• I made these for dinner tonight. They are currently in the crock pot on warm, but I had to steal one before dinner. They are amazing and so moist! The flavor is great.5 stars

    1
    1. HOORAY Amy! I’m glad to hear you enjoyed the meatballs! Thanks so much for taking the time to leave this review.

    1. Hi Bridget, I have not tried these in the Instant Pot myself, but if you decide to experiment, I’d recommend following the cooking time guidelines for a similar Instant Pot meatball recipe when you get to step 4.

  • My family loves these meatballs! And I love that I get to change up our protein source from the usual chicken and beef. We pair it with spaghetti squash to cut some of the carbs and mm mmm yummy!! Thank you!5 stars

  • I have made this recipe several times in the last few month and my family absolutely LOVES it!!! It’s nice to get the majority of the dinner work done early in the day so that there’s not much to do during the “witching hour” before dinner with my kids. ;)5 stars

  • My boyfriend LOVED these meatballs. We weren’t in a rush, so I cooked them on low for 4 hours. They were very flavorful and moist. We froze the leftovers to eat at a later date and they reheated very well! Paired this with zucchini noodles and garlic bread. Simply amazing.5 stars

  • I haven’t actually tried cooking these yet but I was wondering if you had any suggestions for lowering the sodium? 234mg per meatball can really stack up!

    1. Hi Andrew! Sodium content can vary so much based on the brands of ingredients used. I recommend using an online calculator like MyFitnessPal, which you can customize based on the ingredients you have to get a more accurate number. For this recipe, you could try experimenting by cutting out the salt to lower the amount of sodium. I hope this helps!

  • I love this recipe so much! My whole family will eat it, it’s healthy, and it makes enough that we can still enjoy leftovers the next day! Plus, I can get it all ready during the day while my family is at work and school. I usually just serve with pasta and a salad.5 stars

  • Erin I am sorry that I have never commented or left a rating before now because I make your recipes multiple times a week and love almost all of them, however I need a new word to describe how wonderful these meatballs are!! I used a pound of ground turkey and a pound of pork sausage because that’s what I could find but followed everything else exactly.  I also only browned one tray at a time in the oven since mine were only getting crispy on the bottom rack.  They were so tender and flavorful that my husband was still raving about them later that night!  Thank you for all of your wonderful healthy recipes, I am a huge fan and can’t wait for your cookbook to come out!5 stars

    1. This makes my day, Kristin! Thank you for taking the time to share this kind review! I’m so happy you enjoyed the recipe!

  • Have you tried skipping the oven step and going straight to crockpot? Looking to try these but also want to make it a little shorter on prep time.

    1. Hi Schuyler! I have only tested the recipe as written, so you’d be experimenting. The meatballs won’t get as brown on the outside, and I suggest checking them for doneness before serving. I hope you enjoy the recipe!

    2. Hi there,
      I haven’t done it with this particular recipe but I have done what you’re asking with another meatball recipe. You can make the recipe without browning the meatballs first, but they turn out mussy and bland/not flavourful. Do yourself a favour and brown them, I know it’s an extra step but you’re not doing the meatballs and your self justice by skipping the step, you’ll just get mediocre meatballs, when you could have awesome ones.

      1
    1. Hi Kristin! I haven’t tried to double the recipe before. A few things to keep in mind, the size of your crockpot would determine if you could get that many meatballs in it. Also you would definitely want to check the cooking time to make sure the meatballs are cooked through and reach an internal temperature of 160 degrees F. If you decide to experiment, let me know how it goes!

  • Gluten free household by necessity so I subbed almond flour and extra seasonings for the breadcrumbs…the mix was a sticky mess but the cooked meatballs were DELICIOUS!5 stars

    1. Hi Jess! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review and thanks for the feedback on using almond flour!

  • The crockpot turkey meatballs are excellent! Tender and moist…DELICIOUS! Every recipe I have made from Erin is a hit!5 stars

  • Wow these were so good!!! I added half a box of orzo directly to the bottom of the slow cooker, underneath the meatballs and cooked everything on low for 4 hours. The orzo was cooked by the sauce and tasted so great. We had broccolini on the side.5 stars

  • I made this with 1lb of ground turkey and 1 lb of mild italian sausage (ground, not links). Sausage is typically high in sodium, and other ingredients have sodium, such as pasta sauce, bread crumbs and cheese, so I left out all of the kosher salt. IMO, the meatballs, which are delicious, have enough saltiness. I used freshly grated combo parmasan/reggiano cheese, no parsley, and eneded up with more than 40 good sized meatballs, so enough to freeze and use for another 2-3 meals for our small household of 2. This is a keeper recipe. So good!5 stars

  • These came out FANTASTIC! I made them for a potluck the day before, and refrigerated them overnight in an airtight container. The next morning, I warmed them up on the stovetop and then put them back into the slow cooker to keep warm. When it was time to go to the potluck, I unplugged the slow cooker and put it in the back seat of my car. At the potluck, there were power strips available, so I plugged it in, and the meatballs were a big hit.

    There were some leftovers, and I brought them home for my husband. He put them with some pasta and pronounced them “sublime.”

    Notes: I could only find a 1 lb package of ground turkey, and the turkey sausage was 20 oz, so I had about 4oz more meat than you did. Surprisingly, I ended up with 60 meatballs, and they were 1-1/2 inch (I measured!). Not sure how that happened, but it all worked out. Also, I used the Silver Palate Basil sauce, which was super yummy for a jarred sauce.

    I will definitely make these again!5 stars

  • I made this recipe omitting the sausage the first time; it was delicious . Unfortunately, my hubby grabbed cooked Italian sausage for the 2nd try 😢. I have a feeling it’s not going to turn out right. It would be nice if the recipe specific uncooked sweet Italian sausage since so much of it is precooked.4 stars

    1. Hi RMT, I’m glad you enjoyed it the first time. I’m a little confused, we are cooking the meatballs in the crockpot, so we can not be adding already cooked sausage to the meat mixture, I feel like that is understood. If for some reason the sausage needed to be cooked prior, then that part would be specified in the recipe. Keeping the meats uncooked prior to making a meatball is pretty standard. Personally I haven’t seen cooked Italian turkey sausage (which is what we are using here in this recipe).

  • My family absolutely loves these turkey meatballs. Four hours in the slow cooker after browning them in the oven makes for juicy meatballs . We follow the directions exactly, every time, and we have a delicious dinner:5 stars

  • Hi, I was wondering, is there a way to make these meatballs only in the oven? And if so, how long do I bake and at what degrees? Thank you.

    1
  • Hi! Can you clarify what this is: “sweet Italian turkey sausage”. Do you take a turkey breakfast sausage and break it up into small pieces? Maybe you have a picture of it you can share?

    Thanks!