Hello this will be my first time brining a turkey, I usually just buy store bought typically butterball turkey which I believe are usually pre-brined I think do you think this matters or no? Also I plan on getting one that’s larger then what the recipe calls for what would you recommend? Thank you!
Hi Whitnie! If using a pre-brined, I still recommend brining but reduce the amount of salt. If your bird is smaller than 14 pounds or larger than 16 pounds, follow these guidelines: For every 5 pounds of turkey, use 1 tablespoon kosher salt, 1 ½ to 2- teaspoons fresh herbs, the zest of ½ a small lemon, and ¼ teaspoon black pepper. Hope this helps!
Looking forward to trying this! I need to feed 16 and I want leftovers so I think I will do 2 turkeys approx 14 lb each. Sometimes really big turnkeys are hard to deal with. Do you think it would work to cook one the day before and one the day of? If so, how do you recommend I reheat the turkey from the day before? Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Hi Shelly! Two turkeys sounds good. It’s typically 1 1/2 pounds to 2 pounds per person if wanting leftovers. Timing wise, you’ll have to do whatever works best for you to manage. For reheating and storage tips we’ve listed them here in this post: https://www.wellplated.com/thanksgiving-leftover-recipes/ Hope it all goes welL!
Hi Sara! In a nutshell there are two parts, dry brining for 24 hours covered (up to 48 hours) and then uncovering for 24 hours to let the skin dry out. You can skip the second part, but highly recommend it!
I’ve never brined a turkey before, but I want to try your recipe because of the great reviews. We put our 22-pound frozen turkey in the fridge to thaw on Monday the 17th. Chat GPT suggested starting the dry brine last night or this morning (11/24) since it should be thawed by now. Since neither of us has cooked a turkey before, we’re double-checking everything. Do you agree that we should start the brine this morning rather than Tues-Wed.? Thank you!
Hi Karen, I have the details specifically spelled out here in the post and recipe. You can start up to 48 hours from when you want to cook it, but as close as 24 hours. Hope this helps!
I’ve never dry brined a bird before but for sake of fridge space am planning to do it this year. I have a 23 pound bird. I’m nervous to not brush off the brine but will obeyt because of the high ratings of this recipe LOL. My question – to baste with butter or not to baste? Thanks so much!
Hi Diane! Hope you enjoy the use of the brine, I would not spend time basting. Here are my tips and trick on the turkey once you have brined it: https://www.wellplated.com/how-to-cook-a-turkey/ Enjoy!
Two questions: Would using a grey sea salt result in a saltier taste? Also I was surprised to see that the brine/herb mixture isn’t rubbed under the skin of the turkey breast, additionally. Can I do this, or do you advise atop the skin of the turkey only? Thank you in advance, and Happy Thanksgiving!
I made this recipe for our small Friendsgiving dinner. The flavor was great and not too salty, just enough to taste seasoned all the way through. The skin came out nice and crispy too. Will definitely do this again next year.
My turkey is
“butterball fresh all natural premium whole young turkey”
It says – contains upto 4% of a solution of water, salt, spices for tenderness and juiciness
I’m trying a dry brine for the first time for this Thursday. I have a question about your directions. When you say to wrap tightly in plastic wrap do you mean only the turkey itself or the whole roasting pan with the turkey?
Hi Gloria, check out our step by step photos in the blog post! Step 3 shows us wrapping everything in the wrap just to make it a little easier! Thank you!
I tried this for the first time this Thanksgiving and it actually turned out way better than I expected. I was nervous because I’ve never done dry brine before, but it made the turkey so juicy. Even the breast part wasn’t dry, which never happens for me. Definitely doing this again next year.
I have a 14# fresh turkey, dry brined, followed directions carefully. I am now very concerned after 36 hours there is water/juices that have seeped out, not reabsorbed. I will use herbed butter under & on skin… what else can I do to keep moist?
Hi Marjorie! Definitely don’t stress, that’s totally normal. Herbed butter under the skin isn’t necessary but it is delicious, so go for it if you like. The biggest thing you need to do now is not overcook the turkey, and it will be plenty moist. I also like to tent the breast with foil about 90 min or so in (I leave the rest of the turkey uncovered). Happy Thanksgiving!
This recipe was a lifesaver! I didn’t have a ton of fridge space for a wet brine, so this dry brine was perfect. It made the turkey moist and flavorful without any weird saltiness. I was scared it would be too plain, but it wasn’t at all. My family already asked me to make it again for Christmas.
This was so delicious! Family said it was my best turkey yet! I did two turkey breast and adjusted recipe. Turned out perfect. Also, I purchased (and used) the ThermoPro digital meat thermometer you suggested and I love it.
My large family always has 2 turkeys, one fried and one in the oven (cooked by me). Everyone is polite and drowns mine in gravy but it’s always dry and I’m always making excuses because I’ve tried everything! Until yesterday. I used your dry brine recipe and it was delicious!! So many compliments. Thanks!
Hello this will be my first time brining a turkey, I usually just buy store bought typically butterball turkey which I believe are usually pre-brined I think do you think this matters or no? Also I plan on getting one that’s larger then what the recipe calls for what would you recommend? Thank you!
Hi Whitnie! If using a pre-brined, I still recommend brining but reduce the amount of salt. If your bird is smaller than 14 pounds or larger than 16 pounds, follow these guidelines: For every 5 pounds of turkey, use 1 tablespoon kosher salt, 1 ½ to 2- teaspoons fresh herbs, the zest of ½ a small lemon, and ¼ teaspoon black pepper. Hope this helps!
Looking forward to trying this! I need to feed 16 and I want leftovers so I think I will do 2 turkeys approx 14 lb each. Sometimes really big turnkeys are hard to deal with. Do you think it would work to cook one the day before and one the day of? If so, how do you recommend I reheat the turkey from the day before? Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Hi Shelly! Two turkeys sounds good. It’s typically 1 1/2 pounds to 2 pounds per person if wanting leftovers. Timing wise, you’ll have to do whatever works best for you to manage. For reheating and storage tips we’ve listed them here in this post: https://www.wellplated.com/thanksgiving-leftover-recipes/ Hope it all goes welL!
This worked exactly as written, thanks!
Thank you Elisha!
I have kosher turkey. Day before could I coat with rosemary and lemon zest (without the salt) to season?
Yes, that should work Heidi!
Hello! Can I just do the dry brine for 24 hours or do I have to do the part where it’s also wrapped for 24 -48 hours prior? Thank you
Hi Sara! In a nutshell there are two parts, dry brining for 24 hours covered (up to 48 hours) and then uncovering for 24 hours to let the skin dry out. You can skip the second part, but highly recommend it!
I’ve never brined a turkey before, but I want to try your recipe because of the great reviews. We put our 22-pound frozen turkey in the fridge to thaw on Monday the 17th. Chat GPT suggested starting the dry brine last night or this morning (11/24) since it should be thawed by now. Since neither of us has cooked a turkey before, we’re double-checking everything. Do you agree that we should start the brine this morning rather than Tues-Wed.? Thank you!
Hi Karen, I have the details specifically spelled out here in the post and recipe. You can start up to 48 hours from when you want to cook it, but as close as 24 hours. Hope this helps!
Does this same technique and recipie work for just turkey parts instead of whole turkey?
Yes!
I’ve never dry brined a bird before but for sake of fridge space am planning to do it this year. I have a 23 pound bird. I’m nervous to not brush off the brine but will obeyt because of the high ratings of this recipe LOL. My question – to baste with butter or not to baste? Thanks so much!
Hi Diane! Hope you enjoy the use of the brine, I would not spend time basting. Here are my tips and trick on the turkey once you have brined it: https://www.wellplated.com/how-to-cook-a-turkey/ Enjoy!
Two questions: Would using a grey sea salt result in a saltier taste? Also I was surprised to see that the brine/herb mixture isn’t rubbed under the skin of the turkey breast, additionally. Can I do this, or do you advise atop the skin of the turkey only? Thank you in advance, and Happy Thanksgiving!
Hi Jeni, I’d suggest using less salt if using grey sea salt. I would not advise to put it under the skin. Enjoy and let us know how it goes!
Just wondering why you include black pepper in the instructions for smaller/larger turkeys, but not in the original recipe?
Hi Carol! That was a typo, we will fix that! Thank you!
I made this recipe for our small Friendsgiving dinner. The flavor was great and not too salty, just enough to taste seasoned all the way through. The skin came out nice and crispy too. Will definitely do this again next year.
Yay! So glad too hear, Victoria! Thank you!
My turkey is
“butterball fresh all natural premium whole young turkey”
It says – contains upto 4% of a solution of water, salt, spices for tenderness and juiciness
Can I do the dry brine on this?
Hi Ninu, I would just reduce the salt to make sure the turkey is not too salty. Let me know how it goes!
Getting ready to brine right now! Planning on following the recipe but using the whole poultry bouquet. You made this soo easy!! Thank you!!
Makes me so happy to hear, thank you Jenn!
So far so good!
It’s looking great!!
I’m trying a dry brine for the first time for this Thursday. I have a question about your directions. When you say to wrap tightly in plastic wrap do you mean only the turkey itself or the whole roasting pan with the turkey?
Hi Gloria, check out our step by step photos in the blog post! Step 3 shows us wrapping everything in the wrap just to make it a little easier! Thank you!
I tried this for the first time this Thanksgiving and it actually turned out way better than I expected. I was nervous because I’ve never done dry brine before, but it made the turkey so juicy. Even the breast part wasn’t dry, which never happens for me. Definitely doing this again next year.
I have a 14# fresh turkey, dry brined, followed directions carefully. I am now very concerned after 36 hours there is water/juices that have seeped out, not reabsorbed. I will use herbed butter under & on skin… what else can I do to keep moist?
Hi Marjorie! Definitely don’t stress, that’s totally normal. Herbed butter under the skin isn’t necessary but it is delicious, so go for it if you like. The biggest thing you need to do now is not overcook the turkey, and it will be plenty moist. I also like to tent the breast with foil about 90 min or so in (I leave the rest of the turkey uncovered). Happy Thanksgiving!
This recipe was a lifesaver! I didn’t have a ton of fridge space for a wet brine, so this dry brine was perfect. It made the turkey moist and flavorful without any weird saltiness. I was scared it would be too plain, but it wasn’t at all. My family already asked me to make it again for Christmas.
Love to hear that, Aurelia! Thank you!
This was so delicious! Family said it was my best turkey yet! I did two turkey breast and adjusted recipe. Turned out perfect. Also, I purchased (and used) the ThermoPro digital meat thermometer you suggested and I love it.
Yay! So glad to hear, Alicia!
My large family always has 2 turkeys, one fried and one in the oven (cooked by me). Everyone is polite and drowns mine in gravy but it’s always dry and I’m always making excuses because I’ve tried everything! Until yesterday. I used your dry brine recipe and it was delicious!! So many compliments. Thanks!
This makes me so happy to hear, Gloria! Thank you and glad it was a hit!
What’s the temperature and how long to bake for please ?
Hi! You’ll find all baking instructions here: https://www.wellplated.com/how-to-cook-a-turkey/ Enjou!