These potatoes were great! I made them on a night when the oven was in use for another dish and not a good temperature for baked potatoes. I made 6 large potatoes, which necessitated 2 layers, and it worked out fine. Thanks for a great recipe!
Could I cook the potatoes this way and then scrape them out and make mashed potatoes? You know add butter and milk and beat them? I’m no cook, so wasn’t sure if it would work?
Hello! Yes, you could make mashed potatoes that way, but if you do an internet search for crock pot mashed potatoes recipes, you’ll find some that might be a little easier and faster that won’t involve wrapping the potatoes in foil first!
Hi Tawni, I haven’t tried that but it’d be an experiment, and would possibly take less time if the potatoes are smaller than the ones I used. Another great crock pot red potato recipe are these breakfast potatoes! You could leave out the peppers, etc., if you’re looking for a more straightforward potato flavor.
Hi Patsy, I believe other readers have tried the recipe without foil and had success. I haven’t tried them this way myself, but you’re welcome to experiment.
Could you wrap the potatoes in parchment paper insteadof foil? I don’t use foil anymore since learning of the aluminum leaching into the food when heated. Do you think the cooking time would be the same?
Hi Sherry, I haven’t tried that myself, but it looks like other recipes on the internet suggest parchment paper, so you could probably give it a try! A few commenters have also mentioned that the recipe came out without wrapping the potatoes at all. If you do experiment, I’d love to hear how it comes out!
I’m going to try this tomorrow. I was planning on making potato soup on Sunday so I’ll try adding the chopped potatoes after the other veggies are cooked and maybe mash one up to thicken the soup. Years ago we had family living with us after they relocated to our area. It seemed like there was always a little bit of this and that left over after meals (I was cooking three meals a day for 7 people for 5 months). One night, after running out of ideas for dinner, I baked a bunch of potatoes and put all of the leftovers out for toppings. Taco meat, bacon, bbq chicken, a couple of kinds of shredded cheese, broccoli, chili, hard boiled eggs, sour cream – I had a PILE of dishes that night but the fridge was empty :) Everybody agreed it was a great meal idea!
Love this recipe and your website. Perfect amount of commentary, easy to understand recipe and a nice short and sweet video for those of us who appreciate seeing the process! Appreciate your hard work!
I found this recipe a few years ago and have been making them this way since. I have a extra large crockpot and I can do 10 easy. So great for summer meals too. I just put the crockpot outside on the patio so I don’t heat up the house. My kids eat the skin too because it’s so soft. I know potatoes covered in butter and cheese aren’t the healthiest but as a family of 6 dishes like this really help stretch our grocery budget.
I do not recommend this recipe. I have a new crockpot, and it cracked the crock. I had read other comments stating that this cracked older crocks, and assumed it would not do the same to a new one. I believe the lack of liquid is what causes this. Beware before making.
Oh no! I’m so sorry to hear that this happened, Laurel. I have not been able to duplicate this issue and am not sure what might’ve gone wrong. I’m very sorry you had trouble with this, and I know it can be frustrating, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
This is how we’ve done baked potatos for a while, and they turn out fantastic. One other secondary use for extra potatoes I didn’t see in the comments, and again breakfast… freeze them, and then shred them with a course box grater. Fry that up in some oil and this is how your local greasy spoon (or Dennys’) makes hashbrowns.
I used this recipe for an office party and I did not feel that the potatoes were as good as they are when baked in the oven, but worse than that, the high temperature coupled with only dry ingredients and no fluid in the crock pot caused my pot to crack.
I’m so sorry to hear that this happened, Tyson. I have not been able to duplicate this issue and am not sure what might’ve gone wrong. I’m very sorry you had trouble with this, and I know it can be frustrating, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
so happy I found this and it works! I had a slab of leftover short ribs done on the gril and didn’t get to the falling of the bone done. so I wanted to put them in my slow cooker to see if I could Finnish them last night but I didn’t want to just add them in water.. (i have never been a great cook). anyway I remembered seeing something on internet about doing potatoes in a slow cooker so I googled and found you.. only thing I forgot was to wipe the potatoes with the oil. but no matter they turned out great and by just laying my ribs on top of the potatoes works awesome. I did the 4 to 5 hrs on high and bones pulled right out!!
SUPPER DONE!! Thanks so much for sharing this recipe…..I am liking some of your other recipes as well.
These are nice recipes. I just bought a crock pot slow cooker . I am new at cooking meals but i am raring to go. I can follow instructions so i am ready to try your recipes.
These potatoes were great! I made them on a night when the oven was in use for another dish and not a good temperature for baked potatoes. I made 6 large potatoes, which necessitated 2 layers, and it worked out fine. Thanks for a great recipe!
Vivian, thanks for reporting back how it went with 2 layers of potatoes! I’m so glad the method is a winner for you!
Trying this right now. I rolled up a couple of foil sheets so the potatoes would not sit on the bottom and harden in that position. Hope it works.
Great idea Shirley! I’d love to hear how it goes.
Could I cook the potatoes this way and then scrape them out and make mashed potatoes? You know add butter and milk and beat them? I’m no cook, so wasn’t sure if it would work?
Hello! Yes, you could make mashed potatoes that way, but if you do an internet search for crock pot mashed potatoes recipes, you’ll find some that might be a little easier and faster that won’t involve wrapping the potatoes in foil first!
I would like to try this with medium red potatoes. What do you think?
Hi Tawni, I haven’t tried that but it’d be an experiment, and would possibly take less time if the potatoes are smaller than the ones I used. Another great crock pot red potato recipe are these breakfast potatoes! You could leave out the peppers, etc., if you’re looking for a more straightforward potato flavor.
Has anyone tried it without the foil?
Hi Patsy, I believe other readers have tried the recipe without foil and had success. I haven’t tried them this way myself, but you’re welcome to experiment.
Could you wrap the potatoes in parchment paper insteadof foil? I don’t use foil anymore since learning of the aluminum leaching into the food when heated. Do you think the cooking time would be the same?
Hi Sherry, I haven’t tried that myself, but it looks like other recipes on the internet suggest parchment paper, so you could probably give it a try! A few commenters have also mentioned that the recipe came out without wrapping the potatoes at all. If you do experiment, I’d love to hear how it comes out!
Absolutely PERFECT baked potatoes! I may never do them in the oven again. Thank you!
Hooray Catherine!!!!! So happy to hear it, thank you!
Glad I found this recipe! I followed the directions but was wondering if only cooking 2 potatoes does that make a less cooking time?
Hi Kim, I haven’t experimented with fewer potatoes, but you could check them a little earlier to see. I’m glad you found the recipe too!
I’m going to try this tomorrow. I was planning on making potato soup on Sunday so I’ll try adding the chopped potatoes after the other veggies are cooked and maybe mash one up to thicken the soup. Years ago we had family living with us after they relocated to our area. It seemed like there was always a little bit of this and that left over after meals (I was cooking three meals a day for 7 people for 5 months). One night, after running out of ideas for dinner, I baked a bunch of potatoes and put all of the leftovers out for toppings. Taco meat, bacon, bbq chicken, a couple of kinds of shredded cheese, broccoli, chili, hard boiled eggs, sour cream – I had a PILE of dishes that night but the fridge was empty :) Everybody agreed it was a great meal idea!
That does sound like a delicious meal, Jan! I hope you enjoy the potatoes.
You could try putting foil balls on the bottom of the pot. This keeps the potatoes from touching the bottom which does make them hard.
Thanks for the tip, Stacey!
Love this recipe and your website. Perfect amount of commentary, easy to understand recipe and a nice short and sweet video for those of us who appreciate seeing the process! Appreciate your hard work!
Ann, this is so kind—thank you so much! It makes my day to hear you enjoy my recipes and site too.
Delicious!! Can’t wait to try! ?
I hope you enjoy it, Dina!
I found this recipe a few years ago and have been making them this way since. I have a extra large crockpot and I can do 10 easy. So great for summer meals too. I just put the crockpot outside on the patio so I don’t heat up the house. My kids eat the skin too because it’s so soft. I know potatoes covered in butter and cheese aren’t the healthiest but as a family of 6 dishes like this really help stretch our grocery budget.
Thank you for sharing this kind review! I’m so happy this recipe has been a hit!
I do not recommend this recipe. I have a new crockpot, and it cracked the crock. I had read other comments stating that this cracked older crocks, and assumed it would not do the same to a new one. I believe the lack of liquid is what causes this. Beware before making.
Oh no! I’m so sorry to hear that this happened, Laurel. I have not been able to duplicate this issue and am not sure what might’ve gone wrong. I’m very sorry you had trouble with this, and I know it can be frustrating, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
This is how we’ve done baked potatos for a while, and they turn out fantastic. One other secondary use for extra potatoes I didn’t see in the comments, and again breakfast… freeze them, and then shred them with a course box grater. Fry that up in some oil and this is how your local greasy spoon (or Dennys’) makes hashbrowns.
Thank you for sharing this kind review and your tips, Jay! I’m happy to hear that you’ve enjoyed this recipe!
I used this recipe for an office party and I did not feel that the potatoes were as good as they are when baked in the oven, but worse than that, the high temperature coupled with only dry ingredients and no fluid in the crock pot caused my pot to crack.
I’m so sorry to hear that this happened, Tyson. I have not been able to duplicate this issue and am not sure what might’ve gone wrong. I’m very sorry you had trouble with this, and I know it can be frustrating, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it!
so happy I found this and it works! I had a slab of leftover short ribs done on the gril and didn’t get to the falling of the bone done. so I wanted to put them in my slow cooker to see if I could Finnish them last night but I didn’t want to just add them in water.. (i have never been a great cook). anyway I remembered seeing something on internet about doing potatoes in a slow cooker so I googled and found you.. only thing I forgot was to wipe the potatoes with the oil. but no matter they turned out great and by just laying my ribs on top of the potatoes works awesome. I did the 4 to 5 hrs on high and bones pulled right out!!
SUPPER DONE!! Thanks so much for sharing this recipe…..I am liking some of your other recipes as well.
YAY! Thank you for sharing this kind review, Sissie! I’m so happy to hear that this recipe was a hit!
Going to save this recipe under my party bookmarks to try it soon!
I hope you enjoy the recipe if you try it!
These turn out perfect every time.
Thank you for sharing this kind review, Camille! I’m so happy that you’ve enjoyed the recipe!
These are nice recipes. I just bought a crock pot slow cooker . I am new at cooking meals but i am raring to go. I can follow instructions so i am ready to try your recipes.
I hope you enjoy the recipes you try, Lorenzo!