Hi Erin – do you think these would fare well if prepped ahead of time and then just warmed in the oven? These would be awesome for an upcoming party, but I don’t think I could pull these off without making ahead.
Alice, while I think you could do 90% of the prep work ahead (caramelizing the onions, slicing the cheese, spreading the buns), I would wait to grill and slice the steak until as close to the party as you can (and then leave it at room temperature). Personally, I haven’t had a ton of luck reheating steak from cold without it drying out. I think if you leave the steak at room temperature, then bake the sandwiches just before serving, you’ll be good to go. I hope that helps!
Hi Alice, It’s been a while, so I honestly can’t remember—either Sendick’s or Pick N Save. They were sold as French dinner rolls, but I sliced them in half. Trader Joe’s has some great bun options too!
I made these sandwiches when my husband hosted poker last year. It is his turn to host again this year and wants me to make them again. They are a little bit of work, but so worth it! Thanks for all the great ideas and recipes here!
These were delicious and so easy to make. I prepped everything in the afternoon and threw it together at dinner time. I didn’t have fig jam. I substituted bacon jam. Awesome. Definitely a keeper.
This recipe is a huge hit!! I use fresh sliced Italian bread like Pugliese and butter toast them with parmesan on a skillet. I add a truffle aioli as well for more umami, but this recipe is awesome!
If I could rate this 10 stars I would!! I used left over flank steak for the steak. We barely rewarmed it before adding to sandwiches. We ate this with cinnamon maple butternut squash!!!! Will definitely make it again!!!
I’m about to make these delicious looking sandwiches, but I’m concerned. After cooking the steaks to medium rare, what happens to them when you cook them for an additional 15 minutes at 350? Won’t the meat be overcooked. I thought of placing the brie on the roll, melting it under the broiler and continuing to assemble the sandwich. What are your thoughts?
Hi Bob! You’ll cook these to just rare, not medium rare. Also the meat won’t be overcooked, it will likely be above medium. You could definitely do that with your sandwich if you’d like to meat to stay medium rare. Hope you enjoy it!
I made these with leftover prime steak from Christmas, and I used what I had: Brioche buns and Havarti. I had Dijon, arugala, onions, and fig jam. Holy smokes! This made my leftovers taste like we ordered DoorDash from a local restaurant. My tiny 17-year old who eats nothing said, “That was really good. I mean really good. I could eat another one!”
Great recipe. Used spinach for leaves (not too many as they hold a lot of water that’s released when they wilt in the oven), substituted brie for cheddar as had that in the fridge. Worked really well in Ciabatta.
This was fantastic! used leftover grilled London broil. Toasted the inside of the bread with olive oil, s&p, then added the toppings, closed the sandwich and brushed the tip of the bread with butter s & p. Also added Mayo since my bread was very dense. So delicious! Much easier than the version I had been making with an au jus. Yum!
I made this with a couple of changes. We had leftover Teres Major steak so I put it in the sous vide to reheat to keep the medium rare doneness. I did not add the Dijon to the onions – a personal preference. Fresh spinach was what I had so I subbed for the arugula. The jam was a fig/ honey, which was a delightful taste. The Brie was spreadable so melted nicely. I used a mini whole grain baguette (just two of us).It was an excellent sandwich and will be a repeat next time we have left over steak. Thank you Erin.
I just made this recipe for a few friends last night, and wow, was it delicious! My friends said it was restaurant quality and I agree! Thank you—It was a spectacular success!
I wasn’t sure if Brie and steak would go together but it’s actually really good. The flavors kind of balance each other out, and the onions make it even better. It felt a little fancy but not hard to make. I’d definitely do this again. Thanks
Hi Erin – do you think these would fare well if prepped ahead of time and then just warmed in the oven? These would be awesome for an upcoming party, but I don’t think I could pull these off without making ahead.
Alice, while I think you could do 90% of the prep work ahead (caramelizing the onions, slicing the cheese, spreading the buns), I would wait to grill and slice the steak until as close to the party as you can (and then leave it at room temperature). Personally, I haven’t had a ton of luck reheating steak from cold without it drying out. I think if you leave the steak at room temperature, then bake the sandwiches just before serving, you’ll be good to go. I hope that helps!
Thank you!!
Also… where did you get those beautiful rolls? I’m in the MKE area, so I figured it’s worth asking :)
Hi Alice, It’s been a while, so I honestly can’t remember—either Sendick’s or Pick N Save. They were sold as French dinner rolls, but I sliced them in half. Trader Joe’s has some great bun options too!
Made these on a whim and they were amazing! Great recipe!
YAY!! I’m so excited to hear that Lora! Thanks for trying the recipe and letting me know how it turned out for you.
An amazing sandwich that has become a family favorite! We love the fig/Brie combo. Thanks
That’s awesome to hear, Jan! I’m so glad it’s a favorite…fig and brie is a favorite combo of mine too! Thanks for taking the time to report back!
I made these sandwiches when my husband hosted poker last year. It is his turn to host again this year and wants me to make them again. They are a little bit of work, but so worth it! Thanks for all the great ideas and recipes here!
Debbie, I’m so glad the recipe was enjoyed and is starting to become a tradition! Thanks so much for taking the time to leave this nice review!
Made these for my family when they flew out to visit, hands down one of my favorite lunches i’ve made!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Karlie! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
These were delicious and so easy to make. I prepped everything in the afternoon and threw it together at dinner time. I didn’t have fig jam. I substituted bacon jam. Awesome. Definitely a keeper.
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Sue! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
These were perfect. Like so many of your other recipes, I only attempt complex flavours and textures like this when it comes from you. Thank you!
I’m so happy that you enjoyed the recipe, Sue! Thank you for sharing this kind review!
This recipe is a huge hit!! I use fresh sliced Italian bread like Pugliese and butter toast them with parmesan on a skillet. I add a truffle aioli as well for more umami, but this recipe is awesome!
Hi Adam! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
If I could rate this 10 stars I would!! I used left over flank steak for the steak. We barely rewarmed it before adding to sandwiches. We ate this with cinnamon maple butternut squash!!!! Will definitely make it again!!!
Hi Kimberly! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
Erin,
I’m about to make these delicious looking sandwiches, but I’m concerned. After cooking the steaks to medium rare, what happens to them when you cook them for an additional 15 minutes at 350? Won’t the meat be overcooked. I thought of placing the brie on the roll, melting it under the broiler and continuing to assemble the sandwich. What are your thoughts?
Bob
Hi Bob! You’ll cook these to just rare, not medium rare. Also the meat won’t be overcooked, it will likely be above medium. You could definitely do that with your sandwich if you’d like to meat to stay medium rare. Hope you enjoy it!
Erin, making this for Christmas! What sides do you suggest? Thank you!
Hi Carolyn! Any one of these would be great! https://www.wellplated.com/sweet-potato-fries/ or https://www.wellplated.com/air-fryer-potato-chips/ or https://www.wellplated.com/oven-roasted-brussels-sprouts/
I made these with leftover prime steak from Christmas, and I used what I had: Brioche buns and Havarti. I had Dijon, arugala, onions, and fig jam. Holy smokes! This made my leftovers taste like we ordered DoorDash from a local restaurant. My tiny 17-year old who eats nothing said, “That was really good. I mean really good. I could eat another one!”
Hi Julie! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
We love your recipes!! This was my husband’s favorite. 99% of our meals are from Well Plated!!
Makes me so happy! Thank you Lindsay!
Great recipe. Used spinach for leaves (not too many as they hold a lot of water that’s released when they wilt in the oven), substituted brie for cheddar as had that in the fridge. Worked really well in Ciabatta.
Hi Stephen! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
This was fantastic! used leftover grilled London broil. Toasted the inside of the bread with olive oil, s&p, then added the toppings, closed the sandwich and brushed the tip of the bread with butter s & p. Also added Mayo since my bread was very dense. So delicious! Much easier than the version I had been making with an au jus. Yum!
Hi Nathalia! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
made this with some leftover steak and a mini baguette. It was delicious, especially the caramelized onions with the dijon.
Awesome, thanks Tulip!!
I made this with a couple of changes. We had leftover Teres Major steak so I put it in the sous vide to reheat to keep the medium rare doneness. I did not add the Dijon to the onions – a personal preference. Fresh spinach was what I had so I subbed for the arugula. The jam was a fig/ honey, which was a delightful taste. The Brie was spreadable so melted nicely. I used a mini whole grain baguette (just two of us).It was an excellent sandwich and will be a repeat next time we have left over steak. Thank you Erin.
Sounds tasty! Thanks, Judy!
This is the most tastes like I am at a restaurant recipe I have ever made.
It’s crave-able! I use leftover steak, and this recipe always makes it tastes not like leftovers!
Yay! Thank you Julie!
I just made this recipe for a few friends last night, and wow, was it delicious! My friends said it was restaurant quality and I agree! Thank you—It was a spectacular success!
Great to hear, thank you Rose!
I wasn’t sure if Brie and steak would go together but it’s actually really good. The flavors kind of balance each other out, and the onions make it even better. It felt a little fancy but not hard to make. I’d definitely do this again. Thanks
Glad to hear you enjoyed it, Alyson! Thank you!