This looks extra good and I’ll definitely be making it soon. Slo-cooker is the way to go in the summer if at all possible. Hope you have a wonderful “reunion”. I also have the pleasure of doing the same with my best friend from college – she’ll be spending this coming Tuesday with us along with her sister. Have a great weekend!
Hi Erin! Congrats on keeping your friends so close to your heart! I’m still close to my high school and college friends after 50 years! Enjoy this blessing.
A question: have you ever used foil or a commercial liner in your slow cooker? I was wondering if you used one if you could lift the whole thing out (in one piece) to either put in a decorative platter OR take it out and freeze for a future meal?
Have fun!
Hi Kathy! I have not tried foil or commercial liners, but if you’ve had good experience with them on similar recipes, you are welcome to try it! If it doesn’t work, you’ll be able to slice it into big pieces and lift them out individually (which is what I did for these photos!). I hope you enjoy!
What can I say? I love Mexican food, and in a crockpot, during the summer, even better. Going to try it this weekend. I have everything but the tortillas, so this will be easy.
Val
Hi! Wow, this looks delicious and EASY! I’d love to make this but have a question — my husband is allergic to tomatoes. Can I simply leave them out, or do you think omitting the canned tomatoes + their juices would affect the outcome too much? Thanks so much for your time!
Hi Kristen! I’m afraid the tomatoes are pretty necessary to the recipe, both for moisture and for flavor. I wish I had a good substitute, but I honestly can’t think of one :( You might like this Mexican Pasta Salad: https://www.wellplated.com/mexican-pasta-salad/. It’s not slow cooker but is delicious! You could swap the tomatoes for chopped red bell pepper instead.
Did you add the toppings later or cook them with the casserole? They look fresh not cooked and I was confused reading the article. Thank you for posting this! Just wanna know about toppings ?
Erin:
I made this recipe For Sunday dinner! It is wonderful! I am having friends over mid week and I will be making the casserole again. It’s so easy to make and very hearty! I was chatting with my son on the phone while I was making it and after I assembled everything, or thought I had, I realized that I forgot to add the 2 cans of diced tomatoes!! I quickly poured the 2 cans of diced tomatoes on top of the casserole in the slow cooker! I thought if this casserole doesn’t turn out, no problem, I can blame it on my son! Didn’t need to worry, the casserole was delicious! Nice hearty meal anytime but especially for the fall and winter season! You’re the best! Thanks very much.
Hi Erin
This recipe looks amazing and I can’t wait to try it! However, I’m the only person in my house that’ll eat it (my husband has an eating disorder and its touch and go as to whether my 2 year old will eat it) so I was wondering if its possible to freeze it in individual portions?
Thanks for posting so many delicious recipes, your blog has been a lifesaver in more ways than one! Xxx
I can’t wait to try this for college football season! I have one quick question about it though — would it not be more advantageous to start with a layer of tortillas at the bottom? It seems to me that it would keep it all together a bit better when you’re trying to cut and serve it. Thanks so much!
Hi Chris, sticking can be an issue if you start with a tortilla on the bottom, which is why I recommend starting with the sauce. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Hi Gina, if you want to double it, I’d recommend you borrow another slow cooker or do one of the batches in the oven. Doubling it in one crock pot would make it really, really thick, which would be hard to cut and hard to cook too. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
This was soooo good. Exceeded my expectations. I mixed some plain not fat Greek yogurt into the filling to make it even creamier, and subbed in some chipotle chili powder because I’m obsessed with that spice
Elizabeth I LOVE chipotle chili powder too and bet that would be delicious. Thanks so much for trying the recipe and taking time to leave this wonderful review, along with the tip on the fresh tomatoes. YUM!
Hi Samantha! I’ve never tried the recipe this way, but my guess is that because corn tortillas are more fragile, they will break down quite a bit more than wheat tortillas and the casserole will be very soft. If that doesn’t bother, you can certainly experiment with corn instead!
This looks extra good and I’ll definitely be making it soon. Slo-cooker is the way to go in the summer if at all possible. Hope you have a wonderful “reunion”. I also have the pleasure of doing the same with my best friend from college – she’ll be spending this coming Tuesday with us along with her sister. Have a great weekend!
Thank you, Chris! I hope you love the recipe, and I hope you have a wonderful visit as well!
I just kinda want to dive right into that slow cooker! So cheesy and tasty looking :)
Thanks Gerry!
Hi Erin! Congrats on keeping your friends so close to your heart! I’m still close to my high school and college friends after 50 years! Enjoy this blessing.
A question: have you ever used foil or a commercial liner in your slow cooker? I was wondering if you used one if you could lift the whole thing out (in one piece) to either put in a decorative platter OR take it out and freeze for a future meal?
Have fun!
Hi Kathy! I have not tried foil or commercial liners, but if you’ve had good experience with them on similar recipes, you are welcome to try it! If it doesn’t work, you’ll be able to slice it into big pieces and lift them out individually (which is what I did for these photos!). I hope you enjoy!
What can I say? I love Mexican food, and in a crockpot, during the summer, even better. Going to try it this weekend. I have everything but the tortillas, so this will be easy.
Val
Hope you love it Val!!
Yuu mean I don’t have to turn on the oven? Praise god! Totally truing this with my udis tortillas! YUM!
That’s absolutely right! I hope you enjoy!
Hi Erin, this looks yummy! Can’t wait to try! Hope you have a great time tonight with your dear friends! Sounds like a perfect evening!
Thank you so much, Laurie! I hope you enjoy the recipe. :)
OMG yum! I love the flavors in this! Such a great Slow Cooker recipe!
This will be so cozy in the fall!!
hey girl- this looks amazing! Ya’ll have fun!
Thanks so much Shawnna!
Hi! Wow, this looks delicious and EASY! I’d love to make this but have a question — my husband is allergic to tomatoes. Can I simply leave them out, or do you think omitting the canned tomatoes + their juices would affect the outcome too much? Thanks so much for your time!
Hi Kristen! I’m afraid the tomatoes are pretty necessary to the recipe, both for moisture and for flavor. I wish I had a good substitute, but I honestly can’t think of one :( You might like this Mexican Pasta Salad: https://www.wellplated.com/mexican-pasta-salad/. It’s not slow cooker but is delicious! You could swap the tomatoes for chopped red bell pepper instead.
Did you add the toppings later or cook them with the casserole? They look fresh not cooked and I was confused reading the article. Thank you for posting this! Just wanna know about toppings ?
Hi Melissa! Yes, I added the avocado and cilantro at the end. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Erin:
I made this recipe For Sunday dinner! It is wonderful! I am having friends over mid week and I will be making the casserole again. It’s so easy to make and very hearty! I was chatting with my son on the phone while I was making it and after I assembled everything, or thought I had, I realized that I forgot to add the 2 cans of diced tomatoes!! I quickly poured the 2 cans of diced tomatoes on top of the casserole in the slow cooker! I thought if this casserole doesn’t turn out, no problem, I can blame it on my son! Didn’t need to worry, the casserole was delicious! Nice hearty meal anytime but especially for the fall and winter season! You’re the best! Thanks very much.
Suzy, I’m happy to hear you enjoyed the recipe! Thanks so much for giving it a try and taking the time to report back!
Hi Erin
This recipe looks amazing and I can’t wait to try it! However, I’m the only person in my house that’ll eat it (my husband has an eating disorder and its touch and go as to whether my 2 year old will eat it) so I was wondering if its possible to freeze it in individual portions?
Thanks for posting so many delicious recipes, your blog has been a lifesaver in more ways than one! Xxx
Hi Paula, absolutely! You can cut into portions, wrap individually, freeze, and then thaw overnight. I hope you love it.
This looks delicious! I don’t have a full size slow cooker. Is that ok? Would I have to adjust the recipe for a 4.5 qt crockpot?
Hi Veronica, I’d do 3/4 of the recipe to make sure it fits and to ensure that it cooks all the way through!
I can’t wait to try this for college football season! I have one quick question about it though — would it not be more advantageous to start with a layer of tortillas at the bottom? It seems to me that it would keep it all together a bit better when you’re trying to cut and serve it. Thanks so much!
Hi Chris, sticking can be an issue if you start with a tortilla on the bottom, which is why I recommend starting with the sauce. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Can I double this?
Hi Gina, if you want to double it, I’d recommend you borrow another slow cooker or do one of the batches in the oven. Doubling it in one crock pot would make it really, really thick, which would be hard to cut and hard to cook too. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
If I wanted to bake this in the oven instead, do you have suggestions on settings? Time?
Hi Steph, I’d try it at 350 degrees F for 40 minutes or so, or until hot and bubbly!
Turned out great! Baking recommendations were perfect.
I’m so happy to hear it, Steph! Thanks!
Do you have to cook the ground turkey and beans first? Just wanted a “dump and walk away” recipe and this looks delicious!
Hi Angie! Yes, I am afraid you do. If you are looking for a “dump and go” try these crockpot stuffed peppers. They are super easy and delicious! https://www.wellplated.com/chicken-quinoa-crock-pot-stuffed-peppers/
This was soooo good. Exceeded my expectations. I mixed some plain not fat Greek yogurt into the filling to make it even creamier, and subbed in some chipotle chili powder because I’m obsessed with that spice
Also, I had farm fresh tomatoes I needed to use up, and fresh tomatoes instead of canned worked just fine!
How many fresh tomatoes or cups did you use?
Elizabeth I LOVE chipotle chili powder too and bet that would be delicious. Thanks so much for trying the recipe and taking time to leave this wonderful review, along with the tip on the fresh tomatoes. YUM!
Looks so good! Could you use corn tortillas in this vs. wheat?
Hi Samantha! I’ve never tried the recipe this way, but my guess is that because corn tortillas are more fragile, they will break down quite a bit more than wheat tortillas and the casserole will be very soft. If that doesn’t bother, you can certainly experiment with corn instead!