This is amazing! Not only does it taste great but one serving only 280 calories? I had to modify since I couldn’t find just wild rice at my usual grocery. This recipe will be a staple in my home. Thanks, Erin!
Oh my! I could marry this soup. Deeeelish. However I might butterfly the chicken as the rice was overdone…. However still the best soup ever…. thanks :)
Great recipe! I made in instant pot with 3 frozen chicken breasts and chicken was moist and tender. I followed recipe except only used half of the roux as I felt it was thick enough. Will definitely make this again. I made fresh garlic bread sticks to go with the soup.
So I’ve made this about 6 times now in my Instant Pot so I wanted to report back what I’ve found! I follow Erin’s directions for the Instant Pot and do high pressure for 35 minutes once my chicken and rice are in. ONE thing I change is that I only use 3 cups of chicken broth, since the instant pot loses no liquid in the process. That being said, I do like my soups “souper” (haha) thick, so keep that in mind. Wild rice is really not hard to find in the store, my neighborhood market Walmart carries it and they pretty much carry nothing speciality. Happy cooking!
I made this last night and I loved the flavor. I improvised on the spices since I didn’t have poultry spice. I did need to add quite a bit more stock. I just wish I had checked it before 6 hours since I think my chicken was overdone and wild rice exploded a little. But I will make it again. I would also make veggies bigger, add others, and leave out potatoes.
My only criticism is the flour to butter ratio, which, as seems to be the case with others, didn’t work for me. Instead, 1/2 C butter to 1/2 C flour made a lovely base to which I added the warm milk.
Also, it is a very thick soup using only the 4 C stock, really more of a casserole than soup, so having 2 to 3 C of stock available to think the soup is a good idea.
So I attempted this recipe in an instant pot it tasted delicious but over cooked the rice and potatoes I cooked mine 30 mins should have only cooked it 20
No my favorite sadly :( My chicken also came out chewy (I checked it and took it out early). the flour mixture also came out clumpy. I made it a second time putting the milk in verrryy slowly and still the same result.
Hi Kiki, I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with this soup. Did you whisk the flour mixture well after pouring in the milk? Either way, I know it’s frustrating to try a recipe and not have it turn out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
Michele, if you keep reading the recipe, you’ll see that the remaining stock is added at the end, according to how thick you like the soup; you can add as much or as little as you like. I hope you enjoy it!
I found your site a few weeks ago, and have made several of your recipes- they’re all sooooo good!! My husband is kind of picky, but he LOVED THIS SOUP, and so did I. He also couldn’t stop raving about your Chicken Tikka Masala!!! So this week I’ll be trying the Butter Chicken. My father was from Mumbai, India, and we took him back there to see his family before he died. All my kids, and my husband, love Indian food, so I’m so glad to have a few recipes that are easy AND healthy!!! Thank you for all you do!!! You’re amazingly gifted!!
This was great!!! I used a combo of wild rice and brown rice, I seasoned and seared the chicken before throwing it in the pot and added mushies w the cream at the end. What a great soup and a great recipe. Very easy to follow!!
Note to those who skim read like me. I used all the stock up front. Should have used less for a creamier soup.
I am planning to cook my rice separately and add it at the end to avoid overcooking it, which has happened when I have cooked rice in the crock pot in the past. Should I adjust the chicken broth that is added to the chicken and veggies at the beginning if I do this?
Hi Lynne! I’ve only tested this recipe in the slow cooker but it should work on the stovetop with some adjustments. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Hi Jenna! Yes you can substitute the milk with almond milk. You’ll see more of my substitution suggestions in the recipe notes at the end of the recipe card. Hope you enjoy it!
This is amazing! Not only does it taste great but one serving only 280 calories? I had to modify since I couldn’t find just wild rice at my usual grocery. This recipe will be a staple in my home. Thanks, Erin!
Kelly, I’m so happy to hear you enjoyed the soup! Thanks so much for taking the time to leave this wonderful review!
Oh my! I could marry this soup. Deeeelish. However I might butterfly the chicken as the rice was overdone…. However still the best soup ever…. thanks :)
I’m so glad you enjoyed it, Esther! Thanks for taking the time to leave this review!
Hello! Can you use Rotisserie chicken instead? Sometimes, I feel like the chicken comes out dry when you cook it for a long time.
Hi Shristi, I didn’t experience the chicken coming out dry, you could try using rotisserie if that’s a concern for you. I hope you enjoy the recipe!
Great recipe! I made in instant pot with 3 frozen chicken breasts and chicken was moist and tender. I followed recipe except only used half of the roux as I felt it was thick enough. Will definitely make this again. I made fresh garlic bread sticks to go with the soup.
Thanks for reporting back, Judy! I’m glad to hear you enjoyed the soup!
So I’ve made this about 6 times now in my Instant Pot so I wanted to report back what I’ve found! I follow Erin’s directions for the Instant Pot and do high pressure for 35 minutes once my chicken and rice are in. ONE thing I change is that I only use 3 cups of chicken broth, since the instant pot loses no liquid in the process. That being said, I do like my soups “souper” (haha) thick, so keep that in mind. Wild rice is really not hard to find in the store, my neighborhood market Walmart carries it and they pretty much carry nothing speciality. Happy cooking!
Hooray! I’m glad you love the soup, Elaine. Thanks for reporting back! :)
I made this last night and I loved the flavor. I improvised on the spices since I didn’t have poultry spice. I did need to add quite a bit more stock. I just wish I had checked it before 6 hours since I think my chicken was overdone and wild rice exploded a little. But I will make it again. I would also make veggies bigger, add others, and leave out potatoes.
Bernadette, thanks for taking the time to review the recipe! It sounds like you know exactly what else to tweak next time!
This is great, and very easy.
My only criticism is the flour to butter ratio, which, as seems to be the case with others, didn’t work for me. Instead, 1/2 C butter to 1/2 C flour made a lovely base to which I added the warm milk.
Also, it is a very thick soup using only the 4 C stock, really more of a casserole than soup, so having 2 to 3 C of stock available to think the soup is a good idea.
Thanks for sharing your notes! I’m so glad you enjoyed it!
Perfect soup for a cold day in the Midwest!
So I attempted this recipe in an instant pot it tasted delicious but over cooked the rice and potatoes I cooked mine 30 mins should have only cooked it 20
Hi Morgan! I’m happy to hear that you enjoyed the flavors in this dish! Thank you for taking the time to try this recipe!
No my favorite sadly :( My chicken also came out chewy (I checked it and took it out early). the flour mixture also came out clumpy. I made it a second time putting the milk in verrryy slowly and still the same result.
Hi Kiki, I’m sorry to hear that you had trouble with this soup. Did you whisk the flour mixture well after pouring in the milk? Either way, I know it’s frustrating to try a recipe and not have it turn out, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
So it says 5-6 cups of stock, but you only say 4 cups in the directions….haven’t made it yet but I will use more.
Michele, if you keep reading the recipe, you’ll see that the remaining stock is added at the end, according to how thick you like the soup; you can add as much or as little as you like. I hope you enjoy it!
Very delicious, I recommend to any body to make it , plus I make the healthy turkey chili o my good is delicious , my family loved
I’m so happy that it was a hit, Sandra! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I found your site a few weeks ago, and have made several of your recipes- they’re all sooooo good!! My husband is kind of picky, but he LOVED THIS SOUP, and so did I. He also couldn’t stop raving about your Chicken Tikka Masala!!! So this week I’ll be trying the Butter Chicken. My father was from Mumbai, India, and we took him back there to see his family before he died. All my kids, and my husband, love Indian food, so I’m so glad to have a few recipes that are easy AND healthy!!! Thank you for all you do!!! You’re amazingly gifted!!
This comment MADE my day, Shera! Thank you for trying my recipes and sharing this kind review!
This was great!!! I used a combo of wild rice and brown rice, I seasoned and seared the chicken before throwing it in the pot and added mushies w the cream at the end. What a great soup and a great recipe. Very easy to follow!!
Note to those who skim read like me. I used all the stock up front. Should have used less for a creamier soup.
This was delish!!!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Gina! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
My whole family loves this soup! It is so satisfying and tasty, and of course healthy and easy! Thanks Erin! Your recipes never fail!
I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed it, Elizabeth! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
I am planning to cook my rice separately and add it at the end to avoid overcooking it, which has happened when I have cooked rice in the crock pot in the past. Should I adjust the chicken broth that is added to the chicken and veggies at the beginning if I do this?
Mandy, yes I’d suggest adding less broth. You can always add more at the end to thin it out if needed. I hope you enjoy it!
Hi, Erin.
Can I use the same recipe to make it on the stovetop? (I want it to be done more quickly than inthe slow cooker.) Thanks!
Hi Lynne! I’ve only tested this recipe in the slow cooker but it should work on the stovetop with some adjustments. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!
Can I sub almond milk for regular milk??
Hi Jenna! Yes you can substitute the milk with almond milk. You’ll see more of my substitution suggestions in the recipe notes at the end of the recipe card. Hope you enjoy it!
This soup was a great dinner tonight, to warm us up on a cold Canadian winter night. Thank you for the great recipe!! Soo good!
Hi Sheri! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I made this as a stovetop soup tonight and we all LOVED it. DELICIOUS!
So glad, yay!
Hi Marie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!