I’m sorry that this smoothie wasn’t to your tastes, Elizabeth. I (and other readers) have really enjoyed it, so I truly wish it would’ve been a hit for you too!
This smoothie is really good i forgot the maple syrup and it still turned out really good the only little thing that is kinda weird is the texture but it is still a really good smoothie a solid 5/5.
thank you for this recipe. this is a lifesaver! i needed a liquid food idea so I can easily eat breakfast out of home. i did a lot of modifications as i don’t have all the spices plus i also added plant-based protein and removed the bananas. it still tasted good! this will be my out of home go-to breakfast during the pandemic :D
I’m on an apple smoothie making adventure. Due to more nutritional value I am opting to make smoothies rather than juicing. Would mango work with this recipe or any other fruit. i.e strawberry or pineapple??
This smoothie tastes horrible! I had to add over double the amount of milk because the smoothie was wayyy too thick and clumpy, and even afterward, it still had a really weird texture. The combination of all the ingredients also made the drink taste off and was very bizarre.
I found this to be really boring flavor-wise, and also needed to add a lot more liquid in order to get it to blend properly. Not awful, but certainly not something I would make again.
Thank you! I finally have a way to eat all those pesky apples in my fridge. I added granola instead of oats and a tad more peanut butter, and I loved the texture and taste of this smoothie. 10/10! Will definitely make again :)
I absolutely love this smoothie and am so grateful to have found it! Like other commenters, I also encountered the “mushy” texture (it’s from the rolled oats plus cinnamon, mostly), but was prepared to combat this. I added a bit more almond milk, per the instructions, but this didn’t do much in the way of reducing the grainy texture; it almost seemed to enhance it.
If it’s helpful to anyone else who might be looking to make this amazing smoothie just a bit smoother and juicier, you can adjust the single person serving by adding 1/2 cup of apple juice or 1/4 cup of vanilla greek yogurt (I did both and turned it into two servings). I would recommend using pure pressed apple juice to avoid oversweetening the smoothie, and would also suggest adding the juice and almond milk before the apples and blending that really good before adding the rest. Finally, I added just a smidge more peanut butter (1/4 tbsp) and amber maple syrup (1/2 tbsp).
Thank you so much for this phenomenal addition! My whole family agrees that this is the best smoothie of 2021.
Oatmeal makes the texture funky but thats expected! I added a little bit of honey and frozen spinach, omitted the banana too, and it was still awesome. Yummy!!
This smoothie tasted just ok. Made it according to the recipe (2x). The oats made a good texture but found that the peanut butter overwhelmed the taste of the apples; I used Gala apples. It was too thick and I had to add more milk in order to get it to blend. I will try it again without the peanut butter and see how it does.
I forgot to add the oats but this was delicious and I’ll make it again! I’m new to smoothie making, and appreciate great recipes.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Lisa! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I made this without the banana and it was absolutely delicious. Try it without banana if you don’t like super sweet smoothies.
YAY, so happy to hear it Janice. Thank you for sharing!!
It was okay but it would have been better without the nutmeg and allspice. Too many spices/ flavors going on.
I’m sorry that this smoothie wasn’t to your tastes, Elizabeth. I (and other readers) have really enjoyed it, so I truly wish it would’ve been a hit for you too!
unfortunately this has a mushy and grainy texture and is bland :( i had to force this down and i still didnt finish
I’m sorry that this wasn’t to your tastes, Jaimie. I (and other readers) have enjoyed it, so I wish it would’ve been a hit for you too!
This smoothie is really good i forgot the maple syrup and it still turned out really good the only little thing that is kinda weird is the texture but it is still a really good smoothie a solid 5/5.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Angel! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This was delicious! I added half a scoop of vanilla protein powder and omitted the vanilla and sugar. Will be making again tomorrow morning.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Stephani! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I think this smoothie is absolutely delicious. I left out the allspice. It tasted just like an apple pie. What a great way to start breakfast!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Lindsey! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
thank you for this recipe. this is a lifesaver! i needed a liquid food idea so I can easily eat breakfast out of home. i did a lot of modifications as i don’t have all the spices plus i also added plant-based protein and removed the bananas. it still tasted good! this will be my out of home go-to breakfast during the pandemic :D
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Hazel! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I hated it
The oatmeal was awful and added a powdery texture and the spices were too much.
I’m sorry that this wasn’t to your tastes, Sarah. I (and other readers) have enjoyed it, so I wish it would’ve been a hit for you too!
This is a vanilla smoothie with hints of peanut butter. With the amount of vanilla I used, I could make like two cakes omg.
I’m sorry that this wasn’t to your tastes, Blake. I (and other readers) have enjoyed it, so I wish it would’ve been a hit for you too!
I’m on an apple smoothie making adventure. Due to more nutritional value I am opting to make smoothies rather than juicing. Would mango work with this recipe or any other fruit. i.e strawberry or pineapple??
Hi Star! I’d recommend checking out all my delicious smoothie recipes for inspiration using the fruits you mentioned. I hope this helps!
This smoothie tastes horrible! I had to add over double the amount of milk because the smoothie was wayyy too thick and clumpy, and even afterward, it still had a really weird texture. The combination of all the ingredients also made the drink taste off and was very bizarre.
I’m sorry to hear that this recipe didn’t turn out as you’d hoped, JaM. I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
I found this to be really boring flavor-wise, and also needed to add a lot more liquid in order to get it to blend properly. Not awful, but certainly not something I would make again.
I’m sorry that this wasn’t to your tastes, Anne. I (and other readers) have enjoyed it, so I wish it would’ve been a hit for you too!
Thank you! I finally have a way to eat all those pesky apples in my fridge. I added granola instead of oats and a tad more peanut butter, and I loved the texture and taste of this smoothie. 10/10! Will definitely make again :)
Hi Shannon! So glad you enjoyed them! Thank you for this kind review!
I absolutely love this smoothie and am so grateful to have found it! Like other commenters, I also encountered the “mushy” texture (it’s from the rolled oats plus cinnamon, mostly), but was prepared to combat this. I added a bit more almond milk, per the instructions, but this didn’t do much in the way of reducing the grainy texture; it almost seemed to enhance it.
If it’s helpful to anyone else who might be looking to make this amazing smoothie just a bit smoother and juicier, you can adjust the single person serving by adding 1/2 cup of apple juice or 1/4 cup of vanilla greek yogurt (I did both and turned it into two servings). I would recommend using pure pressed apple juice to avoid oversweetening the smoothie, and would also suggest adding the juice and almond milk before the apples and blending that really good before adding the rest. Finally, I added just a smidge more peanut butter (1/4 tbsp) and amber maple syrup (1/2 tbsp).
Thank you so much for this phenomenal addition! My whole family agrees that this is the best smoothie of 2021.
Hi Victoria! Thank you so much for your feedback on the smoothie! So glad you enjoyed it!
Easy to make and delicious! I use fresh and not frozen banana, haven’t tried the frozen option
Hi Henrietta! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
thank you so much for this smoothie recipient.I added a handful of mint leaves too!!
Hi Surabhi! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Delicious! I also added spinach and whey protein. My 3 year old called it a ‘pie smoothie’. So tasty!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed it, Kristin! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
Tasty
Thanks Laurence!
Oatmeal makes the texture funky but thats expected! I added a little bit of honey and frozen spinach, omitted the banana too, and it was still awesome. Yummy!!
Hi Chloe! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This smoothie tasted just ok. Made it according to the recipe (2x). The oats made a good texture but found that the peanut butter overwhelmed the taste of the apples; I used Gala apples. It was too thick and I had to add more milk in order to get it to blend. I will try it again without the peanut butter and see how it does.
I’m sorry this recipe wasn’t to your tastes, George. I (and many other readers) have truly enjoyed it, so I wish you would’ve too!