• Just made this for my 4 year olds birthday. It turned out really well. I made a double recipe and made two cakes. I cut each cake in half and put icing in the middle of each cake. I had to make a 2.5x icing recipe to cover the cakes and have the middle layer. We loved it! We used 250g of frozen strawberries and had a lot of puree left over.4 stars

  • I made this strawberry cake for an Easter gathering. It was amazing! Moist and delicious! I could have eaten the frosting with a spoon! This cake will definitely be on repeat at our house!!5 stars

  • My fiance and I are going to make this cake for our wedding, but want to use a bundt pan instead. Is there anything that you think we should do differently from the recipe as written here?

    Thank you!

    1. Hi Joseph! I’ve only tested the recipe as written so it would be hard to say how it would come out in a bundt pan. I’m positive you would have to adjust the time on baking. I would recommend spending some time experimenting with it before the big day! Hope you enjoy it!

      1. Erin,
        We made this cake, along with a similar lemon cake for the wedding in bundt pans. They turned out wonderful! Thank you!5 stars

  • Erin,
    Have you tried using this recipe for cupcakes? Any thoughts on that? Thanks for the time taken for your reply. …xox…

    1. Hi Diane, I have lots of notes in the blog post that talks about how to adapt this using all kind of pans, including making cupcakes. Hope this helps!

  • Made a double layer version of this cake and it was a crowd pleaser. Used half a cup less of sugar for the cake and half the amount of powdered sugar for the icing (I doubled the recipe since making 2 layers). This is a dense cake.5 stars

    1. Hi Leslie! I’ve only tried it with strawberries but cherries sound amazing! If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

  • I loved the flavors in this cake but it was a little dense. Can I sub oil for butter or cake flour for the all purpose?4 stars

    1. Hi Valerie! I’ve only tested the recipe as written, so I can’t say for sure about those specific substitutions. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

      1. I ended up making a vanilla bean cake from a different recipe but had to use this frosting! It’s seriously the best I’ve ever had.

        I made it for my daughter’s 4th birthday and the entire thing is gone, everyone loved it! Will be saving to make again.5 stars

  • I baked this today and I think I have two “hockey pucks” instead of two cakes. They are heavy and dense. Two questions: The ingredients list says “2 large whole eggs” but the instructions say “add the whole egg.” Where does the other egg go? And why add egg whites without beating them to get lightness into the cake?

    1. I’m sorry to hear you had problems with the recipe, Rhoda! It has worked well for myself (and others) and I wished it would have been a hit for you too.
      When you add the whole egg that is supposed to be add the whole eggs, I’ll make sure to correct that. And you do beat the egg whites in Step 5. Hope this helps!

  • I’m pretty sure I’ve left a comment about this cake in the past but it bears repeating. I cook A LOT and this is one of the only recipes that I return to several times a year. It is famous in my family. Everyone requests this strawberry cake for their birthday and family gatherings.5 stars

  • Hi! I’m planning on making this for my daughter’s second birthday today. Any idea if this recipe works well with cake flour? Thanks in advance for your help!

    1. Hi Priya, I’ve only tested the recipe as written, so I can’t say for sure about those specific substitutions. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

  • I’m going to make this cake today. Is it ok or possible to substitute the granulated sugar for brown sugar or coconut sugar? Thank you!

    1. Hi Brooke, I’ve only tried this recipe with white sugar, so I’m afraid I can’t recommend any alternatives. I do know other readers have tried using half white sugar and half coconut sugar with success. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!

  • Delicious cake, although it’s very dense. I’ve made it with strawberries before and this time I subbed mango and had a little puree left over so I added some extra on top of the middle layer of frosting and it was excellent!4 stars

  • The blog says two egg whites, one whole eggs, however, the recipe ingredients has four egg whites and two whole eggs. Can I just check which it is?
    I made this cake for my son’s 2nd birthday but it seemed overly moist and had bits sticking to the baking paper and plate when decorating! So not sure if I measured wrong somewhere? Thanks!

    1. Hi Megan, the ingredients in the recipe card are the correct ones, 4 egg whites and 2 whole eggs. What was in the post, but a typo and we’ve updated it. Thanks!

  • I was amazed at how light and fluffy the cake was, and the fresh strawberry flavor really shines through. It’s not overly sweet, which makes it even more enjoyable. I’m so happy with how it turned out! Thank you so much 😀5 stars

  • My daughter requested a strawberry cake for her 3rd birthday. I happened upon this recipe. It’s definitely a labor of love to back but shoot dang is it worth it. All the party guests were raving about how delicious this cake is. Literally THE BEST!5 stars

  • It definitely exceeded all my expectations! The cake itself is light and fluffy, with just the right amount of sweetness. The fresh strawberries really make a difference in the flavor. This one is a keeper for sure!5 stars

  • This is my third time making this cake, coming back to the website to check a few details I felt obligated to leave a review because it’s that good!!!

    Definitely follow the instructions on letting the cakes cool completely before rushing to frost, I have learned my lesson after my first attempt. Patience is important for this one but nonetheless it’s my favorite cake! Delicious and not overly sweet.

  • Hi! I plan to make this for my sister’s baby shower, and I’m wanting to make a 3-layer cake. Would you suggest doubling both recipes? (Cake and frosting) I just want to make sure I have enough!
    Thank you!

    1. Hi Lindsay! Yes, I would. You want to make sure you would have enough batter and frosting for all of the layers! Enjoy!