope you love the recipe if you try it!
LOVE this recipe! I do however add a sage flavored sausage and reduce the sage a bit, it is a family hit every year. Easy to make and more oven space for other things.
Thank you for this recipe <3
I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed it, Maria! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Had this on Thanksgiving after doing the prep ahead steps to help make day-of easier. It was delicious!! Full of flavor and moist ??
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Megan! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I’m making this now, it smells heavenly! Question — do you stir this halfway through to redistribute the liquid or does that disrupt the brown edges?
Hi Diane! No need to stir halfway through! Hope this helps!
I have vegetarians coming for Thanksgiving. Will this work with vegetable broth and still be flavorful?
Definitely Lois!! Hope you all love it. I’d use veggie stock vs. broth if you can find it because stock has a bit more flavor.
Can you just use the traditional bagged cubed stuffing? I really don’t want to make my own using bread due to time constraints
Hi Natasha, I haven’t tried it with bagged stuffing but it might work. The only issue I see is that sometimes the bagged stuffing cubes are smaller pieces than the ones you see here. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Not a single quantity of anything is listed except 1 apple.
You mention adding broth.
Which one ? How much ?
Onion- White ? Yellow ?
Eggs- How many ?
I’m sure this is delicious, but I can’t make it with the information provided and I’m not going to guess at it.
I’m sorry to hear you are having trouble, Julian. It seems like you are only looking at the blog post. You’ll need to go to the recipe card for the entire recipe. You had to scroll past it to comment, or you can click the “jump to recipe” button that is provided at the top of the screen. Hope this helps!
My son can’t have onions and celery. Last yr did some cornbread and cranberries. Soso.
This time maybe 2 breads, cranberry, apple, and mushrooms. Maybe sweeten the mushrooms a tiny bit? What do u think?
Sage, thyme, parsley? Salt and pepper. Egg and chicken broth.
It will lost some flavor without the onions and celery, so I’d then recommend increasing the amount of herbs. You can experiment with 2 different types of bread (though cornbread will get soggy). I’ve only tested the recipe as written, but it you try some substitutes, I’d love to hear how it goes!
For some reason this recipe did not work for me. I used a sourdough artisan loaf, dried it in the oven etc. Everything was made as written. The stuffing more or less congealed into a goopy mass and turned grayish color. I think it would have been better in the oven. Possibly?
I’m sorry to hear this BSD. I have no idea what could of caused it to turn gray, maybe the type of broth used? The oven works great too!
Hi Erin, can I combine everything in slowcooker the night before and cook next day.
Betty, I haven’t tried this but I think it would work! I’d refrigerate the insert, then let it come to room temperature before cooking the stuffing.