• Fourth time making this and finally leaving a review. PERFECT. So easy and seriously the best I’ve ever had!5 stars

    1. Hi Emily, it doesn’t always work to directly double an IP recipe, but if you’re feeling up for an experiment, you could start with 1.5 times the amount. I hope you enjoy!

  • Thank you for making my Thanksgiving prep. So much easier. Doing mashed potatoes in the instantpot has made mashed potatoes for 30 so much easier! 5 stars

  • I made this recipe in my new Instant Pot – it was a huge hit! I added one finely chopped and sautéed leek and cut down on the chives. Such a great companion for roast turkey!! I will never go back to making regular mashed potatoes.5 stars

    1. Hi Joann, I haven’t tried halving this recipe, so you may be able to cut a minute or so off the cooking time, but I can only vouch for the amount and timing as written. If you give it a try, I’d love to hear how it goes.

      1. Thanks for your answer. I did try to halve it—used the same cooking time snd it came out perfect! Easiest whipped potatoes I’ve ever made ! Thanks 5 stars

  • Made this as a side for Erin’s Baked Chicken Parmesan and it tied our meal together perfectly! My boyfriend is not a huge fan of mashed potatoes, but he scarfed this down and begged me to make this a regular in our house. Had leftovers the next day and they tasted even better.5 stars

    1. Thank you for sharing your wonderful successes, Marielle! I’m so pleased that you all enjoyed both of these recipes!

    1. Hi Sharon! There are specifically designed steamer baskets that can be inserted into your Instant Pot to help steam your food (like these potatoes) just like you would when steaming vegetables on the stove. I hope this helps!

        1. Hi Kristin! The insert is important here, I’m afraid. It keeps the potatoes from soaking up too much of the water, so I definitely recommend using it.

  • Hi!!! Not a fan of yogurt can I use something else? Like sour cream or cream cheese? If yes how many cups? thank you so much!!!

    1. Hi Amanda! I don’t think you can taste the yogurt at all, but if you are nervous you swap in sour cream. I hope you love the recipe!

  • EXCELLENT recipe. I did not have chives so I omitted. I added a touch of garlic powder (meant to add fresh garlic but dinner was ready and it smelled sooooo good so we needed to eat NOW). I completely forgot to salt the water in the beginning but it turned out perfect. I also left most of the skin on the potatoes cause that’s how we roll. ;-)
    Thanks for the great recipe!!5 stars

    1. Hi Jen! I haven’t tried doubling the recipe myself, so I don’t have any specific advice to offer. If you decide to play around with it, I’d love to hear how it goes!

  • Hey Erin! would it be possible to make this in a slow cooker? If so, what would you recommend for adjusting the time? Thanks in advance!

    1. Hi Sierra! I haven’t tested the recipe this way, so I can’t say for certain. However, I do have stovetop instructions listed in the blog post. I hope this helps!

  • I was already a big fan of Instant pot mashed potatoes as it is my go to method of cooking this side dish. This recipe just elevated my love for mashed potatoes in general! Where do I start? Well I can tell you that if one of Erin’s recipes does not have Greek yogurt I’m a wee bit disappointed! (Kidding… sort of!). These were healthier, tastier, creamier than any mashed potatoes I’ve ever eaten (did I mention I love mashed potatoes???). Six stars if I could!!!5 stars

  • Loved them! I’m the one person that’s never been able to cook mashed potatoes well. They never taste right. I think in hindsight I just wasn’t cooking the potatoes long enough. I did 9 minutes in the instant pot instead of 8. I used 3/4 cups of sour cream instead of the cup of Greek yogurt. Next time I’ll add a little milk so it’s not quite so dense. But loved it. All I did was mash it and it turned out very smooth.5 stars

  • Love the recipe! First time I made it without steamer basket they were the BEST mashed potatoes I’ve ever eaten! Then I used the steamer basket and as soon as I added the melted butter they turned to glue :( I started using russets to counter this. But gold is so much better and creamier.. almost every time I use gold they turn to a glue consistency!! I wonder what am I doing wrong??5 stars

    1. I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe the first time, Ashley! I’m sorry you’ve had trouble with the Yukon Gold potatoes. It sounds like the potatoes might have been overworked, causing them to release starches and become gummy. I hope this helps!

    1. Hi Sheri! I think fresh herbs are worth it here, but in a pinch the general rule of thumb is to use 1/3 the amount of dried as fresh.