I’ve eaten a lot of questionable things standing over my kitchen sink at 9 a.m. Until this creamy Pea Salad entered my life, I never imagined peas would be one of them.
Old fashioned pea salad is a Midwestern potluck/family reunion/parish cookbook stalwart.
These classic creamy pea salads of the past are made with bacon, a mayo-based dressing, and red onions. Some versions include cheese; others are made with ranch dressing.
If you can’t tell, we have a rather liberal definition of “salad” here in the Midwest ;-). Grape Salad would know.
For today’s recipe, I wanted a more modern take on the creamy pea salad with bacon that I grew up seeing at summer gatherings.
This is a healthy pea salad without mayo. The dressing uses yogurt and it features heart-healthy additions (like almonds!).
At the same time, it stays true to its roots and tastes like it belongs at a proper cookout. You can thank the bacon!
TIP!
If you love lighter versions of classic comfort foods, be sure to grab a copy of my cookbook! It has more than 1,750 5-star reviews and features lighter spins on beloved recipes like pasta salads, macaroni and cheese, casseroles, and more.
5 Star Review
“I made this last night, and it was a big hit. The bonus is I’ll have lunch for a few days too.”
— Jana —
How to Cook Pea Salad
This green pea salad turns a vegetable that would typically be filed under things my toddler won’t eat and turns it into a crowd-pleasing side that’s ideal for potlucks and barbecues.
The key to pea salad irresistibility is the toppings and dressing.
The ingredients are simple, but they work together to create something so yummy, I inhaled it directly out of my fridge.
The Ingredients
- Peas. Technically a legume (the same family as chickpeas and lentils), peas are high in fiber and nutrients. They are this spring and summertime salad’s star!
TIP!
While you can make fresh pea salad, I prefer to use frozen peas. They are just as nutritious as fresh peas and a complete time saver.
Since the peas are blanched before they are frozen, you do not need to cook them before adding them to the salad. Simply thaw them overnight in the refrigerator or run them under cool water to defrost.
- Chopped Roasted Almonds. They add warmth, crunch, and make the pea salad a pleasure to munch.
- Crispy Bacon. Pea salad with bacon is the way we do it here in the Midwest (Southern pea salad does the same).
- Greek Yogurt. My healthy stand-in for mayo. It has the same creaminess and tang as mayo or sour cream, but is low in calories and high in protein.
- Honey + Apple Cider Vinegar. Old fashioned pea salad dressing is usually made with white vinegar and sugar. I prefer the floral note of the honey and the subtle fruitiness of cider vinegar.
- Red Onions. Just the right bite and a pop of color.
Recipe Variations
- English Pea Salad. Add 2 to 3 diced hardboiled eggs.
- Sweet Pea Salad. Use baby peas or sweet peas, which are smaller and sweeter. These are my favorite!
- Southern Potato Salad. Add diced cheddar cheese, hard boiled eggs, and swap the red onion for green onion.
The Directions
- Cook the bacon, dice the red onion, and toast and chop the almonds.
- Stir together the dressing in a big bowl.
- Add everything to the bowl with the dressing and stir to combine. Refrigerate until ready to serve.
Storage Tips
- To Store. Refrigerate leftover pea salad for up to 4 days. Stir and taste for seasoning before serving.
- To Freeze. I do not recommend freezing pea salad. It will become mushy and the dressing will separate. (Don’t worry; you won’t have leftovers).
Meal Prep Tip
Roast the almonds up to 2 weeks in advance. Store at room temperature. Stir together the dressing 1 day in advance and refrigerate.
What to Serve with Pea Salad
Recommended Tools to Make this Recipe
- Chef’s Knife. A cook’s most precious tool. It makes chopping a breeze.
- Mixing Bowls. These are stackable for easy storage, and they work great for this recipe.
- Measuring Spoons. I love how easy these are to store and the double sides mean you can stop less to wash while cooking.
Stacking Mixing Bowls
With a size for every need, these are easy to store, dishwasher safe, and you can use them as a serving bowl too.
I leave you in peace with the peas, courtesy of pea salad!
Green Pea Salad with Bacon and Almonds
Ingredients
- 3 strips bacon cooked*
- 1/2 cup plain nonfat Greek yogurt
- 2 tablespoons honey
- 1 tablespoon apple cider vinegar
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 1/4 teaspoon black pepper
- 16 ounces shelled petite peas fresh or frozen and thawed
- 1/4 cup whole roasted almonds roughly chopped
- 1/2 small red onion finely chopped
Instructions
- If necessary, cook the bacon according to one of my easy methods listed below. Once cool, chop into small pieces and set aside.
- In a large mixing bowl, stir together the Greek yogurt, honey, apple cider vinegar, salt, and pepper. Add the peas, almonds, and red onion. Toss gently to coat. Serve chilled or at room temperature.
Video
Notes
- *Easy bacon cooking methods: Air Fryer Bacon and Oven Baked Bacon.
- TO STORE. Refrigerate leftover pea salad for up to 4 days. Stir and taste for seasoning before serving.
- TO FREEZE. I do not recommend freezing pea salad. It will become mushy and the dressing will separate. (Don’t worry; you won’t have leftovers).
Nutrition
Join today and start saving your favorite recipes
Create an account to easily save your favorite recipes and access FREE meal plans.
Sign Me UpRelated Recipes
Cheers to potluck salads! Here are a few of our favorites.
Pea lovers everywhere applaud you, Erin! I fall into the pea lover category, so set me up with a bowl and a spoon so I can dig into this goodness!
I think this would make me majorly crave some peas too! I love all the textures and flavors going on here and that creamy Greek yogurt dressing–genius!
First off: these photos?!?!! I’m so hungry!!
Second: I love peas. I haven’t made a pea salad in forever. I’m off to make one now :)
Peas are finally in season here and I am so excited!! Nothing beats fresh peas. Love this dressing!
This is a new esteemed category for peas!! Totally love the toppings and that dressing.
Dude, I love pea salads. And this salad is perfect for picnics! Love!
I love pea salad. And I love that you have bacon in there ;)
YES, love that you made something with green peas! They definitely don’t get enough love! I can rarely cook with them because both my mother and grandmother pick them out of their food like toddlers haha! Awesome that you didn’t use mayo here, greek yogurt is definitely a great substitute. Pinning this one, sounds like a must try! Thanks, girl! Happy Monday :)
What is not to love about this recipe? I am seriously making this this week.
It’s got Bacon. Peas. Almonds. All the winners are included. I especially like that red onion you added for “bite” as you phrased it.
Perfect for everyday or a picnic day. Lovely. Thanks for sharing!!
But now you’re getting me to seriously wonder why peas on not on the menu at restaurants? Will have to google that! Nothing beats fresh peas. Not the lunch lady high school cafeteria kind, the fresh, homegrown kind. You know which!
Oh, poor peas… they probably got picked last in kickball, too. They are totally the underdog of the veggie world. I’m glad you gave them this all star treatment! Pinning!
I’ve really started to love peas, but it wasn’t until the last year or so that my love affair with peas began. I never really ate them as a child and didn’t buy them as an adult, either. But since my hubby likes them, I decided to be more open where peas are concerned. ;) Love this recipe!
Thanks so much Madison! Your relationship with peas sounds like mine with beets. Our love was slow, but now it’s built to last a lifetime. Um, did I just compare vegetables to a significant other? Yes, yes I think I did.
I’ve been wanting to make a broccoli salad lately and I think this post just inspired me to try a similar lightened up dressing with that. Thanks for the inspiration!
I’m a big fan of peas but you are right about the toddler thing. I can’t get my little one to eat them or try them. Looks like I get this salad to myself.
Love sweet peas, even more than corn! This is my kind of meal, Erin.
Poor peas indeed. I like the little guys but I almost never cook with them. Until now! This salad looks so good! I love that you subbed out the mayo (mayo-phobe here, too). Definitely worthy of being a “kitchen sink” food. :)
i never liked peas until recently. with this dish i will like them even more :)
I am a weirdo who love peas, and this salad looks right up my alley! And a little bacon never hurt a salad’s cause, right? ;)
Erin: I love, love peas, red onions, and almonds; and fresh veggie salads.
Question: My hesitation with this recipe is that I am an “I love mayo” person (olive oil mayo); I really, really do not like Greek yogurt; that and cottage cheese are about the only dairy products I do not like. Can you or perhaps other readers suggest an adjustment(s) to the recipe to use mayo? If not, I will experiment with it myself, but thought I would ask all of the helpful people here. Thanks!
Hi Mary! Do you mind if I ask what it is about Greek yogurt you do not like? I know some people don’t care for the texture, but since it is similar to mayo, I’m guessing that’s not the issue. If it is the tart taste, the honey in the recipe really helps to mellow that. I don’t cook with mayo since I don’t care for it, but because its texture and consistency is similar to Greek yogurt, I think you should be fine with a one-to-one substitution. Again, I’ve never tried the recipe that way so I can’t personally vouch for it, but that is what makes the most sense to me. I hope that was a bit helpful(?).
Hi, Erin: Your comments are very helpful! Yes, my dislike is primarily due to the tart taste. Secondly, the Greek yogurt I have tried (I live near San Francisco, perhaps it is the brands available here) has been much thicker than traditional cow’s milk yogurt, and I did not care for the consistency. However, as you state that the honey offsets the tartness, that should help me. I’m going to try the recipe “as is”. If I don’t care for, I’ll try a direct substitution of mayo and see how that goes. Thanks again!
Mary, I’m so glad I could help! Greek yogurt is much thicker than traditional yogurt, and you will certainly find that with most brands you try. For that reason, you may never enjoy eating it with a spoon, but you might find you feel differently about cooking with it. Also, if you want to embrace your love of mayo and make the pea salad with that, I promise my feelings won’t be hurt :-) One idea to make sure that you don’t end up with a dish you don’t like is to make a scaled-down version of the Greek yogurt dressing, and just take a small taste to see what you think. Then if you like it, you can go big and pour it all over the whole dish. Thanks so much for giving the recipe a try, and I would love to hear what you think!
I used to hold my nose and fake death when my mother would force me to choke down peas as a child (I was a bit dramatic). Now, I actually kind of love them. So glad to see them getting some love! Pinning this one to my cookout board!
I’m the odd one who actually like peas a lot, note: I didn’t say love. But I do love the flavors in this salad. Perfect for Summer.
Another great way to get that smoky flavor for vegetarians would be (I am partial here) Penzey’s smoked Spanish paprika. I made deviled eggs once and used this and actually had a vegetarian ask if there was bacon in them.
Martha, smoked paprika is one of my all-time favorite spices, and Penzeys is one of the best places on earth! That is a great tip. Thanks for sharing!
Peas never looked better! Loving the lightened up dressing made with Greek yogurt – smart!
Wow, peas really never looked better! I’m not a huge fan of peas but once you throw bacon and almonds on it…i’m all over them!!! great dish!
Bacon and almonds for LIFE Julie. No veggie stands a chance ;-)
I love peas! We actually eat them all the time – my whole family (even the kids!) love them! :) But baby food peas are nasty. Just wrong.
I’m totally with you on the ‘No-thanks-I’ll-pass-on-the-mayo’ thing. But Greek yogurt … is there a shovel that I can use? Cause I love it!!!
I think my mom used to make a pea salad years and years ago, but I don’t remember ever actually eating it! I can’t wait to make this … pinning quick quick!!
I love peas, but never make them because I’m the only one who likes them. When my kids were little I made them all the time. Now they too reject those poor peas. This salad looks delicious and easy enough to prepare for one :D
Haha I actually love peas and so does my 3 year old so this salad is right up my alley: ) It looks fantastic and I love the flavors in here! Especially the greek yogurt dressing – yum!
Peas can be so amazing when they’re ‘done right’. I love them, particularly with goats cheese, mint or lemon. This combo looks DIVINE. I think the bacon alone would make my husband eat an entire bowlful! I love the idea of the crunch from the almonds and that gorgeous yoghurt dressing. Yum! x
So when I eat this BY THE HANDFUL…you won’t judge? K good. I actually think the.boy lived off of canned peas before I met him. Pretty sure these would put those to shame.
I am totally with you, I never think about green peas. Not my vegetable of choice, but this looks fantastic! I can’t wait to try it!
Creamy dressing, almonds and bacon work pea miracles! Thanks so much :)
I happen to fall into the “I love peas” category. Although not ever at 9 am! I am loving the yogurt dressing mixed with the peas and bacon. This sounds great!!!
haha I do really like peas I just tend to forget about them! But I feel like I wouldn’t forget about them with this recipe! Looks so good! And I love your photos!
Its the bacon…. Bacon makes EVERYTHING taste good. LOL! :) I don’t actually mind peas these days (wont order them in a restaurant or anything) but Ill eat them. As a kid, I avoided them like the plague, they fell into the green foods that taste awful category. This would work a treat as a side, beef daube maybe?!
I made this today…absolutely amazing. Will try with smoked paprika next time!
Sue, comments like this never ever fail to make my day! I am so glad. Thanks for taking time to share your review, and I am sure smoked paprika will be delicious too!
Is this regular or turkey bacon? I actually never had turkey bacon before, so am wondering if one or the other would be best with the peas or if it doesn’t matter :)
Great question! I use only regular bacon because honestly, I don’t care for the taste or texture of turkey bacon, and I feel the real-deal is worth the splurge. If it works better for your diet/tastes, however, you can certainly use turkey bacon instead.
I added 1/4 tsp of smoked paprika, a tad more regular salt on top of the kosher salt in the recipe (adjusted a little to taste), and I couldn’t help myself: about a heaping TSP of mayo (less than what most recipes require anyway!) and it was wonderful. The original recipe is great and I loved it but it was a smidgen too sweet with the baby peas and honey so that is why I made those adjustments and also to make my bf eat it (however, it says something because this man hates most veggies and ate a full serving of this!). Thanks for a great recipe! Unique taste and lovely texture, will make again.
I am so, so excited to hear this! I bet the addition of smoked paprika was absolutely fabulous too. Thank you so much for trying the recipe and for letting me know how it turned out!
I have always wondered what more can I do with peas that is exciting and creative. With almonds and bacon, this is a must-try recipe! Thank you for this!
Thank YOU Jinky. I hope you love it!
What is the nutritional value of a serving? Did I miss that somewhere?
Hi Lana! Regarding nutritional info, this is something that I’ve actually started adding to all of my new recipes, effective January 2016 (you’ll see it in the recipe box at the bottom). Unfortunately, it’s pretty time consuming, so I’m unable to go back and add it to past recipes. If you’d like the nutritional info for any of my older recipes (or really any other recipe or food), you can actually calculate it yourself for free at myfitnesspal.com (this is how I calculate the new recipes on my blog). I’m sorry I can’t give you the information for this exact recipe, but I hope that My Fitness Pal will be a helpful resource for you.
Could you substitute another nut or something else for the almonds?
Hi SandyG! I have not tried this recipe with anything other than almonds, so you would be experimenting. You could leave them out or try using pumpkin seeds (pepitas) or sunflower seeds but it will alter the flavor.
Terrific! The bacon is the perfect addition. Using fresh peas add just the right touch of crunch. I didn’t have 6 oz of fresh peas so i added an additional 4 oz of frozen. The difference between fresh and frozen is obvious. Next time I’ll make sure to use only fresh!
Hi Laurie! Thanks for the feedback and this kind review!
Made fora Women’s Club dinner. Was a hit!
Hi Catherine! So glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for this kind review!
I originally hit 3 stars by mistake instead of 5 stars. This salad sounds so good I can’t wait to make it. Both my husband and I love peas so this will be delicious I am sure. I wanted a recipe without mayo as we are eating healthier these days. Thank you for the recipe!
Hi Cindy! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!
I substituted Kefir and smoked maple syrup for the dressing. Fantastic! Thanks for sharing such a supreme recipe.
Hi Nora! So glad you enjoyed the recipe! Thank you for this kind review!