• This is a perfect family-friendly casserole and was great to prep ahead! Love the healthy ingredients and ease of making it in one pot! We all enjoyed it and we’ll be working it into our regular rotation! Thank you for a great cooking challenge recipe!5 stars

    1
  • Made this for my lunches this week – so flavorful and love how veggie packed it is! It took a little longer for me for the rice to cook enough. A super easy healthy one pot meal.5 stars

    1
  • Delicious! Prepped the day before and then it was mainly simmering on the stove tonight… worked out perfect to have it going while my 4 year old was taking a bath.5 stars

  • I wasn’t sure my family would be on board with this because they are not stuffed pepper fans, but I was wrong! Everyone loved it! The peppers are mild and a bit fruity and are mellowed out with the spices and tomatoes. I love that it all comes together in one pot, so it is super easy, especially for a busy weeknight. So much better than a traditional stuffed pepper!5 stars

    2
  • Just made this recipe tonight. It was the perfect meal for a chilly day. I did not have frozen spinach, but I did have fresh which worked just fine. Great flavor and easy to make. We will be having this again! Erin, between your two cookbooks and website my recipe rotation stays fresh, healthy, and tasty. Thank you so much for all you do.5 stars

    1
    1. So many readers ask about using fresh spinach, so I am happy to hear that it worked well for you! This looks great, Alyssa!

  • I’m 10 years old and just started cooking and baking with my Dad. This is the first casserole we’ve made and it was very fun to make. My Dad also enjoyed eating it and loved all the veggies. I liked the cheesey top. We are looking forward to next months challenge!5 stars

    5
  • I added another green peper and a jar of drained sliced banana peppers to brighten it up4 stars

    1. Hi Denise! I haven’t tried it myself but since they have similar cooking times, I think it could work. Let me know how it goes if you decide to experiment!

  • Bought microwave quinoa and that cut the time in half and did not add water or the tomato sauce. Turned out fantastic!! This recipe is quick and easy and healthy.5 stars

  • 🌶️🫑🧅My kids were hugely skeptical as always. They were SO IMPRESSED with this dish.
    Normally they don’t like brown rice but it’s absolutely perfect for this recipe. Thank you for sharing. This one is going in the favorites collection! 🥰5 stars

  • I have to agree with several of the comments. I’m very accomplished in the kitchen and was excited to try this recipe. I had some concerns about the rice before I started and had I read the comments I would have done something completely different. After an hour and a half the rice still was not done. Some of it had started to soften but there was still some that was still crunchy. If you’re making this recipe, cook your rice first. The flavor is good but it is not a casserole. More like a one pot dish.3 stars

    1
    1. Hi Kathy, I’m so sorry to hear you had an issue with the rice. I looked online at a few different brands of brown rice and it seems like the cooking time will depend on the brand used. The whole organic brown rice from Target cooks in 25 minutes or so, but other brand I found takes longer, so I would definitely look at the cook time on your bag and see how long it says. This might be why it takes some readers longer for their rice to cook then others. I would also raise the temperature a little more on the dutch oven to see if that helps. Hope this helps!

      2
  • Delicious!! My only note is that it’s a bit low in protein. Next time I’ll either add an extra pound of ground chicken or sub water and rice for bone broth and quinoa. Served it with a side of blended cottage cheese and hot sauce… delicious! Will absolutely make it again.5 stars

  • Delicious
    I made slightly lighter but just adding cheddar cheese and not the mozzarella too and added 1/2 c of rice.5 stars

  • This is great! I doubled the recipe in a big pot and made two casseroles in 9×13 pans. Also added a can of black beans to each pan and some chili powder. Will definitely make again! Thanks for the recipe!5 stars

  • I have made this numerous times, and will continue to do so. It is very good and a favorite of my husband’s, he loves stuffed peppers but likes this even more! Thank you for a wonderful recipe.5 stars

  • We loved this! Tons of flavor and super easy-rice turned out great! I omitted the spinach (because I forgot to buy it!) I added more ground beef (doubled recipe with 3 lbs ground beef). I love that this is a healthy high protein easy one pot dish! Will definitely be making again!5 stars

  • This one wasn’t a favorite of ours, it just didn’t have a lot of flavor and took a long longer to cook the rice. I may have used the wrong type of brown rice? This is probably the first Well Plated recipe we found that didn’t make the repeat pile.3 stars

    1. Sorry to hear that, Stacey. Some readers have reported back saying that starting with cooked rice worked well. While the flavors and amounts have worked well for us, and many others, you can definitely adjust it based on your personal preference. Hope this helps!