Made this with 3 LG sweet potatoes, but I had a high ratio of celery and onion to the potatoes. Add 2 leftover boiled white potatoes. Had enough dressing, and of course I added more bacon! Everyone loved it.
Thank you for sharing this recipe! I made this today and it was a HUGE hit…HUGE! This has to be one of the best potato salads one had, no lie! I also made your Lemon layer cake with the Lemon Cream Cheese icing, so delicios! Thank you for the great recipes !
Here’s the deal. I made this using butternut squash instead. It is orange, hard, and what I had on hand. Otherwise followed directions with less oil, more squash. I baked the squash chunks 15 mins. or so.My life is now forever changed for the better. Thank you Erin. I now must return to the bowl and ‘sample’ just to make sure.
Jim, this is so so good to hear, and I bet the recipe was delicious with butternut squash too. Thanks so much for sharing your comment and enjoy every bite!
This will be my new go to picnic/get together side! I’ve made it twice this week, and I’m in love! Way better than any mayo based potato salad I’ve tried. Thanks!
So I made this Sweet Potato Salad with Bacon this evening. It turned out beautiful and delicious! I decided to add some pomegranate arils for more color, health and yumminess. So glad I did. I wish I could include a photo to show you how lovely it is, but I’m posting it on twitter (@MaryShowalter). Thank you so much for the recipe!
Mary, I am so happy to hear this! The pomegranate sounds like a lovely addition too. Thanks so much for trying the recipe and leaving this lovely review!
Oh my gosh, lost my old sweet potato salad recipe (also with jalapeño) and stumbled across this one. So glad I did because it beats the oldie hands down! Thought I wouldn’t like the whole grain mustard, but it’s perfect. What a great blend of flavors and healthy to boot : )
This was fantastic! My daughter took all the leftovers back to school with her! And EVERYONE has asked for me to make it again! (Even those who aren’t that crazy about sweet potatoes.) Only changes I made were to leave out celery, use red pepper flakes instead of jalapeno, and apple cider vinegar instead of rice vinegar. And those changes had to do with what I had on hand. I will be making this all summer!! Thanks for the yummy recipe!
This is absolutely AMAZING. My son actually found this recipe first and made it and then shared with me. I have made it several times since and have given the recipe to at least 4 other people. I can’t say enough about how great this is!!!
Made a mistake. Stopped boiling sweet potatoes, quickly drained them placed in hot oven to finish cooking and hoped they crisp-up. They did crisp up a little. Add dressing. Served room temp. Everyone loved it. BUT THE NEXT DAY, EVEN BETTER TASTING. This sweet potato salad with bacon was very, very tasty. Gave friends recipe. Will make for lady’s get together. If I owned a healthy restaurant, would place Sweet Potato Salad on menu. Would definitely be a hit!
Hi! Salting the water does help the potatoes cook and promotes a wonderful creamy texture, but you could skip it if needed. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
My 10 year old and I just made this together. The kid loves potato salad and loves mustard but isn’t a sweet potato fan. He loved this recipe! He measured all of the dressing ingredients even helped peel the potatoes, put the bacon on the pan and cut the celery.
Hi Erin, I’m trying this for the first time today. The recipe calls for 3 large sweet potatoes, once they’re cubed, how do they measure? How many cups? I’m cutting this recipe in half. Thank you! Lorri
Hi Lorri, I’ve not measured the amount of sweet potatoes in cups, so it would be hard to say. This really is a forgiving recipe so if you are halving, I would use two medium sweet potatoes. Hope you enjoy it!
My Sister in law brought this to Easter dinner and it was soooo good! We don’t have any dietary restrictions but it’s still delicious! Thankfully she sent me the link to the recipe!
This potato salad was delicious. My father-in-law is diabetic, so can’t have regular potatoes. I like to make items that don’t make him feel like he is missing out! I made this as a side for out BBQ, and the entire family loved it! Thank you!
Made this with 3 LG sweet potatoes, but I had a high ratio of celery and onion to the potatoes. Add 2 leftover boiled white potatoes. Had enough dressing, and of course I added more bacon! Everyone loved it.
Thank you for sharing this recipe! I made this today and it was a HUGE hit…HUGE! This has to be one of the best potato salads one had, no lie! I also made your Lemon layer cake with the Lemon Cream Cheese icing, so delicios! Thank you for the great recipes !
Ashley, YAY!!! I am so, so happy to hear this. Thanks for trying the recipe and sharing your review!
Here’s the deal. I made this using butternut squash instead. It is orange, hard, and what I had on hand. Otherwise followed directions with less oil, more squash. I baked the squash chunks 15 mins. or so.My life is now forever changed for the better. Thank you Erin. I now must return to the bowl and ‘sample’ just to make sure.
Jim Duffey
Jim, this is so so good to hear, and I bet the recipe was delicious with butternut squash too. Thanks so much for sharing your comment and enjoy every bite!
This will be my new go to picnic/get together side! I’ve made it twice this week, and I’m in love! Way better than any mayo based potato salad I’ve tried. Thanks!
So I made this Sweet Potato Salad with Bacon this evening. It turned out beautiful and delicious! I decided to add some pomegranate arils for more color, health and yumminess. So glad I did. I wish I could include a photo to show you how lovely it is, but I’m posting it on twitter (@MaryShowalter). Thank you so much for the recipe!
Mary, I am so happy to hear this! The pomegranate sounds like a lovely addition too. Thanks so much for trying the recipe and leaving this lovely review!
I made this today for memorial weekend. I left the bacon on the side as we have some vegan family members. Delicious!
HOORAY Madeline! I am so happy to hear you all enjoyed it. It’s one of our favorites too!
Oh my gosh, lost my old sweet potato salad recipe (also with jalapeño) and stumbled across this one. So glad I did because it beats the oldie hands down! Thought I wouldn’t like the whole grain mustard, but it’s perfect. What a great blend of flavors and healthy to boot : )
So happy you enjoyed it Gina!! Thanks for sharing this lovely review, and I’m so happy you found the recipe too!
Ridiculously delicious!
Whooo hoooo! Thanks Paul!
This was fantastic! My daughter took all the leftovers back to school with her! And EVERYONE has asked for me to make it again! (Even those who aren’t that crazy about sweet potatoes.) Only changes I made were to leave out celery, use red pepper flakes instead of jalapeno, and apple cider vinegar instead of rice vinegar. And those changes had to do with what I had on hand. I will be making this all summer!! Thanks for the yummy recipe!
Melissa, I’m so glad this recipe is a hit! Thanks for taking the time to share this wonderful review.
This is absolutely AMAZING. My son actually found this recipe first and made it and then shared with me. I have made it several times since and have given the recipe to at least 4 other people. I can’t say enough about how great this is!!!
I’m SO happy that you’ve enjoyed it, Pamela! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Made a mistake. Stopped boiling sweet potatoes, quickly drained them placed in hot oven to finish cooking and hoped they crisp-up. They did crisp up a little. Add dressing. Served room temp. Everyone loved it. BUT THE NEXT DAY, EVEN BETTER TASTING. This sweet potato salad with bacon was very, very tasty. Gave friends recipe. Will make for lady’s get together. If I owned a healthy restaurant, would place Sweet Potato Salad on menu. Would definitely be a hit!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Kathy! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Do I have to salt the water? (Low salt diet)
Hi! Salting the water does help the potatoes cook and promotes a wonderful creamy texture, but you could skip it if needed. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
My 10 year old and I just made this together. The kid loves potato salad and loves mustard but isn’t a sweet potato fan. He loved this recipe! He measured all of the dressing ingredients even helped peel the potatoes, put the bacon on the pan and cut the celery.
I’m so happy that it was a hit, Jacqueline! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Wow……loved this recipe, and definitely will use it again.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Laurie! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This is one of my favs!! I’m a big sweet potato fan and just add in avocados to this sometimes as an extra BUT seriously this is so delicious ?
I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed it, Steph! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Love at first bite!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Kim! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Hi Erin, I’m trying this for the first time today. The recipe calls for 3 large sweet potatoes, once they’re cubed, how do they measure? How many cups? I’m cutting this recipe in half. Thank you! Lorri
Hi Lorri, I’ve not measured the amount of sweet potatoes in cups, so it would be hard to say. This really is a forgiving recipe so if you are halving, I would use two medium sweet potatoes. Hope you enjoy it!
I found the dressing too bitter for my taste so added about 1Tbs sugar. Very tasty.
Hi Brian! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
My Sister in law brought this to Easter dinner and it was soooo good! We don’t have any dietary restrictions but it’s still delicious! Thankfully she sent me the link to the recipe!
Hi Frances! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This potato salad was delicious. My father-in-law is diabetic, so can’t have regular potatoes. I like to make items that don’t make him feel like he is missing out! I made this as a side for out BBQ, and the entire family loved it! Thank you!
Hi Jennifer! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!