• Followed and read everything but still come out with so much liquid. Not sure what magic you have up your sleeve to have them finished in the crockpot “crisp”. They were absolutely tasty and headache free though. So I guess a win.3 stars

    1. I am sorry to hear you had this experience! What kind of potato did you use? Regardless, I know it is disappointing to try a new recipe and not have it come out, so I wish you would have loved it. I hope you were able to enjoy them in the end. They will not be crispy as you would get on the stove or oven. If super duper crispness is important, I’d suggest using the stove or oven instead. In this case, the ease of the crockpot was worth a less crisp outside to me, but the end result is up to you!

        1. Hi Tracey, I’ve not tested this in the oven. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

          1
          1. Question please: I’d like to double the recipe. If I omit both the peppers and onion, should I reduce some of the seasonings? Also, since I’ll be cooking 6 pounds of red potatoes, should I increase the cooking time? I’m hoping to name it this Sunday 5/14/23. Thank you! – Charity Silva

      1. I drained them and put them on a sheet pan under the broiler until they were desired crispness, just like 4-5 minutes. Everyone raved on them. They were very tasty

        1
    1. Hi Linda. I’ve only tested the recipe as written so I am not sure. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

    1. I’m sorry you’ve did not enjoy the recipe, Linda. I (and many other readers) have made this recipe with success, so I wish it would of been a success for you. I know it’s disappointing to have a recipe not come through for you, so I really wish you would’ve enjoyed it.

    1. Hi Ashley, I’ve only tested the recipe as written so it would be hard to say. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

  • I made these last year for our Christmas breakfast so am thrilled that I can share these great potatoes again. But we do have our breakfast at 10:00 a.m. so I didn’t really enjoy waking up so early to get everything chopped to be able to get it cooked for 3 hours on high (which I do a little longer since I use more than 3 pounds of potatoes). Can I make the night before and keep refrigerated in the crockpot?5 stars

    1. Hi Terri! I think the best idea might be to make them the day before, then reheat them in the morning in the oven. From there, you can transfer them to the slow cooker to keep them warm if needed. I hope you enjoy the recipe!

  • Not sure where the confusion is coming from. The recipe says crisp not crispy which is two different textures. A pepper is crisp when you bite into it so this makes sense that as long as you cook it properly the potatoes and peppers won’t be mushy but have a crisp texture. That is exactly what we got from this. It was a delicious dish and perfect for my brunch potluck. I added jalapeños and used wood fired smoked seasoning in place of seasoning salt and paprika. There are so many different ways to customize this and still have it come out perfect and easy. Would make again.5 stars

  • My friend made these for brunch and holy cow they were delicious! She added some sliced sausages too, but the potatoes were the star! Thanks!5 stars

  • This recipe sounds perfect for my Easter dinner. I just bought yukon gold potatoes. Can I use yukon instead of red potatoes?

    thank you

    1
    1. Hi Kathy! I think yukon might work, I just haven’t tested it myself. If you decide to experiment, I’d love to know how it turns out!

  • WHEN I FIRST WENT OVER THE RECIPE, I KNEW THE POTATOES WOULD NOT BE CRISPY. I DID USE THE BABY REDS, BUT FIGURED THE PEPPERS WOULD CREATE A LOT OF LIQUID IN THE CROCK POT. EVEN SO… THE POTATOES WERE TOTALLY YUMMY, ONCE I DRAINED OFF THE LIQUID. THEY FREEZE WELL.4 stars

  • I loved these potatoes…..was a huge hit in my group. However, after 4 hours mine were not done. I cut these smaller for that reason…. WHEN i do again, and I will,I will par boil them for a few min to help the process or do the longer cooking time if it fits my schedule. These flavor was wonderful and tomorrow the remaining will be served with beef.5 stars

  • Not at all as described. Not at all crispy.
    I had to drain moisture, transfer the hot potatoes to a baking sheet and put them under the broiler to get rid of the some of the moisture.
    Followed your recipe exactly.
    Never have responded like this, but this is ridiculous.

    1. I’m sorry to hear you had trouble with the recipe, Jean. I know it can be so disappointing to try a new recipe and it does not turn out for you. It has worked well for myself (and others) and I wished it would have been a hit for you too. It’s really hard for me to know what went wrong without being in the kitchen with you.

  • I am confused. Several times in the article it says ‘overnight breakfast potatoes’, but the recipe says cook for four hours in the crockpot. ??

    1. Greg, I’m sorry for the confusion, the recipe is correct. If you wanted, you could prep them the night before, refrigerate the crockpot insert, then pop it into the slow cooker in the morning.

  • I’m making these this morning. It’s 6AM on Christmas Eve and just now have them in the crock. We’re having brunch. I have some of our hometown German sausage cooked up and am going to try it in there!

    1. Glad you enjoyed the flavor Lynn! They will not be crispy as you would get on the stove or oven. If super duper crispness is important, I’d suggest using the stove or oven instead. In this case, the ease of the crockpot was worth a less crisp outside to me, but the end result is up to you!

      1
    1. I’m sorry to hear that, Laura. Anything in particular that was horrible? Potatoes are normally really easy to make in the slow cooker.

      1
  • Sounds like you’re working on a new cookbook. I just wanted to know more, like when it’s coming out, is it a particular type of cookbook, etc. I’m really excited because I make so many of your recipes and love them all!

    1. Hi Bunny! Yes! Cookbook #2 will be out Fall 2024. We’ll keep our readers updated through emails and on social media when pre-orders open. THANK YOU!

  • Wonderful, I had crockpot set for 5 hours were done in 4. Huge hit with our group. It’s a keeper just as it is.
    Sara5 stars

  • These potatoes were not crispy but they were delicious and perfect for freeing up the oven for other dishes. There was some liquid in the bottom of the dish but I just left it there when transferring to serving dish.5 stars

  • Trying these easy crock potatoes today for pur Easter Sunday brunch. Prep was a cinch. I will post a review later to tell u about taste and what everyone thought.